"Final" Group of September 11 Tapes Released

2006_08_911listen.jpg

Yesterday, the Fire Department released 1,613 phone calls made to fire and EMS dispatchers, and the calls are just heartbreaking. The Mayor explained why the calls had been withheld by the city - they were only released upon a lawsuit - saying, "The real issue here is to protect the families...[was it] really is worth putting the families through reliving the grief that I think none of the rest of us would possibly imagine." At any rate, he apologized for the delay in the tapes' release, which he blamed on a Fire Department manager (way to pass the buck). But the victims' families are listening to the tapes in hopes that lessons can be learned. The NY Times notes what the Sally Regenhard, mother of Christian Regenhard, a firefighter who was killed at the South Tower, said:

“It took five years to hear a scintilla of confirmed information,” Mrs. Regenhard said, adding that many public officials had demanded fast explanations for Con Edison’s performance during the recent blackout in Queens, but that few had broached the question of the emergency response on Sept. 11.
Melissa Doi, the 32 year old woman whose 911 call was played during Zacarias Moussaoui's trial, and the 911 operator who tried the comfort her are the subject of an editorial in the NY Sun: "Yesterday, [Doi's] voice testified to something else — to the way in which the unique spirit of New Yorkers allowed glimmers of light to shine through even on that darkest of sunny summer days...[T]he operator was New York at its best, both compassionate and pragmatic, and unwilling to give up so long as there was any hope onto which to hold." And Newsday has a transcript of her call. The NY Times has an extensive site about the 9/11 Records.

Photograph of firefighter Al Fuentes, left, who was trapped in the World Trade Center rubble but escaped, and Al and Sally Regenhard, parents of firefighter Christian Regenard, who was killed in theTrade attacks, from Kathy Willens/AP

Email This Entry


Comments (4) [rss]

PLEASE, Jen. Take the extra 30 seconds to proofread your posts. "The" and "to", "was" and "what" - not interchangeable. I think your site is pretty good on getting stories of interest, but the sloppy writing has gone well beyond a few annoying typos and is approaching making the site unreadable.

I have absolutely no desire to hear these tapes. Anyone who was in the city knows exactly what happened that day. I don't have to hear it--I lived it. These recordings should be put away for future generations (who weren't there) to let them know what happened but not played now---it's too soon.

user-pic

Hal - speak for yourself. Everyone processes these events at different rates. Just because you're not ready to hear them doesn't mean others shouldn't be either.

user-pic

To add to Hal2814's comment...

Not only don't I want to hear them but if Good Morning America (or anyone else) is going to play them, give me a warning so I can change the channel. I'm surprised that in their coverage of the story this week, they weren't more sensitive to the fact that many people don't want to listen to the recordings.

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

Get your daily dose of New York first thing in the morning from our weekday newsletter, now in beta.

About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung
Publisher: Jake Dobkin

Newsmap

newsmap.jpg

Contribute

Latest Tip:

NY Senate voting on marriage equality right now
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS

Follow us