
Some people may prefer other bakeries, but from the looks of the crowd at the Magnolia Bakery's new Upper West Side location, people are hungering for some heavily frosted cupcakes. If the treats are available, that is.
We stopped by the bakery yesterday, a day after its Saturday opening, and the shop was packed. And many of the customers were victim to the opening frenzy, because Magnolia ran out of cupcakes for a spell (there were red velvet cupcakes on hand, just no traditional buttercream ones). An employee was posted at the door, making sure potential customers realized this as soon as they entered.
The new store has high ceilings, making it feel ten times bigger than the tiny Bleecker Street location. But the scene inside was as teeming as it gets downtown (sans the line around the corner) and even more chaotic. There wasn't any clear indication of a line for customers - equal parts UWS families, Magnolia devotees, and sugar fiends - to request the available items. When we saw people who came in after us being helped before us, we just looked at one employee (we had wanted to ask where we should even stand) who wearily snapped, "I can't help you!" Okay, sorry!
Luckily, another employee was very helpful and helped us with our order of banana pudding (creamy and comforting) and cherry jamboree (a confection of whipped cream and cream cheese, topped with cherries on a pecan crust). We imagine after the opening kinks and demand that Magnolia will be a big hit with the neighborhood.





what is the rage? there are better cupcakes in the cty.
[+] for using veblen for the title.
infact, there are better cupcakes on the UWS. including buttercup bake shop
why would you possibly want to go here?
This place sounds like a bakery here in California, Sprinkles. (It looks like it is headed NY's way.) Overpriced, mediocre cake topped with a glob of frosting. All for the low price of almost $4.
Magnolia cupcakes truly are sugar-laden vomit...the frosting is abhorrent and the cake dry as the gobi desert...
Here's a recent thread on this very topic at chowhound...I concur that 2 little red hens much much better...sometimes less is much more and all that.
http://www.chowhound.com/topics/481174
Typical UWS. In the last few years I've watched people go nuts for little Japanese cream-filled donuts and then for some fancy European gelato. They'll get over it.
HOW BOUT DEM COWBOYS!!!!!!!!!!!!