July 27, 2007
Mixed Reception for MTA CEO Sander Over Fare Hikes
Yesterday, MTA CEO and executive director Lee Sander took the case for subway and bus fare hikes to the people by standing at the Grand Central shuttle platform yesterday morning. The MTA has argued that with looming billion-dollar deficits, fare hikes, as well as agency cuts, are the only way for the MTA to stay afloat without trimming service. According to the NY Times, very few people stopped to talk to Sander who was handing out a leaflet called "The Fare Facts" which cited "growing pension and debt service costs" as why fares should go up.
The people who did stop were skeptical or resigned. The Post reports that one man yelled, "Keep the fares down, bastard!" at Sander. (To enjoy how the Post differs from the NY Times, this is how the NY Times reported the suggestion: A man in a green shirt walked by and shouted, “Keep the fare down,” punctuating his comment with a vulgarity.)
At any rate, advertising "guru" Jerry Della Femina thinks that Sander was smart to make his case in person, "It's effective. The public hates it when Con Ed spends a lot on advertising to tell you why they screwed up." True, but given that the subways and buses have so much advertising space (and you've seen those ads for movies/TV show premieres that have already passed!), couldn't the MTA speak to its constituents directly with a campaign in the subways and buses? Related: Second Avenue Sagas looked at the history of subway advertising.
As for the increase itself, the Post generally finds that subway fare increases have been under inflation - when you use an average fare of $1.30 (with Metrocard discount). The NY Times' Clyde Haberman has a Times Select-only column about the pizza slice index: When subway/bus fares go up, so does the price of pizza. Damn you, ethanol, milk and rent increases!
Photograph of MTA CEO Sander chatting with subway service workers last week by Jonathan Marshall Mantel/AP




so, there gonna raise the transit fares, but the car driving minority will continue to drive into the city unaffected. we better get congestion pricing!
Gee, I don't remember paying $1.30 when I buy a Metrocard. I pay TWO FREAKIN' DOLLARS!!!!
With the discount, #2. If you buy multiple rides, you get one or two free swipes, which drives the average price per ride for the overall card down. It's called math.
In the meantime, I'm amused that the pamphlet on my seat on the LIRR yesterday morning preached the doctrine of "no service cuts"...but when I got on my train home, the usual 12 cars were down to 8, leaving the entire train dangerously overcrowded. Actions speak louder than words, guys...
As long as the MTA can turn a profit on the riders things will not change . It doesn't matter who's at the helm the same song & dance will continue being played out over and over again . Prepare to pay $[3]-$[4] per ride because unless the Governor steps in that's what We'll be paying in the future . Posted by; "Still Not Amused"
#3 Gee, I must be a retard. How about you take some of your "math" and apply it to my wallet. Because my math take two dollars out of my wallet and gives it away at the turnstyle.
Go ahead, bring your math over here and help me out, ya wise ass!
The problem with the MTA is that they are not held accountable for poor management. They forecast a deficit, raise the fares and then end up with a surplus before all of the incremental receipts have even been realized.
Additionally, I am surprised that no once challenged Mr. Sander on the "growing pension and debt service costs". I don't have a pension. Why do overpaid MTA workers get one?
You can't be a civil "servant" and get better pay and benefits than the majority of taxpayers funding your salary when you job doesn't require a high degree of skill.
hey #5 for every $10 you put on your pay-for-ride metrocard, you get 1 free ride (i.e., an extra $2 is automatically added to your card). If you were to swipe your card immediately after purchase, it would show that it has $12 on it, not $10.
For more info.:
http://www.nysubway.com/metrocards/index.html
btw - the MTA would probably prefer YOUR math.
Screw you #7! Stop defending those scumbags. You probably like the Nazis too.
#8, You're either a moron or a 10 year old. I wasn't "defending" anyone. I was just stating the facts. Some people didn't seem to understand how the MTA fare discount works.