Did They Ever Play Polo at the Polo Grounds?

Yes and no.

The name “Polo Grounds” was originally just a generic name describing the function of the place – grounds where polo was played – and got transmogrified into a proper name. Like another Manhattan sports venue, Madison Square Garden, it was the name for several different structures, but it was only the first where polo was actually played.

The original Polo Grounds, located across from Central Park on 110th Street between 5th and Lennox Avenues was built for polo in 1876. In 1880 it was converted into a baseball stadium for the New York Metropolitans (or Mets, no relation to the current Mets), an independent professional team founded by and former baseball player Jim Mutrie backed by tobacco magnate John B. Day and August Belmont (who would later finance the IRT subway). The team joined the American Association in 1883 the same year the ownership fielded a National League team known as the New York Gothams, which would change their name two years later to the Giants. The Giants outlasted the Mets, which got sold and moved to Staten Island in 1886 only lasting a year there before being bought out for the territorial rights by the Brooklyn Dodgers after the 1887 season.

After being evicted by the city in 1889 – a season split playing in Staten Island and Jersey City, the Giants moved in 1890 to 155th Street and Eighth Avenue (now Fredrick Douglas Boulevard). Two ballparks were on the site, the larger Brotherhood Park home to a Player’s League team and the Giants new smaller park which they named the Polo Grounds. After the Players League folded in 1891, the Giants moved into the larger park and renamed it to the Polo Grounds.

It was at this iconic Coogan's Bluff location that got seared into the collective New York baseball memory in the two stadiums that followed on the site. The first being an expanded version of the old stadium, the second was a new concrete stadium built after a 1911 fire.

Like the two previous incarnations, neither ever saw a polo match, but instead saw boxing, professional and college football, galeic football and soccer. The ballpark was also home of the Yankees from 1913 to 1922. Probably the most famous moments at the final Polo Grounds were Bobby Thompson’s “Shot heard round the world” in 1951 and “The Catch” by Willie Mays in game one of the 1954 World Series.

The final incarnation stadium was also home for the football Giants from 1925 to 1955 and the Titans, later renamed the Jets, from 1960 until 1963. The Titans were the only tenant after the Giants decamped to the west coast in 1957 until the Mets came into the National League in 1962. The Mets and Jets moved into the new Shea Stadium in 1964.

The stadium was torn down in 1964 and the site met the same fate as the Dodgers’ Ebbets Field – a public housing complex the Polo Grounds Towers. All that remains other than a plaque marking the location of home plate is the John T. Brush Stairway (named after the teams owner) which was built in 1913 to have fans access the ballpark from below. The stairway still exists, but is in a decrepit state and may get restored as part of renovations to Highbridge Park.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

By Toby von Meistersinger in News on July 21, 2008 2:05 PM

Comments [rss]

66kicks

The Mets home opener in 1962 was more likely April 13, which was a Friday, than March 13, which would have been in the middle of Spring Training.

sherone

Many people think of polo as elitist, expensive and inaccessible. Not necessarily so. With some gay-friendly support from the Santa Barbara Polo Club and the California Polo Club, our lavender league got started on a shoestring. One Club member told me he had never ridden a horse till a year ago. Others showed me the mechanical horse with a polo saddle, where a rookie can learn how to handle the mallet while being galloped and jolted this way and that.

Outter Burrougher

was reading an article that referenced the Polo Grounds just now and thought of this article; can we have more stories like it, please?

spiritross

T-I-T-A-N-S

TITANS TITANS TITANS!!

I must say the fact that the stairway is in that condition in the first place is an insult to all the history of the Polo Grounds.

Toby von Meistersinger

Actually, Bobby Thompson was born in Glasgow.

blablanyc

BTW Bobby Thompson is a Staten Island native.

Toby von Meistersinger

Kevin Walsh - I was just going by what the caption at the source said.

I actually had the pleasure of meeting both Bobby Thompson and Ralph Branca at Carnegie Hall of all places where the two of them were giving a talk about baseball along with the performance of baseball related music about ten, twelve years ago.

MaiaW

Thanks for the article! BTW, if anyone is interested, there is a New York Baseball Giants Nostalgia Society group, which likes to discuss this kind of stuff: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/nybgns/

Kevin Walsh

>>>Bobby Thompson and the Giants return, June 1, 1962

Unless Thomson was coaching with the Jints in 1962, he wasn't with them then. He was traded to Milwaukee in 1954 and retired in 1960....

www.forgotten-ny.com

blablanyc

Thankfully Manhattan will never have another large stadium like this.

DFHdez

there is a picture of the Brush Stairway here

http://www.flickr.com/photos/dfhdez/1404755912/

S.D.

Nice, that's a great article.

matty

"That paragraph is correct, it just needs clarification. The second mention of Giants is the baseball Giants."

ah, my bad.

Outter Burrougher

Gaelic football? Awesome! Best sport.

And great post

Politburo

That paragraph is correct, it just needs clarification. The second mention of Giants is the baseball Giants.

theevilone

This was a great read - thanks!

matty

Interesting article though!

matty

"The final incarnation stadium was also home for the football Giants from 1925 to 1955 and the Titans, later renamed the Jets, from 1960 until 1963. The Titans were the only tenant after the Giants decamped to the west coast in 1957 until the Mets came into the National League in 1962. The Mets and Jets moved into the new Shea Stadium in 1964."

I think you're confusing the Ny Giants (baseball) with the Ny Giants (football). The NY Giants (football) are still in New York - Ahem - New Jersey.