Gothamist: FDA: Menu Foods Tests Killed 7 Pets Before Recall

L Sutter

Sat, 31 Mar 2007 00:45:12 -0500

My cat was also "allegedly" affected by tainted cat food. I am one of the lucky ones, and My cat is still with me though he may have long term kidney problems. My heart goes out to everyone who has lost a loved one. One obvious thing no one is saying, with the exception of Menu Foods and Hill's Science Diet, is that the root of the problem is likely NOT WITH MENU FOODS! It's their supplier!!! This alarms me because ANY manufacturer of pet food could have tainted products out there. Hill's is a prime example! Even though thier recall is voluntary with no immediate evidence of contamination, Their m/d food is not made by Menu foods but rather made WITH ingredients from one of menu Food's SUPPLIERS. I commend Hill's Science Diet for their efforts even though their product may have hurt my kitty. They are pulling no punches. EVERYONE ELSE APPEARS TO ASSERT BLAME EXCLUSIVELY ON MENU FOODS. Menu foods and Hill's Science Diet are the only 2 companies I know of who have stepped up and taken action based on the supplier. Everyone else seems to be blaming Menu Foods EXCLUSIVELY. This is a MISTAKE. More pets will DIE. All pet food makers need to check their suppliers and tell us if they use ingredients from the same supplier! Or... is it all about profits, distancing from potential lawsuits, while the health and well being of your pet takes a back seat?

Melvin D. Fraki

Thu, 29 Mar 2007 10:51:57 -0500

You killed my wonderful minature schnauzer, Cuddles the Princses two weeks ago with your food, Iams, and Ol'Roys Gorment Foods. My beautiful minature schanuzer passed away in a few days, very ill. The Copper Country Veterian, said there was no hope for her ad the Kidneys and other Functions completely failed, she peed all over the house, enterance ways, glossy eyes, and after here exame had only one hope, put to death, and creamated, now sleeping under her Home on the back yard. She was beautiful, obeatent, knew all the commands, friendly, and my loving Cuddles. How could you do this to her!!!! She cost well over $700.00 and Veterian Expenses over $1,000. Shame on you!!! I surely think she is worth much more and please send my check for much more immediately!!!!!!!! Mel Fraki, Houghton, MI 49931-9250 SHE IS JUST NOT REPLACEABLE!!!!!

seangoog

Tue, 27 Mar 2007 10:01:43 -0500

Sadly animals died, but what people should be worried about is what this potential threat to animals could mean to us. What if the food contaminated was eaten by humans? There are no guarantees in this world! Know what you EAT!

seangoog

Tue, 27 Mar 2007 10:00:32 -0500

Doris

Mon, 26 Mar 2007 09:59:11 -0500

Kal Kan Petfood-Pedigree and Whiskas are all produced in their own factories are not affected by the recall. Their food has been cleared by the FDA.

SHELIA FINDLEY

Sun, 25 Mar 2007 21:41:27 -0500

I HAD TO PUT ONE OF MY DOGS TO SLEEP BEFORE THE RECALL. SHE HAD ALL THE THINGS GOING ON WITH HER BECAUSE OF THE DOG FOOD I WAS FEEDING HER. I HAD TO TAKE MY BOSTON TERRIER TO THE VET SHE WAS GETTING SICK TOO. I WOULD LIKE FOR SOMEONE WHO IS FILING A CLASS ACTION SUIT AGAINST MENU FOODS TO EMAIL ME AND TELL ME WHAT I NEED TO DO. EMAIL ADDRESS BRUCESHELIANICK@YAHOO.COM MY HEART IS BROKEN BECAUSE OF LOSING MY DOG AND I AM SURE THERE IS ALOT MORE HEARTS OUT THERE THAT ARE BROKEN TOO

S

Fri, 23 Mar 2007 12:46:26 -0500

Another fine example of global corporate greed. Top execs and stockholders make a few extra bucks to outsource their manufacturing and supplies to a 3rd World Country with no labor and safety regulations and this is what you get. I hope some of the folks who lost their pets are flag-waving Bush supporters because maybe it will wake up these ignorant Archie Bunkers to what's really going on in this country.

Bill Orange County

Fri, 23 Mar 2007 12:08:48 -0500

Well, now we see that death-star foods incorporated (oops, I mean Menu Foods) actually sold food for pets containing rat poison...the story is on the wire this morning. Menu Foods ( and its' "Income Fund") = Rat Poison and Death for your Pet.

kaitlyn

Thu, 22 Mar 2007 02:14:15 -0500

Not only that, but you all should know that only pouches and canned food made by iams and eukenuba are effected, the dry food, which i feed my pets, is not manufactured by menu foods at all.

kaitlyn

Thu, 22 Mar 2007 01:51:44 -0500

I think its really really disgusting that they show that picture of that small little kitten sleeping as though they have captured a dead cat who was poisoned by the food. Thats REALLY sick and disgusting. Thats not what a dead cat who dies from kidney failure looks like, and in fact that kitten looks a lot like my cat, who is thank GOD healthy. UGH im so disgusted.

Dan

Wed, 21 Mar 2007 23:57:36 -0500

Thats sick that those idiots have to kill 7 innocent cats just to see if their product is contaminated when all they had to do was a run a chemical dignastics test on the food, plus after they killed the cats those A-holes did not even pull the product off the shelves until it was made public about a week ago. They killed the cats on febuary 15th. Thats more than enough time to pull the product off the shelves. I hope those scientists become test subjects in hell for enternity.

ripley51

Wed, 21 Mar 2007 08:33:12 -0500

Once I came down off the ceiling over the recall and lack of coverage in my area (our local CTV affiliate started reporting the recall on Monday), I checked the actual Menu Foods website and was stunned at the wide range of products they supply. So what magic ingredients do they add to make Science Diet so much more expensive than Special Kitty? At a huge production facility I just can't see the transport trucks of free range chickens, or frozen lambs from New Zealand rolling and and being processed for Iams while still processing dead leghorn parts left over from the 99 cents a pound/thigh with leg attached sale at Sobey's. It would appear we are getting burned at the cash register. Call me naive, but I would never have thought that Iams would risk outsourcing.

tellsie

Wed, 21 Mar 2007 07:10:36 -0500

i received this email from Wellness last night: "We are aware that Menu Foods has initiated a recall. No products made by Wellness & Old Mother Hubbard are affected in any way. Again, no Wellness, Old Mother Hubbard, or Neura products are part of this recall. There are two very important factors in determining the quality of a food. The first is the manufacturer. In this case, Menu Foods is a top notch manufacturer that receives excellent scores for food safety and quality systems. They make a consistent product which is exactly what the company asks for. Frankly, they make product for so many companies because they are one of the best. The second factor is formula. Ingredient selection can make or break product quality. Certain ingredients can be allergens to certain pets. Other ingredients can be sourced for either their quality or their price. Chicken ingredients, for example, can be sourced at various prices. Low ash chicken, which is better for a cat, can be sourced at a higher price. Those are the types of ingredients we use, because they are of higher quality. So I would not assume all companies are created equal. If you'd like to learn more, please call us. We have much more information where that came from! Menu is a canning only facility. They do not handle any dry foods. Nicole Bibeau Specialist Consumer Affairs"

Elderta

Wed, 21 Mar 2007 00:34:05 -0500

Concerned Consumer, You are correct, there are many foods on the list, and some manufacturers use Menu Foods for some of their processes. I have said this several times today. I have not jumped to conclusions, but have posted only information that I can source. I have been reading information from the Yahoo FelineAsthma and WholeCatHealth lists, including emails members have received from some companies not on the list. I've read all the information from the one good source of much of this information, Howl911, and the information they have gathered. The email I posted earlier by Pet Food Express is a list of foods noted by a highly reputable store in San Francisco. If you read the posting from Pet Food Express, you will see that the information Aylana posted is the same as what is on Pet Food Express (see the Breeder's Choice entry) site, but the lists have been melded together. Hence the reason why I posted what I did. I have not been panicked by the media, because frankly, they haven't really been reporting on this. I'm sorry if I offended. Have a great night.

Maya

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 23:54:49 -0500

I think everyone has valid points here. Let me just tell you I am a veterinary nurse, and while everyone may have one part of the story, there are only A FEW reliable sources that have the whole story. These are the FDA and the USDA. I'm not saying they are saints, but the internet has gazillions of websites so it's impossible to find the truth in all those areas. Bottom line: let's not fight, let's go to the FDA and get the real story. ALSO please read the article "WHAT'S REALLY IN PET FOOD" - by API. They cite good sources and it's excellent info for pet owners. :)

Concerned Cosumer

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 23:20:09 -0500

This is what Elderta said " Alyana, you've gotten the lists mixed up :( They DO produce these foods or aspects of them: * IAMS/Eukanuba * Science Diet * Nutro/Nutro Ultra * Newman's Own Organics. They DO NOT produce these foods, though they do produce one portion of one product: * Canidae/Felidae * Natural Balance * Breeder's Choice/Pinnacle (except for Chicken and Oats formula which is made by Menu). * Triumph/Evolve * Merrick" Eldarta, please get your facts straight before you engage in discussion like this. Since you have absolutely no clue what Menu makes, it would be wise to find out before you continue to spread misinformation. When you finally manage to obtain the huuuuuge list of products that Menu manufactures, you will realize that 3/4 of the brands that are on the shelves are made by this company. As well, before you contribute to the mass hysteria, understand that many products made for human consumption have been recalled by the FDA many many years after being on the shelf. 1) If you recall there have been many recalls by Pharmaceutical companies of drugs which have been used for years and are later found to be linked to human deaths or illness. Finding a direct correlation between a death and a specific product is a complicated task. There is much more involved than simply jumping to conclusions. Animal and human health can be impacted by not only the food we eat, but also by the people or animals we come into contact with. IF someone died from lung cancer is the sole cause cigarettes or can it also be related to other environmental causes. All I am saying is that we have a responsibility here to think and to act on information, by spreading details we are unsure of and by disseminating "untruths" we are contributing to mass hysteria. For all, please exercise some sanity before jumping to irrational conclusions.

Elderta

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 22:02:06 -0500

And by the way, Natural Balance doesn't produce cuts and gravys foods. I have tried all of their products, and none are this type.

Elderta

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 22:01:11 -0500

OK, Aylana, but I feed my cat Natural Balance, and they are not produced by Menu Foods. That, I know for a fact, too. What is your source? Please? SAndy and Tammy, I really do not think people are overreacting. The company has known since Feb. 27th that animals were dying. They did not recall products until Marcy 16, on a Friday. Overreacting? I really don't think so. But of course, I could be wrong.

Tammy

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 21:45:51 -0500

People!! Take it easy! It's only cuts in gravy, not pate. There is a reason there is a recall - because they have identified a heath and safety issue. Be thankful!! Do you think this company meant to do this? Honestly, some people get totally absorbed by the press.

Sandy

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 21:41:44 -0500

Apparently Menu Foods actually manufactures more products than you think and have obviously done so for many many years without incident. I work in the pet treats market and have been told that they manufacture most canned foods in grocery and pet food stores, even the organic and healthy brands. This appears to be a supplier related incident and this is the first issue we have heard of. I am just glad they did the recall, precautionary or not. Did they have any other choice? They have a good reputation as far as I know. Everyone seems to be over-reacting and the media is hurting this more than anything.

Brightliner

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 21:28:48 -0500

I guess that's one bright side to our cat needing uber-expensive Hill's Prescription Diet food. Hill's probably wouldn't outsource their most expensive, most secret formulations. That kitten in the picture has huge paws. I can just imagine the caption: "You said you didn't like anchovies, right? *burp*"

Alyana

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 21:17:04 -0500

I know for a fact they produce wet products for all the brands I listed above... however, please remember that only cuts and gravy varieties are affected. This has been linked to wheat gluten, which is a functional ingredient used to form the chunks. That is why pate kind of products are not affected.

Elderta

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 21:09:30 -0500

Alyana, you've gotten the lists mixed up :( They DO produce these foods or aspects of them: * IAMS/Eukanuba * Science Diet * Nutro/Nutro Ultra * Newman's Own Organics. They DO NOT produce these foods, though they do produce one portion of one product: * Canidae/Felidae * Natural Balance * Breeder's Choice/Pinnacle (except for Chicken and Oats formula which is made by Menu). * Triumph/Evolve * Merrick

Alyana

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 20:49:24 -0500

Whiskas and Pedigree are not produced by Menu Foods... Menu produces: * IAMS/Eukanuba * Science Diet * Nutro/Nutro Ultra * Newman's Own Organics. * Canidae/Felidae * Natural Balance * Breeder's Choice/Pinnacle (except for Chicken and Oats formula which is made by Menu). * Triumph/Evolve * Merrick

benhuh

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 17:44:10 -0500

BTW, there is a class action law suit already under way. http://www.itchmo.com/read/menu-foods-class-action-being-organized_20070319

benhuh

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 17:43:16 -0500

If you want to follow up on the entire Menu Foods recall, go to www.itchmo.com, www.petconnection.com, or www.howl911.com The Menu Foods recall list has changed several times since it was posted on Saturday.

Elderta

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 17:38:40 -0500

PS... see the Howl911 site for an update about Wellness, second article from the top...

Elderta

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 17:36:02 -0500

Maya, no worries! I realize I'm getting a little hyper about all of this anyway and probably need to take a break! I think what happens is that some of these high-end companies outsource certain of their production/manufacturing processes, like you said. Does Wellness have wheat gluten? I guess that would be the key at the moment to this thing. I would probably continue to feed Wellness, but just be aware... though I'm not a vet and not even near being a vet! Wellness will probably tell you that they are not part of the recall, but you may have to specifically ask them if some of their manufacturing processes are connected to Menu... and see what they say. Good luck.

Maya

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 17:26:29 -0500

Elderta, just so you know I was certainly not accusing you but i'm panicked bc I feed Wellness to my cats! I have emailed OMH / wellness. I will call the FDA tomorrow. I must know. From what I understand Menu Foods may MANUFACTURE some of their food without owning it, in which case OMH should stop that practice or I will switch brands. The food I feed my cats is wheat / corn / grain free so I'm assured for now but I will switch if Wellness uses Menu foods. Thank you for bringing this to my attention!! It will protect my cats! :)

Elderta

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 17:13:19 -0500

Wait.. sorry, forgot this last part, my bad: There are several brands that are produced by Menue Foods-- Nature's Variety, Wellness, Wysong, Newman's Own Organics, and Innova-- that have not been recalled and that the parent companies assure us are safe to consume. we will sell them to people who understand the recall issues and accept possible risks. Please be clear, however, that we cannot vouch for the safety of these products at this time."

Elderta

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 17:09:55 -0500

Here is a copy of the email press release a member of the FelineAsthma Yahoo group got from pet food store Pet Food Express located in San Fran. All I'm saying is to be cautious because Menu Foods is obviously not being on the up the up about this crisis. Monday, March 19, 2007, 3:00 p.m. "Because we are not yet certain what the cause of the problem is, Pet Food Express has stopped selling all cans and pouches made by Menu Foods as a precaution, whether they contain wheat gluten or not. Furthermore, we are ceasing sales of all cans and pouches of every manufactureer until we are able to ascertain whether they were produced by Menue Foods, even those that have not been specifically recalled. The brands Pef Food Express currently carries and are withheld from sale are: * IAMS/Eukanuba * Science Diet * Nutro/Nutro Ultra * Kal Kan (Pedigree and Whiskas) * Newman's Own Organics. The brands that are not connected to Menu Foods and are available for purchase are: * Chicken Soup for the Pet Lover's Soul * Canidae/Felidae * Natural Balance * Breeder's Choice/Pinnacle (except for Chicken and Oats formula which is made by Menu). * Castor & Balance * Solid Gold * Triumph/Evolve * Merrick

tellsie

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 17:03:59 -0500

Is there a list some where of foods that ARENT made by Menu Foods? On the Wellness website it says: "Wellness and Old Mother Hubbard products are NOT affected by the recent Menu Foods product recall". It doesn't say specifically that they are not involved with Menu Foods, which you would think it would if that were indeed the case?

Elderta

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 17:00:15 -0500

Maya, the link to the article is from here: http://www.insidebayarea.com/sanmateocountytimes/localnews/ci_5477581 The title to the article on Howl911 (in bold print) on the right sidebar says: WELLNESS, NATURES VARIETY ALSO MADE BY MENU FOODS... with a link to the article. I would not link anything here that is detrimental. People on the Yahoo FelineAsthma and Yahoo WholeCatHealth lists have mentioned that Wellness and Nature's Variety do have manufacturing links to Menu Foods but are not part of the recall. I wanted to point out that there is some confusion about this. I am not and would not be loosey goosey about this stuff. The FDA and everyone esle has been caught offguard by this incident. Vets do not know for sure what is going on because they can't get the information from the company. All I'm pointing out is that there is some issue pointed out on the Howl911 site regarding this.

Maya

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 16:43:42 -0500

I did not notice that info on the howl911 site, but for accurate information the loosey goosey stuff on the internet is not the best place to look. Wellness is owned by Old Mother Hubbard, a private company in MA and have nothing to do with Menu foods as far as I know. The only way to be sure is to ask the FDA or the USDA. They make and enforce laws on this stuff.

Elderta

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 15:41:23 -0500

Please note that I have read on the Howl911 site that Wellness and Nature's Variety are made by Menu Foods though not part of the recall. I have no idea what this means. The link is in the right sidebar on the Howl911 site.

Kari

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 15:01:19 -0500

ps Hills Science Diet and Purina have voluntarily recalled a few of their products as well - they apparently worked in tandem with Iams for a few of their products.

La Leone

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 14:06:50 -0500

Oh no! All those myriad single women who have rejected Spud Spudly now have to deal w/a cheap shot from him! It's sad when someone so bitter infers that loving a pet means, for whatever reason, that they are without a romantic relationship with another human. So stupid. Cats are so prevelant in NYC. People of all types and relationships statuses have them. Duh. * Seriously though, my heartfelt thoughts to all of those whose animals have died or are presently ill. This is horible - incomprehensible.*

Kari

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 13:55:38 -0500

I am a certified veterinary nurse, and I would love to fill people in on a few things. 1. Another pet food called Diamond was also recalled after their food's corn was contaminated. Grains such as wheat and corn are not necessary (sometimes even harmful) for pets. Rice is a better grain for pets. 2. There is an underlying problem that people don't have the resources to learn about cat and dogs' specific nutritional needs. 3. Please read the article called "what's really in pet food" put out by API. ps I use Wellness pet food. Worth looking into.

Elderta

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 12:52:02 -0500

The companies involved have said that they will reimburse those who lost their pets (both men and women who have dogs and cats). This probably includes vet bills at the least, if those whose pet owners who have been affected (which may actually be in the thousands of both dogs and cats) can actually document the losses. This is a Canadian company, btw, so I guess Canada sux, too. In a case like this, where is seems the company knew as early as December that something was wrong, and didn't issue a recall until three weeks AFTER their own tests killed animals in their labs, that a lawsuit is certainly in order, whether it feeds the pockets of lawyers or not. As to Spudly's 'joke,' I would suggest one take a look at the Gothamist thread from 3/17 (see "Most Commented") from the numerous MEN and WOMEN who have lost DOGS and CATS, including MikeKeen whose dog died last night. Save the unfunny jokes for Naomi Campbell. This is literally a matter of life and death.

Red Stapler

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 12:44:00 -0500

That kitty-on-a-pizza-box picture is too cute for words. Nice one, photoperson!

america sux

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 12:39:09 -0500

what kind of damages can you get for a dead cat? Is it going to be worth any lawyer's time to actually litigate this? I smell class-action: lawyers will get millions and the plaintiffs get coupons for more pet food!

Spud Spudly

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 11:31:50 -0500

Oh no! What will all those single women worry about now if their cats are dead???

bulk

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 10:57:43 -0500

cat pizza is very morbid.

Lexiphane

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 10:39:29 -0500

I thought the correct term was Masshole? Now it's Gay Stater? Sorry, spring training baseball makes me antsy. I [heart] MA.

jg

Tue, 20 Mar 2007 10:22:38 -0500

"one Massachusetts"? what happens when you have two Massachusetts? (ps. according to wikipedia, the correct term for a person from Massachusetts is a "Bay Stater". I know, confusing. maybe just call her a Massachusetts resident.)