Man Murders Date, Leaves Body in Bed for Days

2007_10_lenahan.jpgA 29-year-old Chinatown resident was charged with murdering his new girlfriend in the apartment he shares with his grandmother. Michael Chin Lenahan allegedly called his brother in NJ to say "I screwed up." His mother later went to the apartment and found a woman's body on her son's bed, under clothes.

Police say Lenahan and Lorna Santiago had a date on Saturday night. They started at a restaurant on Third Avenue and then went to a strip club, Rick's Cabaret, where he bought her $50 in lap dances. They returned to Lenahan's apartment at 20 Confucius Plaza. From the Post:

On Sunday, however, the couple, who had been dating for just a week, got into an argument.

Lenahan demanded the $50 back. The woman refused and kicked him in the groin.

Lenahan then lost it, grabbed her by the throat and choked her, investigators said.

He left her body lying on his bed and scrawled the apology, which was accompanied by a bizarre drawing, investigators said.

On Sunday and Monday nights, he slept beside the decaying body, they said.

Lenahan called his brother to say he made a mistake and that he would kill himself. The Daily News reports the brother went to the apartment to escort their elderly grandmother - who was in the home during the murder - out before the body was discovered. Lenahan fled but was convinced to surrender at a McDonald's near the South Street Seaport. A neighbor expressed her shock to WABC 7, "It's very unnerving, shocking frankly...It's a very quiet building, you never hear of anything like that. Very unsettling, actually."

Lenahan is described as an unemployed artist who has a record for grand larceny and had been depressed lately; he also suffers from spina bifida. He was charged with second-degree murder.

Email This Entry


Comments (42) [rss]

user-pic

I can't wait for the L&O: SVU episode

user-pic

damn. bro. asian guy commits crime? what is this world coming to? oh wait he's half asian. that explains it.

user-pic

just imagine what all of those hipster's moms will find under the clothes on their beds?

now is probably a good a time as any to get rid of guest comments.

user-pic

"I can't wait for the L&O: SVU episode"

Let me guesss - Law and Order will change the perpetrator to an evil white male, and the innocent damsel in distress will be a Chinese woman living just off Canal Street!

WAR IS PEACE
FREEDOM IS SLAVERY
IGNORANCE IS STRENGTH
DIVERSITY IS STRENGTH!!!

user-pic

I also love taking my dates to strip clubs and getting them lap dances. Nothing says I love you more than that.

Nothing gets the witticisms out like a homicide.

user-pic

That story is so bizarre I don't even know where to start.

user-pic

what an Idiot! Asking for the lapdance money to the girlfriend... after he bought those for her...
It all seems to moronic.

user-pic

Killing people is not difficult. Having a brain is what seems an achievemnt these days! Humans are not very far from beasts! HORRIBLE act!

i agree completely JMH. i think sleeping next to the body has to be the strangest part of the story. he couldn't even push her off the bed?

Seriously, this is one f**ked up dude. What else is there to say?

If a woman is going to kick a guy in the balls because he says something she doesn't like she deserves to die.

It seems like the "sleeping with the body" thing happens quite abit in these spouse/S.O. murders. I recall the wife of that Hong Kong banker sleeping in the same room with the body for 2 days. I wonder if it's just that they don't know what to do with the body, or there is some underlying psychological issue.

user-pic

"underlying psychological issue."....like being a murder!

user-pic

Honestly, really, what is with women and men's groins. She could have hit him with something hard, throw something, pepper stray, bite him, scratch him, kick him in the knee bone where it really hurts, or just ran out the apartment .... but she went to the groin. Women, get penis off your minds for a second.

#13 RC If a woman is going to kick a guy in the balls because he says something she doesn't like, she deserves to die.

Are for real?? You are now officially an ass hole in my book. No one deserves to die because of that. Besides, some guys love that kind of thing. CBT emmmm I believe.

Or maybe you’re just trying to get a rise out of someone, which in this case you got me. Thanks a lot.

user-pic

the type of art he'll be doing now is an anal performance piece in the prison shower, bravo!

Let's quantify the weird elements of this story:

1. The defendant has an almost comically mixed name ("Chin Lenahan").
2. He takes his new girlfriend to a strip club.
3. He buys her lap dances.
4. Despite having a very serious medical condition he's able to kill an adult woman bare-handed.
5. He spends two nights sleeping next to the stiff.
6. Grandma is in the apartment the whole time and doesn't notice anything odd.

Really, boys and girls, who needs fiction when reality can be so strange?

Sadly, Reality Czech's main purpose in life seems to be to get a rise out of posters on gothamist. He's the internet equivalent of bratty 14 year old. Intellectually impotent, sometimes amusing but mostly annoying, and totally harmless. Ignore him...

user-pic

Lorna was a wonderful soul. This man is just sick. God bless her and her family. I was an acquaintance and just met her once....but will never forget her. Please stop these ridiculous comments.

user-pic

at least law & order: SVU will have a new "ripped from the headlines" story for next season.

Peopel who call me an asshole and advise people to ignore me deserve to die.

user-pic

what do you guys mean, L&O eps are based off of fictional characters and events. do you guys remember the michael jackson episode? he was identified by the mole on his penis.

user-pic

reality czech is the kind of guy who probably has a big hairy mole on his penis and is all hung up about it

user-pic

Chin Lenahan is described as an unemployed artist. That sounds like the typical hipster scumbag. This loser didn't even have the common decency to kill himself.

And what's with the grandmother? Mama-san didn't hear a woman getting brutally murdered? Didn't she notice the smell of the rotting body? Was she planning to make some soup out of the corpse?

What a bunch of sick people that family is.

user-pic

Fortune Cookie Say: "Man who sleep next to dead body wake-up with stiffy"

he'll plea temp insanity.

user-pic

Quoting 3:

"damn. bro. asian guy commits crime? what is this world coming to? oh wait he's half asian. that explains it."

Oh no, it's Fu Manchu and the Yellow Peril!

user-pic

Don't know about you guys, but I am very impressed by the fact that this guy dated a Hispanic chick. I can't wait to see the pictures of her....

user-pic

Finally, an Asian dude with some taste - rather than settling for the lame flavorless and predictable Asian chick....

user-pic

Exactly. Asian guys can date outside their race. Since yellow fever has been rampant, why can't Asian guys date interracially? Does it only apply to Asian girls? At first it wasn't so bad because the ones afflicted with yellow fever would only date the ugly Asian girls. However, over time they have wised up and started dating the good looking ones.

user-pic

All the asian chicks I've dated have always been eager-to-please little sycophants. I guess when you're 4'11" with the personality of a doorknob and you meet a 6'2" white dude with some charisma, it's understandable...

user-pic

What's the going rate these days for an Asian guy in the big house - is it 2 or 3 packs of Marlboros? In any case, it's a good thing he wears glasses - so as to prevent stuff from getting in his eyes...

user-pic

Oh, and I just realized that the Latin Kings, MS13 or the myriad of other Hispanic-based gangs might take a particular interest in this fellow - after all...

user-pic

Sad story. This guy obviously has severe mental problems.

user-pic

sad story indeed,
cause we all know there's no crime perpetrated by hispanics towards asians.

user-pic

I am one of this woman's best friends.

Lorna would never kick (NOT EVEN SLAP) a guy without a physical provocation. She was just not a physically violent person. Which means that she probably kicked him while he was being violent with her. That is if this kick in the groin really happened for they do not have their facts straight.

For starters she IS NOT ASIAN (though she certainly did have very easily confused features like her sleek black hair and skintone which is not uncommon for Latinamerican countries). And she was 24, soon to be 25 (just next week)

Lorna B. Santiago Bonilla, Puerto Rican, recently moved to N.Y. to pursue a recently acquired job in the Immigration office.

Having known her intimately and being a really close friend I can testify she also did not voluntarily had sex with this man, specially not by barely knowing him for a few days. I can bet my head on this! (Which would make this all even more freaky than what it already is.)

She is also non-argumentative and avoided heated situations. She had a calm temper and was quite civil and carefully chose her words.

She was not his girlfriend either.

Reading inhumane and obnoxious and irrelevant and bigoted comments towards this is very hurtful for her friends and family.

~Oz Haver

user-pic

Is she hot looking...?

user-pic

This dude is probably a necrophiliac - he just finds a hot looking corpse too good to pass up...

user-pic

Wow, only in New York. Very sad, yet very intriguing. And shut up, troll.

user-pic

Please. We need to let our dead rest in peace. I was a very close friend of hers as well, from school in Puerto Rico. Its been three years since I hadnt heard from her and this is the first news i get from her.
Just wish her to rest in peace..Nobody would like to be thought of or seen as just a body..because Lorna was such a wonderful person...
Yes, it is true she made a bad decision to meet with this person but please you guys need to have a heart. The pain of losing a loved one is something im sure those of you with insolent messages dont know..and I wish you never have to go through this in your lives.

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

Get your daily dose of New York first thing in the morning from our weekday newsletter, now in beta.

About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung
Publisher: Jake Dobkin

Newsmap

newsmap.jpg

Contribute

Latest Tip:

2nd avenue and 47th- 1 hammarskjold plaza. 15-20 ambulances and trucks. Info from FDNY: people on 4
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS