know how to shop effectively. Despite having 1.1 million students to purchase books for, the Daily News is reporting that the DoE is paying on average roughly $1.76 more per book than a shopper "who choose the lowest-priced book on Amazon.com or Barnes &" />

Surprise! The Department of Education Overpays For Books

2006_01_22_tweedcourthouse.jpgApparently, the Department of Education doesn't know how to shop effectively. Despite having 1.1 million students to purchase books for, the Daily News is reporting that the DoE is paying on average roughly $1.76 more per book than a shopper "who choose the lowest-priced book on Amazon.com or Barnes & Noble's Web site."

To be fair, the News skews the numbers just a smidge to make the DoE look worse than it actually is. When purchasing text books and required-reading books the DoE works with an exact number of books that are needed. Those numbers are so large that, according to Deputy Chancellor Kathleen Grimm, "when we buy on that scale, we have been able to get tremendous prices."

It's the $36 million worth of the books that Teachers are given discretion to order through a system called Fastrack where the city bleeds cash ("David Copperfield" on Amazon? $2.58, on FastTrack? $5.94).

That a city department that runs out of the Tweed Courthouse overspends on something should come as no surprise to anyone. But needless to say, the DoE says it's "in the process of installing"a newer system to better take advantage of good deals.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • Yeah, I did see that the News wasn't going by ISBN numbers, but, y'know, who wants to let facts get in the way of a good DoE bashing?

    As for the $31.50, uhm, you might call it a typo. I prefer the second option. Those Gothamist Gremlins struck again!

  • Jesse

    ("David Copperfield" on Amazon? $31.50, on FastTrack? $5.94).

    Huh? I thought your numbers were flipped, but clicking through, the Amazon link shows a price of $2.something. Typo? Gremlins?

  • Anonymous

    Did you note how the Daily News reporter just picked the cheapest copy of the title from Amazon.com and compared it to something on the DOE catalog without matching up the ISBN? This was NOT an apples to apple comparison. She could very well be comparing a heavily annotated, well-edited Norton edition of David Copperfield (which admittedly is pricier) to a cheap tradebook paperback. I would hope that any teacher worth their salary takes into consideration the edition of the text that they choose to use in the classroom.

    When you compare apples to apples, sometimes Amazon is cheaper but many times the DOE prices are better.

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@gothamist.com