Old Memo Reveals Warnings About Deutsche Bank Safety

2007_09_patspit.jpgWere safety concerns about the Deutsche Bank's demolition ignored by aides to Governors Pataki and Spitzer and Mayor Bloomberg? That's what the NY Post is reporting, as the investigation into the August fire that claimed two firefighters lives continues.

Apparently Lower Manhattan Construction Command Center (the government agency overseeing the dismantling) head Charlie Maikish sent a memo to LMDC chairman Avi Schick on May 25, 2007, noting that the LMCC was not prepared to manage the job: "We assumed this role, on an interim basis, in order to be good soldiers; however, we also made it very clear that we could not perform [the demolition and decontamination] safely or efficiently without being provided the necessary resources."

Maikish also wanted the LMDC to resume control over the project - and he included a letter he had sent to former LMDC chair Kevin Rampe in December 2006 noting that the LMCC was understaffed and could not manage the project. (Rampe is a Pataki appointee, Schick is a Spitzer appointee.) However, it's unclear if Rampe ever got the letter. The memo was also sent to Deputy Mayor Dan Doctoroff.

Maikish's spokesman told the Post, "The request by Governor Pataki's Office to Mr. Maikish came with the assurance to Mr. Maikish that resources would be forthcoming from the next administration. Those resources were never provided." The other government parties have not commented. If anything, it seems to be another piece of evidence that the Deutsche Bank building dismantling has poorly managed with little oversight.

Email This Entry


Comments (6) [rss]

user-pic

I believe the mail excuse. I don't get half my mail down here.

Maikish sends this letter that the Post describes as "grave warnings of Charlie Maikish," after a pipe falls off of the building and through a firehouse? Sounds like somebody floated Maikish's name as the guy responsible.

And it sounds like he pulled out a classic CYA letter that typically gets tossed if nothing happens, but the flunky waves around if something does go wrong. "I told you in December we couldn't do this job! See!?!?" We're looking at CYA round 2.

A garbage collector will say, "we're never going to get all this garbage cleaned without more resources."
A teacher will say, "test scores are going to go down if we don't get more resources."
A bus driver will say, "we can't keep our scheduled stops without more resources." Etc.

However, it doesn't sound like a "grave warning." A "grave warning" is "the place is going to go up in a fireball if we don't do something!!!"

user-pic

Government incompetence once again.. is anyone really surprised?

user-pic

Hillster is just a lame defender of the LMDC. And now supposedly "top" LMDC people say Schick and Emil never got the letters, which seems ridiculas. Here are links to the letters so readers can decide for themselves:
http://www.nypost.com/seven/09262007/photos/news003b.jpg
http://www.nypost.com/seven/09262007/photos/news003c.jpg
http://www.nypost.com/seven/09262007/photos/news003d.jpg

user-pic

What kind of crap is it that everyone doing business at GZ has to sign a contract with the LMDC that they won't talk to the media? Its an ideal situation for a cover up. If its an "unprecedented open process" than the LMDC should release everyone from the clause prohibiting them from talking to the media.

user-pic

Isn't the ultimate CYA tactic when a lawyer advises their client "I neverknew about it?"

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

Get your daily dose of New York first thing in the morning from our weekday newsletter, now in beta.

About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung
Publisher: Jake Dobkin

Newsmap

newsmap.jpg

Contribute

Latest Tip:

flavor flav caught owing taxes to the IRS http://www.backtaxeshelp.com/tax-blog/celebrities/flavor-f
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS