Giving New Yorkers a Bad Name

2007_05_nyersbad.JPGWe read the headline "5 New Yorkers detained in Disney World brawl" and thought, "Uh oh." Then it turned out that the five people were from Long Island! (Shirley, NY, to be exact.)

Authorities told the AP that five people, ranging from 14 to 20 years old, were spitting and swearing at Walt Disney World patrons and were detained on Sunday after causing a scene around Space Mountain. Then the group got into a fight with the deputy, who said, "I was punched in the face with closed fists several times by all the defendants. I defended myself by throwing counter punches in their faces and bodies in an attempt to break free." It wasn't until he used a stun gun on a 17-year-old girl who had punched a security guard that "everyone came under control."

Which leads us to this question:

And unsurprisingly, some of the group may have been intoxicated.

Email This Entry


Comments (44) [rss]

I predict 50+ Comments.

Long Islander Savages. Especially the white spoiled teenagers who live out there. Terrible!

user-pic

Lock them up now for good! They've already proven that are going to be wastes in the future, nothing but trouble.

actually my man, Shirley is white trash town. think east bensonhurst.
like riverhead, freeport, ronkonkoma and holtsville.

Really scientific. Most Gothamist readers are incapable of self analysis and self criticism. I'm only shocked that Long Island is leading upstate and that nobody has made a guns and/or redneck comment.

this doesn't surprise me in the least. part of the BTP bridge n' tunnel posse. you can also find these kids on the upper east side or turtle bay area where they spread their seed of white trashery as well.

NY REPRESENT!

Nope, not rednecks,
just guidos and guidettes and their ilk. could be any nationality. italian, irish, polish, jewish.
Long Island has spawned many bad people, Rosie O'donnell and Bill O'Reilly.
and the polls show it, the polls do not lie.
thank you Jen of gothamist.

Shirley is white trash town. think east bensonhurst.
like riverhead, freeport, ronkonkoma and holtsville.

Freeport's mostly nonwhite.

I know, just like Roosevelt is non white but I had to throw in a black trash town in to be fair.

Nothing better than a bunch of white trash Long Gisland guidos. Keep 'em in Florida...we don't want them back.

Good. We should send 500 New Yorkers with attitude to that dumb-ass Disney wasteland to stir things up and give them something to think about besides that awful homogenized vision of fake americana.

Good Lord, is that the real numbers for the poll or has someone wrote a script to keep on voting?
The guys look like the Lester kid from howard beach. the girls look like the porn chick guage.
add in some amy fisher qualities and you get what everybody wrote, white trash.

Predictable and boring Long Island bashing.

"Long Island has spawned many bad people, Rosie O'donnell and Bill O'Reilly. "

Let's be fair, asshole(s). LI also can also claim Lou Reed, Mo Tucker, Public Enemy, Lenny Bruce, Jerry Seinfeld, and Steve Buscemi.

LI certainly has white trash and guidos, and is no paradise overall, but is it really any worse than whatever 3rd rate, shit midwest/southern/west coast suburb you come from? I doubt it, and at least it's close to the ocean, mountains, AND New York City.

Also fun to point out to snobby, ignorant, transplanted douchebags is the fact that Brooklyn and Queens are, in fact, located on Long Island.

What about Staten Island? They are the worst!!

Forget about Long Islanders being the worst, it's just the savages from the bronx or brooklyn can't afford a disneyworld vacation!

the five towns has the worst drivers.

If long islanders only destroyed their own zip code with their arrogant, ignorance fueled absurdity they would be no worse than any other. However, they rove like barbarian hordes and annoy all they come in contact with with their baseless sense of superiority. I went to SUNY Albany and am also from Albany. The LI people looked down on me, but thats cool. Five years later, I've got a good job in the city and a nice apt/life in bklyn. They are still living in their mom's basement, doing coke, and fighting with other jackasses at some meatpacking horror-show. Time wounds all heels.

Is LI "really any worse than whatever 3rd rate, shit midwest/southern/west coast suburb you come from?" Maybe in terms of location, but the people are toxic. See e.g. above human specimens. Every Long islander has a chip on their shoulder. They need to be more city than city kids to make up for the fact that they live in suburbia. I hear that retarded accent and I know what kind of person I am dealing with.

Guidos and Guidettes and their ilk are a plague that has spread to every state and town in this once beautiful country, not just Long Island, and Staten Island.

The only cure for them is to educate them, Instill in them respect and dignity for themselves and other people, and elevate them above their ignorance of the outside world beyond their ugly suburban cul-de-sacs

Would anybody here just care to stop being quite so idiotic for a moment?

Yes, there are assholes from Long Island.

Kind of like everywhere else.

No? Oh. Obviously, all the vitriol-spewing people posting here come from wonderful places full of warm, generous people. Doesn't quite explain why they're spending their time posting stupid hate on an internet news blog, but hey! Whatever!

Want to point out that the Magic Kingdom doesn't even serve alcohol (you have to go to one of the other parks for a drink)... so they would have needed to sneak it in!

20 and counting, Lieutenant.

There are assholes everywhere, usually any time you get five people together one of them will turn AH at the slightest provocation. But here's the thing, it seems that nowhere are they more proud of their assholedness than on the Guyland.

I can remember a Times article from some years back describing, in the wake of Joey Buottofucco/Amy Fischer mess (google if necessary) the life of ennui on the Guyland. It opened with a story of two cops on patrol in a park in Nassau and coming across some graffiti on a boulder. One cop turns to the other and says, "Damn Kids."

The boulder read "SATIN LIVES."

Kind of says it all.

two words: SUFFOLK TRASH

#22,
Maybe the graffiti writers were just being really, really fashion conscious.

p.s. Amen to #14 and #20.
..and Das FX are also from Ronkonkoma

"Guidos", "white trash", etc?

You sound like a bunch of martini swilling Republican dumbbells reeling from fake pride and contempt. Whats up with all this hatred? What makes you so much better than them, your paycheck?

Sarcasm parading as sophistication is a cover-up for self loathing.

As one LI'er who hates LI mentioned to me once,
there really is not difference between Brooklyn and Lynbrook.
it's like the rites of spring where I grew up, the first mob fight from these white trash.
saw them stomp on guy with their rollerblades once.

"Satin Lives?" What, were they Anti-Silkites?

;)

#26

"What makes you so much better than them..?"

Maybe the fact that we wouldn't be arrested for a drunken brawl in Disney World !!

As far as calling a spade a spade, thier behavior says it all

duh.!

number 29 should also add, the youngest one arrested was 14 years old. 3 out of the 5 are under 18.
The oldest is the girl on the top left, the other guy is 19.
this type of behavior starts young and continues on till they're dead. it's really disgusting.
like groundhog day, I expect this behavior when the weather warms up in my neighborhood.
Add me to the list of never been arrested for hitting a cop.

Being from Westchester, I can definitely say that folks from Long Island are low lifes. The Island consistently votes Republivan. Why? Because they just don't give a sh*t about anything but themselves. It's like having a 100 mile long stip of middle America just off NYC. At least most people from upstate are educated and have some class.

Being from Westchester, you're probably a jackass too.

Yeah because Westchester is just full of winners huh? Pretentious pricks.

i'm from jersey. we have class in jersey.

May have some class in Jersey, but way too many Guidos, witch automatically cancels out class = no class

user-pic

Nothing kills the eardrums like the Long Island accent. It's worse than the Southern drawl, the crap you hear in Boston, and even the South Jersey twang.

user-pic

I grew up on Long Island, detest the "culture" there and was overjoyed when I moved away from people who were outraged that I should find anything less than exalting about the crushingly conformist void that exists there as a poor substitute for legitimate culture. After enduring the staggeringly insipid actions, words and attitudes of countless jackasses and goons from Long Island, I witnessed a few cringe-worthy displays of foul mouthed histrionics, littering, shoving and bullying while in Disneyworld traveling with others. The rudest, most thoughtless, boorish, pushy, loud, obnoxious individuals at Disney that day alone were from Long Island(I listened to them refer to Long Island landmarks and use indigenous slang - the Long Island whine) and those incidents inspired me to subtly inquire about difficult tourists wherever I have traveled since. I almost always get a somewhat diplomatically sheepish reply about "some people" from Long Island as the most trouble, most unpleasant, antisocial and or atrocious people anywhere, so whatever is instilled in the distasteful Long Islanders, it stays behind them as a reminder to the civilized folks elsewhere. The rest of the country has to deal with meth addicts wasting their lives, Long Island has arrogant bellicose jerks with ludicrously high and equally unfounded opinions of themselves.

Steve Buscemi was born in Brooklyn. We claim him as ours.

Brooklyn is on Long Island.

user-pic

Long Island is an evil place. It truly is a sub-civilization these days. The thugs in NYC are nothing compared to L.I. thugs.
BTW, this incident had nothing to do with my opinion! It's not surprising in the slightest bit.

user-pic

I know these biased comments are typical of any Gothamist debate, but this one hurts me. I'm from eastern Long Island, actually a nice small town by the beach. People from the East End are really laid-back; in fact, I'd never heard the term "JAP" until I went to college upstate.

In high school, I dated a guy from Shirley, and there definitely are a lot of douchebags there, but there are douchebags everywhere. I dare anyone to flip through their yearbook and not spot a douchebag. It's just part of life, and you have to live hoping that the douchebags from your home town/area won't make fools of themselves.

they should give the land back to the indians. it rightfully belongs to them... right...

I am sick to my stomach over the generalization of these comments about people from LI. I am from a very nice town on the island and yes, there are some uneducated jerks, but the majority are polite, go to college and teach their kids respect.

I worked at a Long Island beach over the summer when I was in high school, and let me tell you...I got the majority of attitude, rudeness and low class behavior from the idiots from Queens and Brooklyn who tried coming in on the weekends even though large signs everywhere said it was a beach for town residents only. They apparently thought they were better than everyone else and the rules didn't apply to them. When I politely explained to them it was for town taxpayers only and of course if they were from New York I could direct them to a state beach they could go to, I got called all sorts of names. Yes, and Long Islanders are trash : P

user-pic

I don't understand you people... I'm sure you'll just assume it because I'm from "a small southern town". But life is way too precious and short for all of this meaningless fighting... I mean seriously, who fist fights at Disney World?? And it gets even more stupid... There are actually people on this webpage arguing about it... You people are freakin weird and I can easily see now why my small town was voted in the top 5 best places to live in the US... It's because ya'll have no damn home training!

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

Get your daily dose of New York first thing in the morning from our weekday newsletter, now in beta.

About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung
Publisher: Jake Dobkin

Newsmap

newsmap.jpg

Contribute

Latest Tip:

what picture?!?
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS