Free Speech - With Suspension - For City Imam

Umar Abdul-Jalil, the city's top chaplain and a Muslim imam, was suspended for two weeks for controversial remarks given at an out-of-state speech. When the NY Post published that Abdul-Jalil said "the greatest terrorists in the world occupy the White House" (plus referred to "the Zionists of the media"), a furor erupted over what a city employee should or should not say. Mayor Bloomberg (and his advisers) ultimately decided that the comments warranted only a suspension, because though he erred by not clarifying that he was not speaking as a representative of the city, he should have the opportunity to speak freely. Here were the Mayor's comments:

"I certainly don't agree with that view, but the issue here is not do I agree with him, but does he have a right to say what he wants to say At the same time, we have an obligation to ensure that city employees do not falsely represent their political statements as the official position of their agency."
And then he criticized both the right and the left for being overzealous in watchdoging speech for being unpatriotic or not politically correct enough. Ah, this is the Mayor Bloomberg we like - not quite liberal enough for Democrats, not conservative enough for Republicans and trying to find the political middle! At any rate, the Mayor made sure he had backup at the press conference: Three Jewish chaplains appeared for support.

Abdul-Jalil will appeal the sentence, as his lawyer Norman Siegel insists that it's clear Abdul-Jalil was not speaking on behalf of the city while Abdul-Jalil himself says that people have said worse things. Honestly, Gothamist thinks we hear worse vitriol - from all sides - on cable news and talk radio, but when the "offenders" are black, Muslim men who work for the city - it is a perfect political hot potato. Naturally, the NY Post is upset by this decision and ridicules the Mayor for giving New Yorkers a lesson on free speech. Well, people do need it at times. And for a refresher, here's the U.S. Constitution.

Photograph from NY Post

Email This Entry


Comments (5) [rss]

user-pic

But it's okay for Bloomberg to call the TWU thugs during the strike? I'm pretty sure he was representing the city when he said that, yeah?

user-pic

TWU is not a race (thugs is surely a right word for people who break the law and carry out illegal actions).

This chaplain talked about "jews controlling the media" and other typical Hamas/Al-Qaida/Far-left BS.

user-pic

deng -

my point was that if the imam if going to get suspended for ANY of what he said - whether it had to do with race or saying the bush admin is chock full of terrorists - than the mayor should be held to the same standards. And calling a bunch of city employees thugs when the mayor, unlike the imam, was definitely doing city business, is messed up.

user-pic

how the hell is "jews controlling the media" far-leftist?

user-pic

k: TWU people are thugs. They broke the law. Saying that aloud is fine. Racist hate-speech like jews are controlling the world or blacks are subhuman is a bit different story.

sp: Isn't that pretty much what Micheal Moore, Cindy Sheegan and all those far-left wackos always say?

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

Get your daily dose of New York first thing in the morning from our weekday newsletter, now in beta.

About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung
Publisher: Jake Dobkin

Newsmap

newsmap.jpg

Contribute

Latest Tip:

It's the same media that NEVER mentioned Muslims' hatred of Israel as a possible motive for 9/11.
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS

Follow us