Morton's Stakes Claim in Brooklyn

122707morton%27s.jpgBy the end of next year, downtown Brooklyn will have a new upscale steakhouse to rival Peter Luger in Williamsburg; it was recently announced that Morton’s will be occupying the ground floor of a new Marriott annex tower on Adams Street. The Chicago-based restaurant chain will dish out their beef, seafood and sandwiches in a 300 seat restaurant near the Brooklyn Bridge.

Writing for the Brooklyn Paper, Gersh Kuntzman sees Morton’s arrival as the beginning of a juicy rivalry between the two steakhouses, but their locations are neighborhoods apart in a big borough with enough meat eaters to go around. Still, there has been a bit of a backlash against Luger, a 120-year-old establishment long regarded as serving the best steak in town. Besides a perceived decline in quality at Luger, the carnivorous Kuntzman points out that Morton’s will have an edge in drawing business people with expense accounts because the chain takes credit cards, whereas “Peter Luger makes you take a J train to Marcy Avenue with $500 in your pocket.”

Luger got a 28-out-of-30 score in the last Zagat review and doesn’t seem to be sweating it. The steakhouse has the rats on the run, they just added an annex space that seats 50-60 diners, and it’s still just as hard to get a table there during prime time. Any steak eaters out there care to comment on the quality of Morton’s versus Luger?

Computer rendering of future Morton's location via Brooklyn Paper.

Email This Entry


Comments (4) [rss]

Luger's isn't all that. Does Delmonico's still serve a good steak?

Also Morton's is subpar by chicago cow-town standards.

Wow I just said three things in an incoherent sort of way.

I can't speak to Morton's, but or me, going to Luger once was enough. It's cool as hell, has a really unique feel and just oozes history, but you can get a far superior meal for much less at a number of places throughout the city. It's cool to go for the experience, but once you've had it, you'll realize you can do a lot better for less. I'm told that it's a pretty good deal to go for lunch and get the Luger burger, though. Seems reasonable enough.

Morton's just needs to make sure that there are soy-based vegan items on its menu, catering to the Billyburg hipster client base.

user-pic

That new Morton's isn't anywhere near the Williamsburg hipsters

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

Get your daily dose of New York first thing in the morning from our weekday newsletter, now in beta.

About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung
Publisher: Jake Dobkin

Newsmap

newsmap.jpg

Contribute

Latest Tip:

Saving Public Housing By Building Anew
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS

Follow us