June 22, 2007
Granny Mugger Indicted; Charges Include Hate Crimes
Jack Rhodes, the man suspected of robbing and beating elderly woman in Queens, was indicted yesterday on 35 charges of burglary, assault, robbery, and, yes, hate crimes.
The NY State Hate Crimes Act has a provision that allows hate crime charges to be filed if the defendant has selected a victim because they are old. Queens DA Richard Brown said, βIn just over nine weeks, the defendant is alleged to have beaten and robbed three women β one of whom was 101 years of age. Remarkably, the injuries sustained by all three victims were not more serious. The savagery and violence of the attacks have no place in a civilized society. The charges will be vigorously prosecuted.β Hate crimes carry much tougher penalties.
The mugging of 101-year-old Rose Morat in her apartment vestibule was caught on tape and outraged the city, and it turned out that the same person was suspected of mugging an 85-year-old shortly after. The two women were suffered injuries, and the robber got away with $65 and two rings. The NYPD formed a dragnet to find the crook and New Yorkers flooded the police's tip lines with colorful suggestions on how to punish the attacker.
You can read the indictment here (PDF). Interestingly, what constitutes a hate crime is being debated in a Brooklyn murder trial; defense lawyers say that three men who lured a man via a gay chat room did not choose their target because he was gay but instead because he was an easy target. At any rate, prison officials are trying to keep Rhodes safe in a private cell, because many prisoners want to "take a pop at him."




Good luck in the pen...
Brother Rhodes has done nothing wrong, this is all a CON-spiracy perpetrated by the SO-CALLED white man! We all know that the old woman is the TRUE AGGRESSOR in this case!
Alfred E. Sharpton
I don't see how this is a hate crime. He didn't hate old people, he just thought theyu were an easy mark, and they were.
Yeah, how can it be a hate crime...the old lady is White.
Yeah, but she took the last rye!
"Hate crime classification" or not, this guy is truly evil and let's be happy he'll be locked up soon.
Private cell is bullshit. This asshole gets what he deserves!
-La Leone-
proof of the overall stupidity of hate crime legislation.