An attempt by NYC Transit to communicate accurate bus arrival times has been partially abandoned out of concerns that it just was not feasible to accomplish by the MTA. A pilot program has been in place on six separate bus lines, but those notification services have been scrapped because the digital displays at bus stops were just not capable of providing accurate information to riders. While in the planning for a dozen years, the actual equipment wasn't rolled out until this past October. NYC Transit doesn't know when its notification system could come back online.
The origins of the project reach all the way back to 1996, when a contract was awarded to Orbital Sciences Corp. to install a bus-tracking system. That contract was yanked after four years when the company ran into problems maintaining GPS and wireless signal capability amidst New York City's avenues and streets lined with towering buildings. This was a complaint of cab drivers who didn't want to install GPS devices in their hacks.
The failed experiment has been passed to Siemens, who is being paid just over $13.5 million to jump-start the now dark schedule messaging system, which encompasses the M15, M72, M57, M66, M116 and M31 lines. A total roll-out of the system could result in a contract for $109 million. NYC Transit has been experimenting with real-time notification schedules on the subway's L line. That project's proliferation also seems to be lagging.
I Don't Doubt It, by thelexiphane at flickr




Why the MTA screws up so many times: Shooting for the stars. Instead of a pilot program outside Manhattan to work the problems out, they choose to try this in the biggest concentration of tall buildings first.
how hard is it to estimate gps? You go out of range for a block. You make an algorithim to compensate. I don't get how Japan can have this wonderful transit system that costs millions less than NY and have it so much more technologically advanced.
Yeah the tube has real time train arrivals as well and has since, like, the early 90s. Not sure why this has been so hard to implement in the US.
What's taking so damn long to implement the notifications on a line other than the L? The system must be pretty difficult with the complex service patterns of various trains, but they could at least implement it on the 1 train too.
the MTA is completely retarded. every other public transportation system in a 1st world country has clocks showing how much time is left until the next train/tram arrives since the early 90's.
this is by far my biggest MTA pet peeve.
How about spending 109 million on ... say...MORE BUSES?
Call me kooky.
You've GOT to be kidding me that they can't get this figured out.