Staten Island Man Mauled by Pit Bulls Loses Leg

2008_07_pitbullattack.jpgThe 90-year-old man mauled by a neighbor's pit bulls yesterday morning had his left leg amputated. Henry Piotrowski's niece said he will probably lose one of his arms.

The dogs belonged to James McNair, a registered sex offender, who was charged with, per the Staten Island Advance, "having unlicensed dogs, not having his dogs on a leash and fireworks possession." Neighbors say that they have called 311 and the police repeatedly about the pit bulls, which were tranquilized and later euthanized yesterday afternoon. The Daily News reports police say by the time they would arrive, the dogs would be gone, and "said loose dogs were an ASPCA matter."

Neighbor Reginald Bell who helped chase the dogs from Piotrowski's lawn was in shock over the attack, "It was horrible. I could not believe these dogs were eating this man like lions on a gazelle. This is not Zimbabwe. They were eating this man alive...There was nothing but bone, blood and cartilage." Piotrowski's niece Elaine Sutton said she "couldn't even distinguish" her WWII veteran uncle's face but remained hopeful, noting he "is a tough guy, so if anyone is going to survive something like this it's gonna be Uncle Hank."

Email This Entry


Comments (15) [rss]

My dyslexia is getting worse... I totally read that as "Staten Island Man Loses Leg and Face".

Or that he had his face amputated. Something like that.

Either way, ouch.

The sex offender owner should be drawn and quartered!! His genitals should be fed to the dogs!!! Bastard! The poor man survives WWII but has to get attacked in his own back yard!! Appalling!!

user-pic

the owner of this dog should be charged with attempted murder.

I hate Pit Bulls. There is no need for them except to satisfy the macho yearnings of the socially and economically impotent. "I have no job, no prospects, no women, but I have two pit bulls, so you better respect me".

The owner of these dogs should be thrown in jail for life.

"The dogs belonged to James McNair, a registered sex offender"

Fantastic. This guy is a really terrific member of society. It just gets better and better.

Pit Bulls do not have to be mean, there are people who own them who love them and take good care of them. But these dog-thug a-holes have to go.

So sad they had to kill the dogs. They should have them had a go on their owner...

Someone should check the dogs for sexual abuse.

Pits are not bad dogs. Unfortunately thugs like this dickwad are attracted to them and raise them to be vicious, just like they raise their kids (who ultimately commit crimes).

I'm a middle-upper class white woman professional and I've got a pitmix who I rescued and have raised since she's a puppy. She wouldn't eat an old man, she's afraid of our cat. It's all about the way they're raised.

"In 2002, [James] McNair and two other men were accused of raping and sodomizing a 14-year-old girl in the schoolyard of PS 19. McNair served about a year and a half in jail."

McNair is a complete waste of space on this planet.

McNair is a level 2 sex offender, which means moderate risk of re-offense. It's no surprise that he doesn't care about the law. I've had to deal with another level 2 in the past. He's a liar, a thief, and just an overall selfish bastard that I wouldn't trust with $5. According to the sex offenders registry, McNair's address was under investigation, so he may not have notified the authorities the last time he moved as he is required by law for the rest of his life. Again, no surprise. If it were up to me, level 2 and 3 sex offenders would be sent off to some maximum security island somewhere so they could never endanger society again.

Wow, a whole year and a half of time served for the rape and sodomy of a 14 year old? Too bad the dogs attacked an innocent man and not their owner. Sounds like that jackass owner deserved to have a few of his limbs gnawed off painfully.

just like I said, people who own pits are mostly psychos, ms frijole! can you really believe you wrote that?

Don't make stupid generalizations, cucarachita.

Yes, I can believe I wrote that. What's the matter? The truth hurts? Who do you think is committing crimes in this city? Take a look at Gothamist maps -- where are the shootings and stabbings? The middle class white neighborhoods?

I'm a criminal defense lawyer, I think I know a thing or two about thugs. I represent them in court all day long.

Responsible dog owners don't let their dogs roam off leash and don't train them to be vicious. But irresponsible dog owners tend to be irresponsible in other parts of their life as well, whether it's criminal behavior or just the sheer incapacity to be a productive member of society -- a cycle that perpetuates from generation to generation. Break the cycle and build a better community instead of denying that this shit happens.

I'm amazed that the victim is still alive. What an incredible trauma for anyone that age. The sex-offender needs to go to prison for the rest of his life. They gave him a chance and look what happened. No more chances.

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

Get your daily dose of New York first thing in the morning from our weekday newsletter, now in beta.

About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung
Publisher: Jake Dobkin

Newsmap

newsmap.jpg

Contribute

Latest Tip:

The Evolution of the Hipster: from 2000 to 2009
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS

Follow us