Report Says Police Get Off Too Easy

The Civilian Complaint Review Board issued a report that finds many police officers are only getting "slaps on the wrist" versus actual punishment after the CCRB brings cases against them. For instance, 75% of police officer who are "reprimanded for such offenses as improper searches usually got instructions on improving their conduct," which is 34% higher than three years ago. The "lenient" punishment is doled out when the offenses do not involve weapons or physical force. The NYPD says that the ability of the public to call 311 and make unsubstantiated complaint has played a part in the increase, though the CCRB says that they didn't think the complaints were to retaliate against certain officers. The Sun offered this explanation of how the CCRB works:

After a complaint is registered with the board, investigators interview witnesses, the complainant, and any police officers mentioned in the complaint. The board, which is made up of five mayoral designees, five City Council designees, and three police commissioner designees, then makes a decision on the case and recommends a level of punishment. Punishment usually ranges from verbal warnings to a period of suspension, known as "command discipline."

The police commissioner is not bound by any determination of the board, and so on receiving the determination, he makes a decision as to whether the officer is guilty — often through an internal trial system — and what punishment the officer should receive.

In June, the CCRB found that while police misconduct was down, verbal reprimands were still more likely to be given as punishment.

Related: Christopher Dunn and Donna Lieberman of the NYCLU have an essay in the Daily News that recommends the creation of " independent agency to review all on-duty police shootings of civilians."

Email This Entry


Comments (10) [rss]

"many police officers are only getting "slaps on the wrist" versus actual punishment"

No Shit

Why can't they give me the money they wasted making this report?

user-pic

Several years ago I dated a girl who worked as an investigator with the CCRB. Most of the cases they investigated were of crack dealin' domestic violence assholes who got roughed up by the police and then filed a complaint.

In oher instances the CCRB investigated "false" searches on people who were suspected of dealing drugs, drunk driving, disorderly conduct, and a slew of other violent offences.

The people making most of the complaints are people who have constant run-ins with the law or are excons looking to get back at "the man".

Wow, no punishment for cops. that's a surprise.
Where's the punishment for illegal parking of vehicles and don't tell me it's allowed per contract.
Thank goodness for technology with Private security cameras everywhere. I'm not talking bout the citicorp cameras but private citizen cameras. The hidden one's.
Never Again.

user-pic

edEx, you had a girlfriend? I thought your hate extended to women also...

user-pic

i love it! hate mail not in my inbox!!!

They arrest turnstile-jumpers on the theory that big time criminals also commit small time crime. Why doesn't the same theory apply to their own workforce?

Exactly, The good cops should have nothing to fear.
It's the persistant bad cop that's the danger and if the CCRB does not see that, then there's a problem.
Never again.

user-pic

there a few cops that got suspended without pay after a full investigation, but it unlikely and here's why:

think of the ccrb as defense attorneys. most defense attorneys i know or are aquainted with *cough* "try their best" to get the crook off of his charges (it depends on the severity of the crime, if they have murdered someone and all the evidence points to them and they still plead 'not guilty' they're going to prison [with the exception of oj]).

most of the people lodging complaints are excons or repeat offenders. so, naturally the ccrb will take each complaint with a grain of salt. as i stated earlier, my girlfriend used to tell me about some of the cops.... 99% of them are clean with no complaints against them, they're good cops. then there's that small percentage of cops that are bad asses... who don't nec. have a list of complaints, but have a rep of roughing... but then again most of the complaints are from people with extensive rap sheets who think they have the upper hand... quite frankly most of these perps need a good tune up before getting locked up.

When did Gothamist become NYPD rant?
Can you pepper your posts with more LEO jargon?
By the way, where's that fourth guy and the missing gun?
NEVER AGAIN!

I had a friend that worked as an investigator there, and he always told me that while a large number of the complaints were made by crazy people, there were often some legit complaints. But, he said everyone knew it was essentially a sham - recommendations were generally ignored.

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

Get your daily dose of New York first thing in the morning from our weekday newsletter, now in beta.

About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung
Publisher: Jake Dobkin

Newsmap

newsmap.jpg

Contribute

Latest Tip:

Saving Public Housing By Building Anew
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS

Follow us