Rescue Effort Continues After Fatal Crane Collapse

2008_03_crane8.jpg
Rescue workers search for survivors at the 305 East 50th Street by Toykin Chin/AP; lower photograph by chucknyc88 on Flickr

After a 19-story construction crane collapsed in Turtle Bay and fell towards other buildings, firefighters and other rescue workers are searching for survivors in the rubble. At least four people - all construction workers, Brad Cohen, Aaron Stephens, Anthony Mazza and Wayne Binder - are dead and many more are injured. It's believed two or three more people are missing, possibly buried under the debris. Mayor Bloomberg called "one of the worst construction accidents" in the history of the city.

Around 2:22 p.m. yesterday, construction workers at 303 East 51st Street, where a 40+ floor building is planned, were trying to lift the crane to another floor. The crane broke apart, its lower part (the boom), falling and hitting 300 East 51th Street across the street, while its upper part, the jib and operator's cabin, continue to fall south, completely destroying 305 East 50th Street and hitting other buildings on East 50th and the rear of a Second Avenue building. Here's the Department of Buildings' explanation so far:

A preliminary investigation indicates the accident occurred while workers were adding tower sections to extend the crane upwards, an operation known as “jumping” the crane. While crews were jumping the crane to the 18th floor, a heavy-duty steel collar, which wrapped around the mast of the crane and used to tie the crane to the side of the building, fell as workers attempted to install it. When the steel collar fell, it damaged a lower steel collar, installed at the 9th floor. The collar installed at the 9th floor served as a major anchor securing the tower crane to the building under construction. With the elimination of the support provided by the steel collar at the 9th floor, the counter-weights at the top of the crane’s tower caused the entire structure to fall southward.
According to the contracting company owner Stephen Kaplan, a piece of steel fell, cutting one of the ties securing the crane to the building, "It was an absolute freak accident. All the piece of steel had to do was fall slightly left or right, and nothing would have happened."

2008_03_crane11.jpgThe number of injured is so far reported to be 24 people, and it's shocking not more were, given yesterday's fine weather and people eager to celebrate St. Patrick's Day early in the mostly residential neighborhood with many bars. Residents described hearing a loud noise (some called it a boom, another said it was "one minute of metal scraping against itself and it gave people a chance to run"), feeling their buildings shake, and, later, seeing a plume of dust from the collapse.

A woman who lives in 301 East 50th, the building next to the crushed four-story townhouse, told the Daily News, "I was in the shower, 10 feet from where the crane came down. When it came down, I was thrown into the wall." Edith Rompilla, who lives at 311 East 50th Street, told the Times she saw the whole thing as she listened to opera, "I looked out the window and I saw the crane coming...I saw bricks flying toward me, and I thought they were going to come right through my window.”

Kerry Walker, who lives on the top floor of now-completely leveled 305 East 50th Street, said to the News, "The whole thing is pancaked, everything, all the way down to the basement." His wife missed the crane because she had gone out to buy aspirin. And one victim, John Gallego, caught under the rubble, called his girlfriend on his cellphone, "I'm hurt! I'm trapped! Call 911!" and was rescued.

2008_03_cranediagram.jpg
Diagram from the Daily News

The NY Times has an interactive showing the sequence of the collapse (there a good explanation of the crane, too), but the Daily News has an excellent 3D diagram showing path.

2008_03_crane12.jpgThe Buildings Department had inspected the crane earlier and noted the operators had the proper permit to conduct the work on Saturday, but had issued a partial stop-work order because of a different issue (concrete mold work).

Still, residents and local officials point to a number of complaints and concerns about the building and its construction. A resident and former building contractor, Bruce Silberblatt, said the Buildings Department paid no heed to warnings, including one he made on March 4 about his worries that the crane wasn't properly secured. "Now, I'm sitting here and, at last count, four people are dead and a couple buildings on 50th St. are completely wrecked. ... It looks like Baghdad over there."

The DOB inspected the site and found no issues. However the inspector who did the paperwork claims he never inspected the crane that day. Silberblatt also thinks Kaplan's "freak accident" claim ridiculous, "A piece of steel has no business falling off a building, period. Had there been another set of braces there where they should've been, this wouldn't have happened."

2008_03_brace.jpg
Photograph above of the crane's boom leaning against 300 East 51st Street by gattogrosso on Flickr; above image from the Buildings Department website of Silberblatt's complaint

A number of buildings were evacuated and Red Cross set up shelter at a local high school. Now officials are trying to figure out how to remove the crane's boom, which is leaning on 300 East 50th Street, without disturbing the building and causing more damage. Several streets remain closed and bus routes diverted for emergency operations.

Email This Entry

Comments (7) [rss]

what a retard! "It was an absolute freak accident. All the piece of steel had to do was fall slightly left or right, and nothing would have happened." that's like a criminal saying "It was an absolute freak accident. All the bullet had to do was fall slightly left or right, and the cop wouldn't have died."

"'As it went higher and higher, I got more and more concerned because I didn't see any more braces installed,' Silberblatt told the Daily News.

"So he called the Buildings Department and lodged a complaint."

. . . .

"The department sent an inspector to the site later that day, records show.

"Two days later, the agency ruled that no violations were warranted.

"'Crane is erected according to approved' code, reads a note on the Buildings Department Web site.

"The inspector listed on the paperwork is Edward Marquette. Reached by The News at his Manhattan home, Marquette denied inspecting the crane that day, saying he had been to the site only once, earlier in the project."

Huh. Interesting.

For what it's worth: thank you, Bruce Silberblatt, for at least *trying* to get city officials to properly do their job of protecting the public.

wow, that complaint is pretty damning.

The real estate and construction industries have sort of a free pass in the city. Sidewalk sheds or overhead bridgework are part of the landscape on most blocks in Manhattan and remain in place for years. Is there corruption? It's a pretty good bet. The real estate families operate without fear that the Building Department is going to bother them much. Mayor Bloomberg knew how to handle the Bd of Ed and teachers union by taking control of the schools away from an entrenched bureaucracy . He should try to do something in the building area as well. A new department staffed by knowledgeable and caring people that won't let construction continue until a violation is cleared. A builder, with connections to the Building Dept or any other inspection unit, that knows the ropes, can get away with almost anything. Is there corruption? You tell me. 4 people are dead many others injured seriously and let's see who, if anybody, other than the victims pay a price.

I'm surprised none of the nutroots have blamed this on President Bush... He was in town the day before and could have been looking to take down another building. :rolleyes:

Actually the news when he came to town was Bear Stearns asking for welfare money.

@glennQNYC: Absolutely! Everyone knows that George Bushs' lizard man soul gives off a magnetic field that disrupts the molecular makeup of steel. This clearly caused the collapse.

One of my co-workers has been bugging me to go to Fubar for the last two months, now I don't have to make up excuses anymore.

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

Get your daily dose of New York first thing in the morning from our weekday newsletter, now in beta.

About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung
Publisher: Jake Dobkin

Newsmap

newsmap.jpg

Contribute

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS