She's Not A Woman, She's a "Man"!

2007_04_surveil2.jpgSurveillance video and witness testimony marked day of testimony in the trial of four lesbians who beat up a man in Greenwich Village last summer.

The victim, Dwayne Buckle, claims he was assaulted because he was straight (he did try to pick up one of the girls). The women claim self-defense, alleging that Buckle called them names and made rude remarks ("I'll f--- you straight, sweetheart"), spat on them, and threw a cigarette at them as well. Well, here's witness testimony, via the Post:

Alleged victim Dwayne Buckle had just shouted, "Calm down, woman," as the sapphic septet surrounded him on a Greenwich Village sidewalk last August, an eyewitness told a jury yesterday.

"She was like, 'I'm not a woman! I'm a n-! I'm a man!' " tattoo and graffiti artist Louis Barak testified of the only "dialogue" he could remember from the predawn beat-down at Sixth Avenue and West 4th Street.

"It stuck out in my mind, because it was pretty bizarre."

Barak added that Buckle did not attack them first and said he saw one woman "swipe" a knife at Buckle, who was beaten, kicked, and stabbed after a melee that was caught by a surveillance camera. Defense lawyers showed footage of Buckle waving "around a handful of his alleged attackers' hair extentions."

And in a side note: The Post also reports how a juror was booted off the panel:

The case is so unsettling that on the eve of opening statements, one juror asked for more information on what kind of "gang" was involved, telling the judge that while he was certain he would remain impartial, "I would want to know in order to protect my family."

Oddly, the concern prompted Justice Edward McLaughlin to complain that the juror, Bruce Nussbaum, apparently feared danger "from an organized group of violent lesbians" - and not only kicked him off the panel, but essentially banished him to purgatory for the duration of the trial.

Nussbaum, an assistant managing editor at Business Week magazine, must now sit in the courthouse's Central Jury Room from 9:45 a.m. until 4:45 p.m. every day court is in session as punishment - or face up to 30 days jail - because he "failed to reveal certain information" during jury selection, according to the judge's order against him.

The jettisoned juror declined to comment, except to say he has filed a complaint against the judge with the Commission on Judicial Conduct. The judge did not immediately return calls for comment.

Quick, Law & Order, pick up this plot!

Email This Entry


Comments (13) [rss]

Of all the cases to duck out of jury duty over, who picks the one about a gang of dangerous brawling lesbians? That's jury duty most people would pay to serve.

calling rev al, rev sharpton...where are you? why dont you get in front of the cameras and talk about this case?

It's no secret that there are a lot of wacky judges on the bench.

Sharpton Sharpton Sharpton. I'm obsessed with Al Sharpton!

SharpTON.

She's not a lesbian, she's a wildebeest.

user-pic

west 4th street and this area of 6th ave is notoriously known for gang violence. the cops need to step up undercover patrols and start throwin these animals in the clink.

I would PAY to be a juror in this trial..LMAO!

user-pic

Putting a violent lesbian in jail is like locking her inside a harem. If she said "I'm a man!" send her to a *men's* prison (assuming she's convicted).

Good he got what he deserved, dumb ass. How many times have women been harassed on the street by ass holes who think they can say whatever they want just because they've got a dick. Fuck him. Sucks when the tables are turned doesn't it.

Here is a video I found, it shows a similar situation. I guess he got what he deserved too.
It seems everytime I travel to the West Village nowadays, it seems I am confronted with viloent
gay young people who appear only to be loitering thier nasty ways in front of my kids eyes, causing wreckless damage to people, property and my well being. Why is no one saying something about this nasty, violent culture, that seems to be getting a "Free" pass to cause various physical and pshycological damage to all the hardworking regular people of the earth.

go to youtube:
youtube.com/watch?v=AfO6tn3g-cg

user-pic

hey superdave,
people like you are the reason situations like this happen. i hope your kids realize what a dickhead you are and leave you to rot alone, miserable, and conservative... super combo.

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

Get your daily dose of New York first thing in the morning from our weekday newsletter, now in beta.

About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung
Publisher: Jake Dobkin

Newsmap

newsmap.jpg

Contribute

Latest Tip:

seniors from samuel gompers high school are trying to raise money to go to rome. these are fairly un
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS