MTA Makes Budget Cuts, But May Still Need Fare Hike

With the MTA's vote whether to raise subway and bus fares coming in less than three weeks, speculation is running high about what will happen. Even though Governor Spitzer said that the base subway and bus fare will remain $2, unlimited Metrocard fares - which 85% of riders use - will rise. The MTA has insisted the fare hikes are necessary, given projected deficits and upcoming capital construction, but many elected officials believe that the decision to raise fares should be postponed until next April, to give State legislators a chance to find more money in the state budget and avoid a fare hike.

While there's debating on stopping a fare hike, the MTA's budget proposal also includes cuts to holiday bus service (supposedly reducing buses to the point of longer waits, but not overcrowding). The NY Times notes that cuts for Thanksgiving, Christmas and New Year’s Day would affect already-reduced holiday service; other days, like Martin Luther King Jr. Day, Christmas Eve and New Year's Eve, currently have regular service. It's strange that the MTA would want to cut service on New Year's Eve and New Year's - days when people are generally out and about - is it because people aren't taking buses?

Another controversial thing being cut: Elevator operators at the northern Manhattan stations, which seems crazy to us. Also being put on the chopping block is the MTA's subway evacuation program. The MTA says that many upgrades, like panic bars on emergency exits, have eliminated the need for actual flesh-and-blood MTA workers to help riders out of subway stations. Hey, aren't many panic bars set off randomly all the time?

Recently, Governor Spitzer claimed keeping the base fare at $2 and raising the unlimited Metrocard fare doesn't benefit tourists more. He said the move would help the poorest New Yorkers who are only able to buy regular pay-per-ride fares. And Mayor Bloomberg, who appointed four of the MTA board members with voting power, could theoretically tell his appointees to vote to delay a fare hike, making some hopeful for mayoral intervention. Bloomberg hasn't indicated whether he supports a fare hike, but he did say he wants to make sure the MTA is being run efficiently.


Email This Entry


Comments (6) [rss]

How about we lower wages? Yes? If they don't do their job efficiently and well, we axe their paychecks.

Jen,

Just FYI, 85 percent of riders don't pay the full $2 base fare. About 60 percent of those folk use Unlimited Ride Metrocards and the other 40 percent use the Pay-Per-Ride discount (pay 10, get 2 free rides).

The whole keeping the base fare at $2 is just political rubbish and Spitzer trying to salvage himself. Since a very small minority of people actually pay the base fare, it is unfair to raise the fare for some but not for others. The whole Daily News campaign seemed like a circulation stunt designed to make them look good without really getting into the fact that keeping the base fare at $2 just takes money out of the pocket of most of the riders.

user-pic

1)

Yeah because you know, its so cheap and takes so few unskilled people to run a 100 year old train system with over 600 track miles, thousands of switches, countless electrical junctions and thousands of pieces of rolling stock.

That's dirt cheap to maintain, power and maybe..just maybe, improve.

You can also get a bunch of Mexicans to work on the system for 4 bucks an hour, all around and have it function without killing people.

....Right.

You guys are getting off easy.

Ph,

What about the lazy-ass workers making $46,000 who supposedly "clean" the trains and station platforms?

The whole business of not raising the base fare is a totally bogus argument. It's true (I can tell you from personal observation) that tourists are not alone in paying the full freight. At least in Brooklyn, some elderly bus riders still feed 8 quarters into the coinbox.

Nevertheless, the vast majority of straphangers will be hit with a hefty fare increase if and when the MTA ups the unlimited-ride and multi-ride Metrocard rates.

I am old enough to remember the disastrous effects of starving the subways in the '60s and '70s, so I'm willing to pay my share. But let's give the State a chance to pony up the buckos before we sweat the hard-pressed fare payers.

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

Get your daily dose of New York first thing in the morning from our weekday newsletter, now in beta.

About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung
Publisher: Jake Dobkin

Newsmap

newsmap.jpg

Contribute

Latest Tip:

Fordham has a basketball team?
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS

Follow us