Quantcast

Faking New York, CSI:NY-Style

Television is coming back to life, with several shows (mainly on CBS) returning to the air this week with post-writers strike episodes. Amongst them, the comically inaccurate CSI: NY returns (Wednesday, 10:00 p.m., WCBS 2), with an investigation of a dead assassin found in a warehouse, no doubt filmed in someplace like Culver City.

While it does shoot some scenes here, CSI:NY mostly films on a studio back lot or in downtown LA. Since it tends to be completely ridiculous, CSI:NY's only merit might be in how absurd they can get with faking things. One of the best--or worst?--examples is this scene (video, above) of the Times Square subway station. It includes a painfully obvious fake set (complete with a black-on-yellow 3 train and red MTA logo), stock footage, scenes from the Money Train, and some filming in a Los Angeles Metro tunnel. This is what makes CSI:NY one of the funniest shows on television. Wait, isn't it supposed to be a drama?

2008_03_newamster.jpgIf you want a show about the NYPD that films here and only engages in the forgivable crime of passing one IRT station off as another, you should be watching New Amsterdam (Monday, 9:00 p.m., WNYW 5). This mid-season replacement (sort of Angel meets Law & Order: CI) is one of the better shows on TV now.

And finally, a show where nobody is pretending to be New York--Battlestar Galactica (Friday, 10:00 p.m., Sci Fi). The sci-fi show begins its fourth and final season and finally exorcises memories of the camp Lorne Greene version.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • FromtheFuture

    Also, they had to *pay* to go through the turnstiles to a crime scene? Someone couldn't have propped open the gate?

  • MT

    I'm sure everyone sees 'Battlestar Galactica' and immediately rolls their eyes, but that show is AMAZING! It's smart, well written and very relevant and tackles current issues surprisingly cleverly. It's thought-provoking but never preachy. It's worth checking out if you can get past your Sci Fi phobia.

  • jchez

    Wow! Thanks for giving me the word I was looking for to describe NY-CSI, "comically-inaccurate".

    I'm sure that Miamians must also look at the super modern Miami-CSI headquarters and say 'Whattt?". Just look at A&E (The Arrests and Examinations) Network to see how Miami detectives really do their work.

  • generalerin

    All I know is that is a GIANT subway car.

  • EricGewiz

    Doesn't that look like the subway car from Die Hard 3?

  • chuzzlewit

    television - forestalling the finger from the socket since 1932.

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com