Some New Yorkers leave the city for our reasonably-priced neighbor, New Jersey, others leave to start farms, and now NYMag reports that some are leaving for Buffalo, NY. One couple (and there's more than one!) in their 30s recently left their 1.5 bdrm Sunset Park apartment (and $1300/month rent) for the greener pastures of the upstate city, where they enjoy their new rent of $795/month. Just what does one get for that price? Three-bedrooms, living room, dining room, basement, a front and back porch, stained-glass windows, and a separate office...on a tree lined street...400 miles away from what used to be their city of dreams. One of the Buffalonians had this to say, “I don’t miss my old life in New York. I only miss the life in New York I know I never would have had.” Sad, really, but if you too have dreams of stained glass windows...there's plenty available.





$795/month and hundreds if not thousands more in gas, car insurance and oil heaters. i'll stick it out here where there's decent mass transit, oil's included in my rent and i do not have to deal wth a car.
"hundreds if not thousands more in gas, car insurance and oil heaters"
So...you break even 3-5 months...the rest is PROFIT!
But, aside from work you can do from home (consulting, etc), I'd guess jobs might pay less, since the cost of living is less.
I just think it would be cold!
"...I'll go home and get my panties
You go home and get your scanties
And away we'll go
Mmm-mmm-mmm
Off we're gonna shuffle
Shuffle off to Buffalo"
looks like most of them are either artist/creative types who can work at home. one person was from buffalo so she basically went back home.
the major industry in the buffalo area are collection agencies. there's no jobs there.
Albany winters were depressing enough for me.
Once you get older and married and want to have kids it make more sense to finally own a house and have a car to take trips.
Getting back to the article why didn't they buy a house? If your going to leave NYC you'd think they would want to own something and stop paying rent.
yeah, it's good for now. But wait til the Niagara winters bite their asses. I once went to a party in Buffalo, My friend lost the keys to his house. we were left stranded outside for 20 minutes! My animal instincts kicked in and I wanted to dig a hole into the earth and crawl into it. It's fucking cold up there.
Buffalo is the most depressing city in the eastern US besides Pittsburgh, there's a reason why it's cheap: rednecks and miserable winters.
I lived in Buffalo for over 10 years. I used to say, while I was there, I hated Buffalo, but now that I'm living in NYC I kinda miss it. Buffalo does have its charms.
If the couple misses the excitement of NYC, there's always Toronto which is only an hour away from the border.
Lived there for three years, if you can call it living. There are nice things about it, and it might be right for people who don't need much in the way of culture or local industry.
Best of luck to them. I'm never going back.
Steven, I agree entirely. Having just had our first child, we're looking to own and simply can't do it here. (Well, we could buy a 500 square foot apartment in a decent neighborhood or a shithole for that in a dangerous one.)
Not sure where we'll end up— definitely won't be Buffalo—but we (like thousands of other middle class families) can't afford to buy a place here. Who is? Europeans? The dollars is terrible right now, are folks coming from overseas and buying up these condos and whatnot? It's confusing.
Also, while Jersey is more affordable than here, the property taxes will kick you in your sphincter.
I think Jeffersonville is looking quite appealing. :]
Or Pittsburgh.
Also, "trend?" They found half a dozen people who've moved there. Throw a dart at a map of the US and you'll hit another place where at least as many people have recently moved from NYC.
errrr (Well, we could buy a 500 square foot apartment in a decent neighborhood or a shithole for that in a dangerous one.) Should read:
(Well, we could buy a 500 square foot apartment for 650,000 in a decent neighborhood or a shithole for that in a dangerous one.)
"To commit suicide in Buffalo is redundant."
See ya, wouldn't wanna be ya!
Buffalo/Rochester sucks.
Buffalo aint so bad if you like the buttfucking cold weather and ridiculous snowfall amounts.
Yes your rent would be cheaper, but having your house collapse under several feet of ice and snow would probably cause your insurance premiums to rise.
If you can't afford New York and hate Jersey, you have *48* other states to choose from!
Philly
Charlotte
Atlanta
Chicago
Austin
Portland
Denver (or Boulder)
Any of the smaller towns/cities in Cali.
You have ALL of these and more and people choose freaking Buffalo?
Being an hour away from Toronto is about theonly plus
Buffalo gets way too much snow
It is VERY cold in Buffalo.
The city of Buffalo is really beautiful, with some amazing houses. The suburbs are pretty lame, and I'm guessing that's where all the haters who claim to have lived there were. I'm sure going to UB and living in a dorm outside of the city really sucks.
Not a lot of jobs, but if you're a creative type who works for yourself it's a nice cheap place to live well and start a family.
I was born and raised in Buffalo and lived there until I moved to Brooklyn in November.
It is only cold in the winter. It's right next to lake Erie, hence the wind and lake effect snow. But Spring and Summer in Buffalo are gorgeous.
Buffalo has some amazing food which is saying a lot, considering NYC is essentially the food capital of the world. I'm not saying it's better there, just that it's good. Buffalo has Mighty Taco, which is better than any tacos or burritos I have or will ever eat in my life.
It has some perks, no doubt. But I stand by my word that it's still a garbage dump. Economy has been dying for years, people are miserable (but then, many here are miserable). Plenty of good schools in Buffalo, plenty of jobs (more than you'd think).
As far as I know, the crime rate in Buffalo is worse than NYC though I'm sure the difference in population factors into that.
I go back to Buffalo to visit family, but never will I live there again. If you're going to move out of NYC, do yourself a favor and move out of New York State in total.
Not sure why all (or most of you) are hating on Buffalo.
A few points:
1. Other cities actually get more snow than us and Buffalo is so used to dealing with snow, that it's rare for a storm to shut down the city..or collapse a roof.
2. I have been more cold these past few winters in NYC than in any of my winters in Buffalo, because I'm not walking around in it there.
Those are minor issues I have with everyone freaking out about snow. At least Buffalo isn't going to be washed away in a tsunami at some point or destroyed by some random "inactive" fault lines. There are many worse acts of nature.
What upsets me about reading these comments: **Lived there for three years, if you can call it living. There are nice things about it, and it might be right for people who don't need much in the way of culture or local industry.**
is the attitude ingrained in many New Yorkers and adopted by transplants, that people who choose to live somewhere else are settling for uncultured, pathetic lives that they must be dying to get out of. This isn't at all true, and I completely agree with the quote in the article, that New Yorkers are obsessed with the NY ideal and aren't living it. There are cultural experiences to be had in every city and it's a rare New Yorker I know who spends all of their free time becoming more cultured. There are many things to love (and hate) about NYC..or every city for that matter..and I'm sick of the "cultured" excuse.
Even if they offered me free rent...
I think Buffalo is going to be where a lot of good music comes out of over the next 10 years
like the Goo Goo dolls.
They have buffalo wings.
Regardless of whether or not Buffalo is a good place to move (went to college in Central NY, so I'm biased), it's tough to move from the center of social activity to a city that's suburban by comparison. I'm not NYC's biggest fan, but I could never move from here to a "small" city.
Buffalo is waking up. A few years ago, if someone there saw a gorgeous but tattered old Victorian, they'd say, "knock it down". Today, the city is slowly reviving. It's still early days there and anyone from NYC would have to squint hard to see it, but it's happening. Houses still go for $60,000 there and the people are generally very friendly. Buffalo is a place where you endure the snowy winters ( and incredible summers ) to build something, not enjoy what's ready made for you.
Many commenters have noted that it's the "artist types" that are moving to Buffalo; but then go on to say how devoid of culture Buffalo is. If NYC is losing its artists to other cities (including Buffalo), where will its culture come from? Washington Mutual? Bank of America? Capital One?
they said that about Pittsburgh and their andy warhol museum. only you got damn humid summers there along with the cold.
im sorry i've been traveling to buffalo pretty frequently for work, and it's still a total dump. even the downtown area is totally gutted. travel down main street (where the tram runs) and you'll see how many empty or abandoned buildings there are in the so called business district.
the only half decent neighborhood i would consider is Amherst.
i can't complain about their airport though, so small, never any delays!
"They have buffalo wings."
There is no such thing as a buffalo wing. Buffalo and bison do not have wings. They are chicken wings. But you are correct. Nowhere else in the world can you get chicken wings as good as in Buffalo. Except Bonnie's in Park Slope, but the place was opened by someone from Buffalo.
As for music coming out of Buffalo - It's not just the next ten years as it has been happening for a long time. The Goo Goo Dolls made it big (regardless that I hate them), Ani DiFranco is huge and has a label and recording studio based in Buffalo.
Numerous hardcore and metal bands have sprouted from Buffalo - Cannibal Corpse, Every Time I Die, It Dies Today (noticing a trend here?), Snapcase, Green Jelly, and other bands and musicians like Cute Is What We Aim for (hold up, I need to chew back the vomit....ok I think I'm all right...), Spyro Gyra, and RICK JAMES. Music has been, is, and always will be enormous in Buffalo.
I did my four years in Amherst and if you're going to live in Buffalo be prepared for it to snow every single day from Mid-October to late March. Sometimes for only five minutes a day, but every day for around five months, and sometimes 12 inches a day for several days in a row. The news reports up there barely even mention any snow less than 8 inches. The most I saw was around 36 inches at once, and yes, the city did shut down for a week. At that point in my life I didn't mind, but I didn't have to shovel either.
Amherst on the other hand is the safest city in America for several years running. Duff's has the best wings in the world. Wegman's is a great supermarket. Canada's a short drive away. People are nice and you can still go to a Bills game without owning season tickets. Just realize that you're moving to suburbia, unless you're going to the depressed city center.
MIGHTYYY TACOOO
MIGHTYYY TACOOO
MIGHTYYY TACOOO
yeah, buffalo is awesome.
I grew up in Syracuse and Ithaca and I think the two are much more interesting places than Buffalo (and MUCH closer to New York at that). They are both ass cold and snowy in the winter and the crime in Syracuse is high and the economy low, but the rent is cheap, there are a lot of interesting people (especially in Ithaca), a fairly vibrant arts and music scene and the scenery is beautiful. All that being said, would I move back? Ithaca: maybe someday, if a job brought me there. Syracuse: I've had enough.
Syracuse? Seriously? I only had to spend 24 hours there to realize that it's the most depressing city I've ever been to. The other contenders include Cleveland, Pittsburgh, Detroit, Buffalo, Rochester...no contest, Syracuse, even with the college, is one sad city.
Buffalo's wings aren't all that. Their music "scene" consists of hardcore and (it's over already!) nu-metal with a dash of hippie from the university. The houses are cheap but you'll be one of only two occupants on your block. The rabid Sabres fans are lame and Bills fans still constantly talk about Flutie.
Dear Rest of New York,
You blow.
Sincerely,
Jibbly
P.S.
Keep Rochester around for the occasional Trash/Garbage Plate feast. Give the rest of Niagra Falls to Canada; their side is better anyway.
Anyone who only knows Main street and Amherst doesn't get it. Go through the Victorian Houses on the west side, go through Elmwood, get a drink downtown. Odds are, if you're a lame person you'll have a bad time in whatever city you're in. I love New York, and I love Buffalo. They're insanely different, but it's hard to knock what's special about Buffalo, it has something New York lost a while ago; easier living for artist.
I went to school there. There were two things missing that would keep me from going back:
1. Way too flat. It's just depressing to live in such a flat area.
2. The school is not IN the city. NYU, Baruch, Columbia, Hunter, for all their shortcomings breathe life and youth into the city and it's something that Buffalo severely lacks. Everyone is suffocating from depression in the city and the only airhole is 30 minutes away in Amherst.
More like Bust a Flow.
I did part of my residency there. It wasn't bad. Yet, I think most of the small cities upstate leave a lot to be desired.
I think it's funny when people start saying terrible things about the cities in upstate, new york, especially when they only recently arrived in New York City from some piece of S town in the midwest. What a perfect way to express ignorance!
I love upstate new york. With the exception of Albany, I would not want to live in a major city there. I would rather live out in the country, perhaps around the Finger Lakes, a remote area in the Catskills, or the Adirondacks.
I'm just guy who grew up in Brooklyn and Long Island and I know that Upstate is great. However its small cities will suck the life out of you. I spent five years going to school in the foothills of the Adirondacks and then Buffalo. It was amazing and if I had the chance to go back and live, I would. But I'm talking about Buffalo. Upstate's small cities leave much to be desired.
Have any of you been to Utica? I'm sure it would give you yuppies nightmares. The one thing about Utica is that it does have exceptional Italian food. It's the Bensonhurst of Upstate.
Any body remember Love canal?
39: Utica is bad, but Elmira is the worst!
New York in the 70s... New York in the 70s....
The hot wings from Duffs are good, but my favorite are the Honey Mustard from Elmos.
Yonkers people
Yonkers
I live the dream in Yonkers
Buffalo lost half of its jobs and population during the last forty years. The city went through a lot of difficult changes as it downsized and adjusted to its new reality. There are a lot of people trying to rebuild Buffalo. They do not need your snarky criticism.
Too cold? Hardly. Please leave if you can't deal with it. Don't come back.
Like Amherst? The only place you like is a faceless bland suburb. How sad is that?
I feel sorry for the above commenters who "did their time in Amherst".Most people in Buffalo consider putting SUNY out in the 'burbs a huge mistake. Many want that campus moved into the city. Not going to happen, but a lot of other schools are building in Downtown Buffalo. As the city revives, more announcements have streamed in. In thirty year's time, Buffalo will be a very different place. it may be smaller, but it is going to be much better.
I'm here for school, but leaving in a few mths, and I can't wait to finally leave this rotten, mediocre, imbecile-laden town. Didn't zumba pants originate from here too? That's all the locals ever do is spend their time defending Buffalo; & they hate you if you suggest anything that's not Buffalo-ish. Buffalo is a black hole that tries to lure & suck people in, having them drown in the worst depression imaginable. I agree with the quote:
"To commit suicide in Buffalo is redundant." UB sucks too-- It's in the middle of nowhere, the student population is either redneck locals or from new jersey (who are all obsessed with ugg boots), and pretentious graduate students makeup for more than half of the undergraduate teaching, gypping [serious] students of their education.
The only good thing that ever came out of Buffalo is Vincent Gallo, and I', pretty sure he hates Buffalo too.
I will also add that Buffalo locals don't recognize talent, class, & radicalism by failing to recognize all these qualities in Gallo. I guess he's too "elitist" for them; which sounds similar to a present political division.
All of you that hate Buffalo, have know idea what you are talking about. First off where is the "redneck" thing coming from. Who knows the definition of a redneck: Redneck refers to a stereotype of usually rural, Caucasian (i.e. white) people of lower socio-economic status in the United States and Canada. Originally limited to the Appalachians, and later the South, the Ozarks, the Great Plains and the Rocky Mountains, this stereotype is now widespread throughout North America.
Hmm... now lets look at that, rural, yeah uhm pretty sure Buffalo is the 2nd largest city in New York state and the 46th largest in the country... "lower socio-economic status" yeah again nothing to do with Buffalo. Ever here of Roswell Park Cancer Institute look it up, oh and I guess all those companies that have corporate operations out of Buffalo don't see any reason to stay.
Why does everyone think there is no jobs in Buffalo? So you are telling me that all the waterfront renovations that have been completed and the many more to come don't need employees (and before someone says something stupid they are already aproved and funded). Or the 125 schools (that is just buffalo not the burbs) don't need teachers and staff, the medical researches don't need scientics and doctors.
Snow, are you serious? I would rather deal with snow then a hurricane, eathquake, tornado whatever mother nature can throw. Snow is the worst we get... next time one of you are in Buffalo on vacation a business trip in the winter and it snowed over night go to one of the many parks in buffalo and tell me it isnt beautiful.
If you can not find something to do in Buffalo you aren't looking. There are over 50 art galleries/museums, parks everywhere, great food. Buffalo has pro teams in the NFL, NHL, NLL, IL. Professional golf courses. Skiing snowboarding, fishing, ice skating, concerts, broadway shows (yes, broadway not copies).
So if Buffalo is so horrible why does Men's Health rank it #39 to raise a family, maybe because City Honors School is ranked 11th in the nation, maybe it is all the things to do. AmericanStyle magazine ranked Buffalo number one on its list of Top 25 Arts Destinations. The Buffalo Niagara region has been ranked by a national health care information company as the nation’s best market for the value of hospital care.
So you tell me Buffalo is going down the drain, there is no jobs, uncultured, and has way to much snow and I will tell you, sir you are a moron. And if you still hate Buffalo then don't go there, it will keep Buffalo a happier place.
I lived in Buffalo my entire life, until I turned 18 and do you know why that is? Because I joined the USMC. I have been a lot of places, seen a lot of countries. There is know where like Buffalo. I get out in less then a year, I have already bought my 2500 sq.ft. home in a great neighborhood and am paying 1/3 of what you are paying for your one room studio. But don't worry I will keep protecting my country for the next several months so all of you can talk shit about a city that you have no clue about.
Oh Buffalo...
I can totally understand why an older couple would want to move to the suburbs of Buffalo. I was born and raised in there. A week after my 21'st Bday I moved to California thinking there is so much I must be missing out on, but all I found was better weather. Buffalonians are incredibly genuine people! NY in general just seems to be filled with more sincere people.
Point being, it's not just the food, cheap rent or great music scene, it's the people.