18 Year Old Charged with 4 Year Old's Murder

2006_01_calderon.jpgThe 18 year old boyfriend of Aleshia Smith, Jose Calderon, was charged with the murder of Smith's 4 year old son, Quachon Brown. Calderon was angry at Brown for knocking over a TV, and beat him from Friday until Sunday, when the boy died. Smith was arrested for manslaughter, as she did nothing to prevent her son's death. The abuse inflicted on Brown over the weekend is terrifying. Here's an approximate timeline of events, based on reports from the Daily News, Post, and NY Times:

- Friday: Brown knocks over TV; Calderon punched and slammed Brown (the Times writes Calderon "grabbed him by the ankles, swung him and hurled him into the wall"), and repeated this over the weekend.
- Saturday: The family goes to Chuck E. Cheese, where Brown vomits blood; Calderon beats him again
- Sunday/Monday: Brown soils the bed and Calderon tries to revive him; Calderon and Smith argue about calling 911
- Monday: Paramedics detemine Brown has been dead for hours, based on his 83 degree body temperature [NY Times]
Yesterday, the Times also had a story about neighbors helping Smith - until Calderon moved into the apartment (a quote from a friend of Calderon's backs up his story about the TV falling on the child; but police interviews with Smith's other children seem to confirm Calderon beat Brown). Further, the depressing but now unsurprising news is that the Administration for Children's Service was notified 6 times about the living conditions for Smith's six children, though they had no record of knowing Calderon was living in the home. These stories of abuse are so upsetting - can an additional $17 million really help out? As poor a job as the ACS has been doing, it must be one of the worst jobs to have, to confront these things day after day.

Photograph of Calderon from the NY Times

Email This Entry


Comments (9) [rss]

6 children??! I saw this woman on the news comment on what a rough time the mom had because of her 6 kids...like this can't be avoided? Why why why do people spawn children that can't care for? You can't entirely blame the ACS when people obviously know nothing about birth control.

Agree with above comment on birth control. The agency can't take all the blame. The ACS doesn't have a lot of resources to cover every troubled home. This is not to say they're doing a bang-up job though.


who else can help if there'd no ACS available? is ACS the child's only hope?

user-pic

This is ridiculous. If a man abuses his wife, the police are the ones that show up at the door, not some social service agency. Why is child abuse not treated the same way with law enforcement personnel as the first point of contact rather than some administrative service. This is heart-breaking.

Sometimes the cops show up in addition to ACS. Theoretically, ACS is supposed to investigate every alleged incident of child abuse, ranging from a small burn or bruise to a severe beating or fatality. You can't have the cops show up everytime a kid burns his finger on the stove and a neighbor thinks a parent did it. In a city as big as NY with few resources, you have to allocate resources accordingly, at least for the first visit. Visiting as many times as ACS did with the Brown/Calderon family and not doing anything is inexcusable.

user-pic

It's times like these I wish we had the death penalty. That may be an unpopular viewpoint but what kind of punishment can we give these psychopaths that fit? Death is the only thing these non-humans deserve.

God Damn!!!!

Obviously, this is incredibly heartbreaking. It almost makes me tear up. I am so sad.

And I wonder what can we do as a society to help prevent these things from happening. One thing that seems really important would be to get rid of, and or treat, all of the things, reasons, and issues that would precipitate someone like Calderon doing what he did.

This dude is obvs a maniacal lunatic. I mean, the anger inside him is just incredible.
Totally, we can lock them up, and it appears Calderon needs to be. But what are we gonna do to prevent people like this developing as Calderon did. What are we gonna do to prevent these situations from happening again, and again, and again.

Can we do anything? Is this guy a product of violence, poverty, and other such things that help prevent someone from developing as a healthy person? And if he is, do we bare responsibilty for
that? Or is it completely out of our hands?

Jesus christ.
This is so f*cked.

Throw him by the ankles into the wall?
Why don't they take Calderon and throw HIM into a wall. Or maybe big bubba can do that for him later..

I don't think any amount of money can save a child from moronic animal parents and the scum they associate with...they are born into a nightmare and then have to face abuse which creates another cycle..then they grow up and do the same thing..its very sad.

user-pic

I hope society can see the effects of no-fault divorce and "mom's boyfriends" have on children.

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

Get your daily dose of New York first thing in the morning from our weekday newsletter, now in beta.

About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung
Publisher: Jake Dobkin

Newsmap

newsmap.jpg

Contribute

Latest Tip:

Williamsburg post office bites. 33 people on line!
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS