New NY State License Plate Revealed—And Required On All Cars
Access-A-Ride Renders Bike Lane Inaccessible
Cops: Fort Greene Violence Sparked By Chicken Wing Promotion
The UWS Gets Its Very Own Apple Store
64 Things Restaurant Patrons Must NEVER Do
Local screenwriter Aaron Schnore is suing midtown tourist trap Johnny Utah's after a May 7th ride on the tavern's mechanical bull (pictured) left him with "serious" injuries (beyond his shattered dignity). Lawyers say the operator of the bull should not have allowed an inebriated Schnore on the bull in the first place, and they also accuse him of making the bull buck too hard. Attorney Lawrence Saftler tells the Daily News, "[The operator] pumped it up until he could throw him. That to us is an assault and battery." To others, that's called a mechanical bull. Schnore is seeking an unspecified sum, but no amount of money will change the fact that now the whole world knows he hangs out at Johnny Utah's.
Lawsuit Says Mechanical Bull Too Rough for City Slicker
add to stumble upon
add to reddit
tweet this
post to facebookComments (30) [rss]
Post a comment (Comment Policy)
Tips
Newsmap
Contribute
Latest Tip:
Is Donald Trump broke? Sale of his VIP jet may indicate serious financial troubles for The Donald.
[more]
This is why we can't have nice, violent, things.
The news looks more and more like the Onion everyday.
i rode that bull & everyone only gets 30 seconds: when your time is up the operator does a spin/buck which always throws anyone off.
this guy is an idiot. he signed a release. suck it up.
what a d-bag.
I love this story's search Tags: lawsuit and mechanical bull!
Note to self
Don't do anything anymore anywhere
One who takes part in such a sport accepts the dangers that inhere in it so far as they are obvious and necessary:
http://www.audiocasefiles.com/acf_cases/8889-murphy-v-steeplechase-amusement-co-
I rode that bull, too, and lived to tell about it. Puss!
This is totally true. I went to a birthday party here two weeks ago and sprained my wrist. I've ridden mechanical bulls before and you will always get beat up and bruised, but the operator at Johnny Utah's is very reckless in how he operates this machine. For women, he shakes it back and forth like a sprinkler (to get the boobs shaking) then throws it forward so they are on their face hanging on for dear life then spins it around fast for a very long time until they are thrown off. I was waiting for someone to throw up! The men, they definitely make it very rough, almost vengefully violent as if trying to hurt them. When I rode I told the operator to operate it correctly and don't do that crap you're doing to other girls, he said you don't get to decide what ride you get. He did do a slightly better job with me even though I still got hurt. As I watched everyone else ride I kept saying someone is going to get hurt, he isn't operating this right and he's just being an ass about it. They aren't even trying to simulate a bull ride!
I rode at Mason Dixon last year and the operator was gentler on girls, made sure riders were not too drunk (the operator wasn't drinking either) and didn't actively try to hurt people. When you sign the waiver releasing them of fault, you have some expectation that they aren't going to actively try to hurt you.
signed.a.release
maevemealone - You're implying that the operator at this establishment was drinking.. is that correct?
This guy's name is really Schnore?
http://www.translationdirectory.com/dictionaries/dictionary004_s.htm
Yiddish:Schnorer: a begger, a moocher; a beggar who makes pretensions to respectability; a sponger, a parasite; a person who lives by begging or by sponging on others; a freeloader
maevemealone: if you were so concerned and felt that someone was going to get hurt, why did you sign a release and then ride?
That's what you get for drinking at Johnny Utah's. There are thousands of bars in the city, so why anyone would drink there is beyond me.
I actually know someone else who was thrown off the bull there a few months back, and ended up smacking their head on the railing (which supposedly had covers which mysteriously weren't present), and was taken out in an ambulance and received stitches and a concussion. They are in fact NOT suing because they feel it is their own fault basically.
The main point here is if you get drunk and ride a mechanical bull, you should probably expect to get hurt. NYC is way too insanely litigious to have something like a mechanical bull in your drinking establishment.
fugothamist wrote:
If he was very drunk, he's incapable of legally binding himself that way.Guess those spec scripts aren't getting picked up, eh Schnore?
10: yes, the operator of the ride was seen drinking at the bar several times that night.
11: I signed the paperwork before I saw anyone riding the bull, it was a quieter night so there wasn't a line to ride or anything. Before I rode, I only saw one girl ride. She got the shimmy shake sprinkler ride and didn't last long on it but I remarked that that isn't the way it should be operated, he's just trying to make girls boobs fall out. I rode and asked him to please operate it like a regular bull ride. He didn't do the sprinkler moves on me (I wasn't going to fall out of what I was wearing anyways). Everyone after me got very rough rides and I remarked that someone is going to get hurt. It's a hydraulic machine with a lot of power, he was maxing out the maneuvers the machine was capable of doing.
Look, everyone goes into that ride knowing they're going to get thrown and they'll probably come out sore and a bit bruised, but there is a responsibility of the establishment to operate the equipment properly so as to not cause UNDUE injuries. I wouldn't automatically assume this guy has no case just because he signed a waiver. The bull operator was a dick when I was there and I'm not surprised at all that someone is suing them this reason.
"If he was very drunk, he's incapable of legally binding himself that way.
True, but it's also illegal to serve alcohol to someone who's inebriated, so the bar's position would be that he wasn't that drunk.
I've always thought that the whole point of the mechanical bull was that they're supposed to do everything they can to throw you off -- like a real bull would. It's supposed to give you a taste of what that would be like. But I guess at NYC tourist bars it's supposed to be just an amusement park ride?
victim society 101. don't worry obama will make sure everyone gets paid on these spurious claims.
17: From my experience that night, they were not operating it to simulate an actual bull ride. That should be the point of it but that's not what I saw happening. I was not drinking much that night so I don't know if they ever turn people away for being drunk, other bars they do try to determine if you're safe to ride.
shimmy shake sprinkler ride.
heh.
13 nailed it.
The whole concept is stupid.
The safest way to operate it is probably for the boob flash, or replace it with a Sybian and make the crowd *and* rider happy.
What a bunch of whining wimps! If it as just a little carnival ride, you'd be complaining that it wasn't rough enough! What do you think happens in a REAL bull?
Its annoying that a mechanical bull ride even exists within NYC limits, but aaaaaanyway...
1. If you are trying to ride a actual wild animal and you get thrown off, gored, or trampled: Well, duh.
2. If you willingly sign up to get on a ride that simulates this, plus the operator is drunk and also behaving like a wild animal...well double DUH!
Once again, take responsibilty for your own actions!
3. Well I'm @ it, bullfighters get what they deserve as well. A ball-goring is getting off easy. It's not macho or glamorous. It's stupid and cruel.
Tell you what... you want a real fun ride? Wanna look good in front of your drunken friends? First, drink a whole lot. Yeah... almost to the point of puking. Take a walk over to 77 East 3rd St. There's a whole lot of motorcycles out front. Hop on one of them and start making loud "vroom, vroom" noises. Just do that for a few minutes and, believe me, you'll have a ride that you'll never forget!
having been there a few times myself..
1.. They do shake women for the shakey effect
2.. How hard you're thrown off depends on how hard you hold on. Everyone gets thrown (hydraulic bull will always win) so it ends up being the big guys who refuse to let go who end up effectively hurting themselves (bruised thighs, twisted wrists, smacking the outside padded wall, ...)
3. He rode on a Wednesday.. Monday's their fun night..
24!!!!!
OMG! I totally went to college with this guy (but have since fallen out of touch)...hilarious!
Another douche makes the news.
This guy is a good guy and a good writer. I rode the bull directly before him and Aaron is extremely credible. I was right there, and people who have snarky things to say about this, you are the big D. He is a great person and he did nothing wrong.
At least if he gets drunk and rides the Acela train, there's overhead wires to hang onto.