Joe's Pizza Shuts Its Doors

2004_10_joes.jpg

If you're coming late to the pizza party, brace yourselves, Joe's Pizza on the corner of Bleecker and Carmine in the Village is sclosing up shop. Curbed and Slice had coverage on Friday, with Curbed breaking the news and Slice confirming the story. It seems like rising rents have closed another established presence in the West Village. Known for their quality slices, Joe Pozzuoli says he was unable to stay after a 1666% increase in his $900 rent for the 240 sq. ft. space.

Some fans may be happy to know that Pozzuoli has another Joe's location on Carmine street too. Adam over at slice was quoted in the Post about the other location, "It's not the same. I mean, the pizza is the same, but the place is different. [The original's] got that rundown charm." For some reason, they have Adam's last name at Kubar. Clearly, they didn't read the Gothamist Interview with Adam.

Earlier this year, Zito & Sons, also on Bleecker, closed due to rising rents. Gothamist on Zito & Sons and Tenant.net on what residential tenants can do about a rent overcharge.

Email This Entry


Comments (21) [rss]

Disgusting! I was just talking to friends the other day about how the west village hasn't been as gentrified as the east... maybe i'm dreaming... Another New York institution gone.

1666% - the rent increase of SATAN!

i used to live 2 blocks away from joe's (bedford btw carmine/downing) and would pick up $2 slices constantly. for dinner when i was feeling poor, for a snack, because it smelled good when i walked by, because i liked the pizza guys inside, because i was wasted drunk, because it was fucking good. ... for all kinds of reasons. i estimated that i'd eaten 5,000 slices from there over 2 1/2 years.. but then tien pointed out to me that that would be like $10k.. so.. it probably wasn't that many, but it was A LOT.

I cant imagine what is goign to go in there, but it's not going to be as good. there was nothing like grabbing a slice then sitting in father demo square (watch out for the herds of pigeons) and people watching. i wonder who is going to pay that much rent. i used to love the turquacino like a block away down bleecker, then it closed and sat empty for about a year until i moved away.. it might still be empty now.

im sure a pizza hut or dominos will gladly take over

You should point out that this was the location used as the place Peter Parker delivered pizzas for in Spider-man 2.

user-pic

Ugh, this sucks. I will have lunch there everyday until they shut their doors.

the best pizza in NYC EVER... so depressing. Mostly because it'll be gone before I get back to NYC. No final slice for me... sigh. You think a pie would FedEx well?

I think that should read 660% increase in rents, not 66%. The Post article says the rent is going from $900 to $15,000. Yikes!

user-pic

well, it should be something like eliot pointed out.

Sigh. I guess the original rumors we heard back in August were, in fact, true. Very, very upset about this one, but I guess I'll now have to give the "other" Joe's a try. It's such a shame when rent increases drive out local treasures.

Relax, relax. Joe's new storefront is three doors up the block. Not quite the same charm, but the same great pizza. After 20 years of rent breaks, how sad can one really be?

News to foodies and yuppies. You're part of the reason this city is dying. And this is a great example of that happening.

The Waverly theater is gone. Zitos too. This whole city is being dismantled to provide more housing for yuppies. And you know what? In a few years everything that makes this city great will be killed and hollowed out for housing.

You'll finally be able to live here! But is it really living?

Also to "Real New Yorker":
"I was just talking to friends the other day about how the west village hasn't been as gentrified as the east..."

Is that a joke? The West Village has ALWAYS been gentrified AND more expensive.

dismantled for yuppies? what are you talking about -- all the yuppies live in Brooklyn now. As for Joe's, sorry to see it go and I wonder what will replace it for $15,000 a month, but why the dramatic increase? Did it not have rent control and if that's the case, how did it manage $900 in rent?

Not all the yuppies live in Brooklyn. Trust me - plenty of us poor folk live there, too.

Hell, if all the yuppies live in Brooklyn, who lives in Manhattan? Oh yeah, that's right - loaded yuppies, trustafarians and college kids living 3 to a room.

user-pic

That's bs about the rent increase and all, but Joe's pizza sucked.

just got back with two slices of the "new" joes....damn it wasn't nearly as good...i've been going here since jr high... an end of an era indeed....

*sigh*

ps. j you dont know shite so, suggit.

Stop blaming the yuppies. Did you think that the coolest place on earth was just for you? The city is dying? The yuppies moving in sure don't think so. Maybe they appreciate it more than you.

Dazzle not true walk from 7th ave south down to the water and count how many chains you see as compared to the east village. no comparison. many long time residents here as well. real new yorkers!

why the dramatic increase? Did it not have rent control

Word had it the old landlord built a 20-year rent freeze into the building, so when he passed away and the property was sold, all his tenants could stay. Let's be serious: $900/month for storefront corner rent is ridiculous in this town.

just got back with two slices of the "new" joes....damn it wasn't nearly as good

You're just talking yourself out of it. Over the summer I got a slice from each for comparison's sake, and they both tasted great.

Eshan, the yuppies moving into this city are like adoring/smothering parents. They love you. They only want the best for you. But they don't know when enough is enough and their constant attention actually ends up hurting things in the end. Anyone who has lived in this city for at least 5 years know the place is not as great as it once was. And it's not like 5 years ago things were shitty and needed gentrification to the level we have now.

The West Village has always been gentrified. It's laughable to think otherwise. And while I'm sad the old Joe's storefront is gone, they're quite good at their new place. In fact even in Park Slope, the Joe's of Bleeker near President Street has one of the best slices you can buy in Brooklyn South. Right next to Fascati's on Henry Street as far as quality goes.

I think this whole rent story is crap...they got run out of town by Bleeker St. Pizza on the corner of 7th and Bleeker...grab yourself a slice of the "Nonna Maria" and you'll know what pizza is all about.

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

Get your daily dose of New York first thing in the morning from our weekday newsletter, now in beta.

About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung
Publisher: Jake Dobkin

Newsmap

newsmap.jpg

Contribute

Latest Tip:

years of isiah thomas stories in chant form http://www.nydailynews.com/sports/college/2009/11/14/20
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS