Rudy Giuliani told the American public, via a sit-down with Katie Couric, that the story pointing out expenses for trips to the Hamptons - to see then-mistress Judi Nathan - were billed across a number of obscure city agencies was a "typical political hit job" and a "debate day dirty trick." He even called it a "false story," but Politco, the website that broke the story, pointed out neither Giuilani or his aides "have questioned any of the facts reported by Politico."
Giuliani, who has previously noted that he was the target of death threats and needed police protection, said, "The police department paid for all of these expenses. But since the police department would sometimes be slow in payment. City Hall would pay it first, then the police department would reimburse every single penny of it."
Joe Lhota, who was a deputy mayor under Giuliani, said when police officers complained about not being reimbursed quickly enough, the mayor's office would use pre-paid American Express cards to pre-pay rental cars and lodging. What's funny is that Lhota told the Daily News that distributing security expenses across random city agencies has "gone on for years" and "predate Giuliani." But:
When told budget officials from the administrations of Ed Koch and David Dinkins said they did no such thing, Lhota caved Thursday, "I'm going to reverse myself on that. I'm just going to talk about the Giuliani era," Lhota said. "I should only talk about what I know about."What's especially rich is the quote the NY Times got from former Police Commissioner Bernard Kerik: "There would be no need for anyone to conceal his detail’s travel expenses. And I think It’s ridiculous for anyone to suggest that the mayor or his staff attempted to do so.” Given that Kerik is currently indicted for tax fraud, it's just funny to hear Kerik discussing money.
Mayor Bloomberg's office confirmed that the expenses funneled through agencies like the NYC Loft Board were reimbursed, but City Comptroller William Thompson said, "Is that the preferred way of doing business? No, it is not. It does not lead to openness and transparency."
At the end of the day, Giuliani was the mayor and got the security he needed. But this story reminds everyone how Judi Nathan had a police security detail and how Giuliani's detail also was on the road with him while he was campaigning for the 2000 Senate race.
And no word on whether Giuliani thinks the front page NY Times story - about how various statements he's made on the presidential campaign trail have exaggerated or falsely stated the facts - is a hit job. For instance: "When a recent Republican debate turned to the question of fiscal responsibility, he boasted that 'under me, spending went down by 7 percent.".... an aide said Mr. Giuliani had meant to say that he had proposed a 7 percent reduction in per capita spending during his time as mayor."
Photograph of Giuliani campaigning in South Carolina today by Stephen Morton/AP





"Forget Rudy's trysts. The real scandal crying out for investigation is his firm's business with Qatar, a haven for al-Qaida."
See Joe Conason's artice for the dirt on what should be the REAL story: Rudy's links to terrorists & those who said & abet them.
http://www.salon.com/opinion/conason/2007/11/30/giuliani_qatar/
Yes, an obvious hit job.
How Dare anyone report that his administration practices Creative accounting?
How Dare anyone report that his administration confused his mistress with his Wife?
I mean, giving his Girlfriend and his Wife a NYPD Detail?? Isn't that required by State Law?
i think guiliani is a goner, again. this is just the first story on these kinds of hijinx-- and once the clinton camp really gears up, they're going to turn over ever rock looking for stuff.
but the central theme of this story is crippling: guiliani was using the NYPD as a private car service for his mistress. a very similar situation cost hevesi his comptroller job-- and got him indicted. so i think things are more serious than they appear.
www.judithnathankillspuppies.com
dont put a dog murdering pug-faced floozy in the whitehouse!!!
she is an Imelda-wannabe
Jake's close to the central point... and this is it:
It simply reminds everyone that this married man and guardian of all Catholic virtures (remember the Brooklyn Museum?) was spending his weekends making Judi the Cross-eyed Golddigger sweat and scream.
Will there be indictments? No. Will there be prosecutions? No. Was there a crime? Based on what's known now? Probably not. But his poor judgement and colossal arrogance in this will cost him.
A hit job? Welcome to the NFL, buddy. Karma's a boomerang... as nice as he's been to people over the years, how shocking is it that when something comes to the surface everyone is ready to pounce on it? How many people were just waiting for something like this?
As for his funny numbers, hell, when you're always right, numbers don't matter, just know that he's always, always right.
And they should keep hitting him. Very Hard and Very Fast.
He looks like a preacher in that photo. Hallelujah! And is that Dick Cheney on the foreground getting ready to shoot?
Rudy's problem is that the repubs have already exhausted much of their Clinton fuselage, while Rudy's past, glossed over in post-9/11 world, is just now being exposed. Running for president could be the worst thing ever for his legacy.
Jake, It depends: If Hillary is the Democrat's Candidate.
Never underestimate the power of people that hate anything named "Clinton".
Glad to see someone had to finally backtrack after one of those "but somebody else did this or that" arguments.
Judi the Cross-eyed Golddigger !!!!!
hilarious
Tgirl:
don't forget social climber
Politcal? I'm impressed none of the 13 comments before me mentioned it with some snarky grammar comment.
As much as I dislike Rudy, I consider him the preferred republican candidate because of his liberal (relatively speaking) views on social issues. Things will only get worse if Thompson or Romney win the GOP nomination and the Dems somehow manage to loose 2008.
Saint Ghouliani of the Marriages inspired me to write a poem!
Rudy got Judy
To give up the booty
Out in the Hamptons
Which are quite snooty
New Yawkers wouldn't mind
His honor gettin some behind
'Cept they had to pay
For that top shelf whine
So what if it IS a hitjob? Looks like he's got a lot of 'splainin to do...
I [puffy heart] Gail Collins this morning in the Times:
"Rudy...has been having a bad week. Or, as he might put it, suffering persecutions never seen upon this planet since Mel Gibson was tortured on the rack, castrated, disemboweled and beheaded in “Braveheart.”... It’s fitting that Giuliani’s first big campaign crisis wound up being about his special subject: security. When he was mayor, he got a whole lot of it. The city was at one point paying for police guards to protect and transport not only Rudy, his children and his elderly mother, but also both his wife and his mistress. Really, they were thisclose to assigning a detail to the family retriever and a springer spaniel he was courting down the block."
There's more, check it out...
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/12/01/opinion/01collins.html?_r=1&ref=opinion&oref=slogin