Got a Tip?
tips at gothamist
About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung Publisher: Jake Dobkin

About Us & Advertising | Archives | Contact | Mobile | RSS | Staff

Favorites
Newsmap
Contribute

Latest tip:

2 people were hit by a car outside of enid's in greenpoint last night. does anyone have any more [more]

 

Latest link:

 

Latest Photo:

 

Subscribe
Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS

February 26, 2008

New York Philharmonic Concludes North Korean Concert

022608North%20KoreaPhilharmonic2.jpgPhotos: AP/David Guttenfelder

The New York Philharmonic Orchestra’s historic concert in North Korea concluded hours ago, marking the first performance by an American orchestra in the impoverished, totalitarian nation. The event also marked a first for much of the press, who are routinely denied access to North Korea and, once inside, usually find their movements tightly controlled. The Times has a stunning slideshow of photos snapped en route from the airport to the center of Pyongyang, something the photographer says is never permitted.

The 48-hour visit began Monday with an extravagant state welcome featuring “a gala performance of traditional music and dance, and an endless banquet with quail eggs, roast mutton and pheasant ball soup.” The lavish festivities might surprise most North Koreans, as electricity is scarce throughout much of the nation and ordinary citizens are not permitted to own cellphones, use the Internet or listen to radio broadcasts from other countries.

022608North%20Korea%20NY%20Philharmonic.jpgThe Philharmonic concert was held in the 2,500-seat East Pyongyang Grand Theater, with former U.S. defense secretary William Perry seated in the audience next to Ri Gun, North Korea's deputy nuclear negotiator. North Korean dictator Kim Jong Il was not spotted in the audience, according to the Times. The concert began with the North Korean national anthem, followed by the Star Spangled Banner. Also on the program was Richard Wagner's prelude to Act 3 of “Lohengrin,” Antonin Dvorak's Symphony No. 9 “From the New World,” George Gershwin's “An American in Paris,” and Leonard Bernstein’s “Candide” overture. A rendition of “Arirang,” a beloved Korean folk song, reportedly brought tears to the eyes of many in attendance.

When the concert ended, the Philharmonic received a five-minute standing ovation from the audience, many wearing badges with a portrait of Kim Il Sung, father of Kim Jong Il. The decision to perform in North Korea has been predictably controversial. Critics like Terry Teachout have found fault with Maazel’s hope to bring "peoples and their cultures together on common ground" – and not just because the performance was only accessible to the party elite:

Even if such a concert were to be telecast, the handful of North Koreans lucky enough to see it, isolated as they are from the rest of the world, might well conclude that by sending a great orchestra there, the U.S. was showing its support for the tyrants who rule them. That's why I've come to the conclusion that should the Philharmonic choose to play in Pyongyang, it will be doing little more than participating in a puppet show whose purpose is to lend legitimacy to a despicable regime. [Anyone doubting Teachout’s description of the regime should read this shocking testimony.]
Condoleezza Rice was visiting Seoul on Monday for South Korea’s presidential inauguration; she told the Times she “had no plans to come to Pyongyang and sought to play down the performance as a diplomatic instrument.” The concert was broadcast live on North Korean state television and radio, and can be heard tonight at 8pm on WNYC. It will also be televised on local PBS station WNET tonight at 8pm; after midnight tonight you can stream the full concert online at VideoThirteen. WABC reporter Jim Dolan is accompanying the Philharmonic and blogging about the trip. His last post appeared Monday morning before leaving China for Pyongyang; North Korea is not not known for superior bandwidth.

918

Email This Entry







Advertisement: Gothamist Continues Below!

Comments (11)

Teachout is a writer for the Wall Street Journal and contributor for National Review. I would be surprised if he didn't call for attacking Pyongyang because Bush told him it was a good idea.

 

I think it would have been funny if Kim Sung Il pretended he was conducting the orchestra.

 

Sorry I meant to say Kim Jong Il

 

What a puppet show.

What a waste.

I'll no longer support the NY Philharmonic until Maazel is gone.

There is so much wrong with the decision to play North Korea. Yet I struggle to find one good reason to do so.

 

#4, because our country has tried giving this regime the silent treatment, and it has not worked. I, for one, was proud of NYPO.

 

They might still not be able to investigate all they would like by any stretch of the imagination, but this trip did get reporters from major news outlets doing stories on the country because they were actually allowed in the country. That is one good reason to go, dk.

 

Cultural exchange can be a real eye opener, especially when artists and musicians have the opportunity to intermingle. Regardless of Maazel's statements, the conversations that musicians have backstage--even the opportunity to meet as peers and see "the other" on human terms--can have a spreading impact. That is especially so in a hermetically sealed state like North Korea, where outsiders are constantly deemed poisonous. Poets and musicians are fertile ground for social revolution.

 

Also I wonder if Tehran is next on the list for them to go to.

 

Hmm. I watched the reporter's North Korean coverage. It felt all fake. The gov't was probably showing them the best of the country which wasn't all that great.

They were in a university with only about 20 kids in the class. Probably the only privilaged few...

 

because our country has tried giving this regime the silent treatment, and it has not worked.

I would hardly call almost two decades of negotiating - much of which was six nation talks - the silent treatment. Cuba gets the silent treatment. I'm not saying the Bush administration is doing a great job either but the North Koreans are hardly making it easy.

 

If you want to read more about the actual concert, I liveblogged the event earlier this morning on my site: www.feastofmusic.com.

 
Post a comment (Comment Policy)

2003-2008 Gothamist LLC. All rights reserved. Terms of Use & Privacy Policy. We use MovableType.