Columbia Professor Says She "Will Not Be Silenced," Police Continue Hate Crime Investigation

2007_10_poisonivy.jpgThe professor at Columbia University's Teacher College whose office door was found with a noose on it spoke out for the first time yesterday. Madonna Constantine told students that gathered for a rally, "This is a heinous and highly upsetting incident. I am upset that our community has been exposed to a blatantly vile incident like this. It is an act of cowardice. I would like the perpetrator to know that I will not be silenced."

The police have no suspects in the hate crime, but emphasized that they did not believe Constantine put the noose on the door herself. Deputy Inspector Michael Osgood said, “Our victim is a victim." The police are testing the rope's fibers for DNA evidence; they also say the other professor who Constantine is feuding with, Professor Suniya Luthar, is not a suspect.

Mayor Bloomberg issued a statement calling the act "despicable and disgraceful," and Borough President Scott Stringer and State Senator Bill Perkins attended the rally outside Teachers' College. The Columbia Spectator reports that Perkin was disturbed someone with a Columbia ID and knowledge of the building put the noose on Constantine's door, "It’s as if a burning cross was placed on the campus of Columbia University. This sounds like an inside job.” "

Some Columbia students met with Columbia president Lee Bollinger, who faced criticism he was not visible enough to denounce the incident. Bollinger said, “I want you to feel and just to acknowledge in yourselves that this is a place that cares a lot about things that you have raised," and added that he let Teacher College president Susan Fuhrman take the lead in alerting her community. Students weren't totally satisfied and questioned Columbia's commitment to diversity.

Constantine also spoke to Good Morning America this morning, "I know I don't really have a reason to be embarrassed about it because this was the work of someone who, you know, is not a secure person at some level, but it felt as though it was directed toward me...It felt very personal and very degrading."

Update: The Sun reports that the NYPD has requested surveillance videos from Columbia, but the school refused to hand them over without a subpoena.

Update 2: Columbia says it is cooperating with the investigation and that the earlier report that it refused to turn over tapes was incorrect. A spokesperson says, "We are giving the tapes to the police."

Email This Entry


Comments (24) [rss]

user-pic

Wow. I've worked on people who have been shot dead twenty blocks north of where this took place and it got nowhere near the media coverage.

user-pic

I have a bad feeling about this one, she is the prime suspect in my book.

user-pic

It would be worth researching Ms. Madonna Constantine a little, her credentials are somewhat dubious for a tenured professor. Forty-four is pretty young, I wonder if she has a history of hijinks...

I don't know if anyone noticed, but one of the tabloid papers yesterday, on its sports front page, used the word "noose" with regard to Joe Torre.

shit. I was going to be a noose for halloween...

user-pic

it might be nice to hear about some educational achievements coming out of columbia rather than controversy after controversy.

user-pic

Somebody fill me in. What is the crime?

user-pic

you'd hear about it if the media was interested in education and higher learning.

user-pic

I think Lee Bollinger placed the noose there. It's obvious he's a media whore. Maybe he missed the attention his Ahmedinejad stunt caused?

user-pic

If Lee Bollinger didn't place the noose there, why is he afraid to turn over surveillance videos that can implicate him?

user-pic

righty tighty, lefty noosey?

why is she smiling for her photo?

People have to stop referring to these noose pranks as "heinous." Yes, they are racist and threatening and disturbing but NOT heinous. Heinous means "shockingly brutal or cruel." Its meaning is becoming diluted when applied to situations like this. Getting kidnapped and having horrific things done to you is heinous. Finding a noose on your door is not.

I have a bad feeling about this one, she is the prime suspect in my book.

You know, I didn't think this until she decided to hop on the media bandwagon and say she "would not be silenced." Silenced from what? I'd never heard of her before.

Does she have a book due out sometime soon?

user-pic

Are they sure this is "aggravated harrassment" and not a poor attempt at a Halloween decoration?

user-pic

I am not black, so it's impossible to speak from personal experience, but I think it is pretty heinous. Given the history of lynching in this country, putting a noose out for a black person seems an extremely cruel act.

It will be interesting to see where this goes, besides Law & Order, of course.

user-pic

The police are testing the rope for DNA evidence?!?!?!? Are you fucking kidding me?

When my apartment was robbed it took four hours for a pair of rookie cops to arrive and scribble down some report that nobody ever followed up on. No investigation, no fingerprints, nothing. But someone leaves a piece of rope on someone's door and they call out the entire cast of Law & Order and CSI? That's whack.

user-pic

Fortune Cookie Say; "Man who leave noose on door only trying to hang-out with new people"

When someone spraypaints swastikas on a synagogue, they don't call it a heinous crime; they call it vandalism or a prank. Leaving a noose on someone's door is not heinous; hanging someone is heinous.

Would the cops actually admit it to the papers if they were considering her a suspect?
Let's think about it....

And, yes, prime... suspect.

user-pic

why won't columbia give them the surveillance tapes? hmmm.......

user-pic

the whole "heinous" discussion is just heinous.
The word is an adjective, so of course its meaning depends on the "feeling" of the person who uses it.
For some one thing can be BLUE and for others GREEN. That does not mean BLUE is wrongly used, because is a perceptual experience.
Now, if you think the description of that perception is OFF or you don't share the perception, then is a matter of a difference of opinions, not a wrong use of the word.

user-pic

She's a big girl - wouldn't she need a much bigger noose...?

user-pic

It's obviously a "heinous crime" because it reminds everyone of the "horrific" racial lynchings which used to took place on Manhattan's Upper West Side back in the day.

AL Sharpton ALert.

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

Get your daily dose of New York first thing in the morning from our weekday newsletter, now in beta.

About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung
Publisher: Jake Dobkin

Newsmap

newsmap.jpg

Contribute

Latest Tip:

Symphonic rock comes to Manhattan in December! Seann Branchfield and the Unnamed Band performing De
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS

Follow us