April 12, 2007
Lesbians On Trial For Beating Up Straight Man
Remember when a filmmaker claimed that a group of lesbians attacked him outside the IFC Center last summer? And it was revealed that the women felt they were defending themselves, with one woman saying, "I admit I did cut him one time for my own safety"? Well, the case has made it to court.
Manhattan prosecutors say that Dwayne Buckle was viciously attacked - he was stabbed, punched, and kicked - by Patreese Johnson, Venice Brown, Terrain Dandridge, and Renata Hill. Buckle claims that he was simply trying to say hello to Johnson, but then the women attacked him.
However, the women claim that Buckle called them "f---ing dykes," spat on them, threw a cigarette on them, and told one, "I'll f--- you straight, sweetheart." The Post reports that Buckle grabbed the throat of one woman, which was caught on a surveillance camera. Naturally, Buckle denies he said that, but he did say some other things:
Buckle told a different story on the stand, assigning many of his alleged attackers monikers.Buckle also admitted that he told one woman she looked "like a man." Classy! Side note: Judge McLaughlin sounds like a character, because when Buckle explained he was upset that one of the women called his sneakers cheap when they were actually $100 dollars, McLaughlin said, "Then they weren't Stephon Marburys."There was Brown, the one he admittedly called an "elephant." Then there was the one with the "low haircut," do-rag and wife-beater T-shirt, whom he admittedly called "a man," and the "slightly pretty" one to whom he first said hello.
It all started, he said, when the first two walked by. "They looked effeminate [sic] and one of them was slightly pretty, so I said 'hi' to them," he said.
But the "heavier girl, she started to dog me out," Buckle said.
"What does that, perchance, mean," asked the judge, Justice Edward McLaughlin. "Just disrespect me," Buckle explained. Then "more girls started coming out of nowhere."
Johnson, who admitted she "cut him one time," is charged with attempted murder, while the three other women are charged with gang assault. Their lawyers say that Buckle was actually stabbed with another person from the street who joined the women. And the NY Times reports that three of the women's friends have already pleaded guilty to attempted assault and were sentenced to six months in jail and give year's probation.
Related: The Village Voice's cover story this week is about the emergence of "thug"-like lesbians. And that stretch of Sixth Avenue near West 4th is like a Hellmouth - it's also where the KFC/Taco Bell of the Rats is.
Photograph of the IFC Center by The Reeler
|
Wow... can I watch?
I love how his testimony is so derogatory. I hope his stupidity influences the jury to let these ladies off.
P.S. It's about time gay people stood up and started fighting back.
"P.S. It's about time gay people stood up and started fighting back."
lol
MT, even if he said those things it doesn't matter. They had no right to physically attack him. They should be thrown in jail. If three straight people attacked a gay person there would be an immediate uproar over that "hate crime" (as if attacking people otherwise doesn't involve hate). Lock em all up.
finally made it to supreme court... not criminal court... case starts in criminal court and is kicked up to supreme for trial.
While no one should ever be stabbed, if someone started harassing my friends on the street and then grabbed me by the neck - I think most of us would have skipped the pleasantries...
While no one should ever be stabbed, if someone started harassing my friends on the street and then grabbed me by the neck - I think most of us would have skipped the pleasantries...
Man, those are some rough hos. I bet they got tattoos.
I've heard of bull dykes, but elephant dykes?
"P.S. It's about time gay people stood up and started fighting back"
soon there is going to be time for "It's about time straight people stood up and started fighting back"... I tried to walk into a gay bar with some friends and was not let in because I am str8. figure that out.
@arcatera: you weren't let in becasure you're "str8". Hah, that's some bullshit if I ever heard it. I guess you didn't set off the gaydar at the door. How exactly did they know you were straight? Are you just THAT masculine? I have a feeling there's more to that story.
I'm with gay people standing up. Rise up. Fight back. Good for these girls.
So... who here got charged with a hate crime?
Lol, Dyke's fight back ! What a concept ! The ass whooping he took should be justice enough for this case .
@JLS : The reason that they knew I was straight was becoz I was there with my girlfriend who was holding my hand! I was meant to be meeting some gay male friends the bar and arrived early before they got there. The rude arrogant
hetrophobe at the door wouldn't let me in.