
If you happened to miss it this week, you should take a good look at Peter Meehan's exploration of New York barbecue. Aside from giving us enough 'cue porn to make meat lovers swoon and vegetarians squirm, Meehan provides a thorough overview of the barbecue landscape, including spots in Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens, the Bronx, and Wingdale, just a short ways upstate (sorry, Staten Island).
He gives a special nod to Daisy May's BBQ, calling it the "most consistent and distinctive of all New York barbecue spots." He highlights the Big Pig Gig, a custom-cooked feast of a whole or half pig, and awards the rack of lamb, "rubbed with a simple chili-inflected and mustard-based paste, cooked to a perfect tenderness, gently flavored with smoke," a virtual blue ribbon, dubbing it "the single best barbecue in the greater metropolitan area." He is quick to add that "it sits atop a heap of great ’cue."
Meehan's recommendations for where to go depend on what you're seeking. For St. Louis style pork ribs, Mo Gridder’s; for beef ribs, Ranger Texas Barbecue or The Smoke Joint; for chicken, Big W’s; for super-smoky meats, R.U.B., and for pulled pork, Pies ’n’ Thighs. But is the city becoming too over-saturated with barbecue? Only time will tell, but for now, we'll ponder the question while gnawing on a pork rib.
Photo from Jen Chung's photostream on flickr.





RUB is overcooked, tasteless garbage. The baby backs were tough and stuck to its own ribs rather than mine.
i had good stuff at bluesmoke. my friend and i split 4 entrees: smoked texas beef brisket, baby back ribs, st louis and kansas city ribs. of the four, my favorite was the texas smoked beef brisket. it was INSANELY good, and am digesting myself right now just thinking about it. I have heard about the whole pig bbq and definitely want to try it.
there's no such thing as too much bbq
Why does it seem that everytime someone goes to review barbecue he must turn into an opining soliloquy asshole by the end of it?
Feeds only 12 people or less? That's not a pig. That's a piglet.
I agree with Sam. There is *no such thing* as too much barbeque.
Again with the whole roasted pig fetish on Gothamist!!!!!!
Again with Gothamist's whole roasted pig fetish!!!!!