September 15, 2004
Your Night of Drunken Hijinks Paid for My Floodgate, Fool!
I've been sitting on this MetaFilter post since yesterday: Hurricane Risk for New Orleans. Surely you've noticed even Drudge has gotten whipped into a 10,000 BODYBAGS!! frenzy. As a Louisianian, I appreciate the interest--until it devolves into rubbernecking, or when people start trotting out the same old "It's a corrupt city that will never get its act together," "anyone who lives there is an idiot," let 'em all die BS.
Everything you've heard about New Orleans geography is true. Yes, it's under sea level. It's surrounded by water (the Mississippi, Lake Ponchartrain, various swamps and, not too far off, the actual Gulf of Mexico). It's also shaped like a "bowl" and sinks something like six inches into the mud every year. And should a major hurricane come barreling directly up the river and into the city, all hell would break loose.
Okay, now let me talk you down from the ledge. The center of Hurricane Ivan is projected to strike near Mobile, Alabama. The storm track has never put New Orleans in direct danger of receiving the eye of the storm. It's going to be a mess, but I don't think this is the Storm of the Century that will, in the words of my dad, have people swimming like sewer rats in the French Quarter. The west side of any hurricane is where you want to be. The thunderstorms will be generally be weaker and the SSE winds moves the storm surge out, not in. That said, Ivan has a ginormous eye, and you don't want to be anywhere near the eyewall--that's where all of the heaviest storms, highest winds, and tornadoes are.
So, even though Ivan isn't tracking up the Mississippi, I'm really glad my peeps have made the drive on I-10 home, near Lafayette, where we're in the Tropical Storm Warning area. In fact, I'm kind of jealous. The last time we evacuated together, for Hurricane Andrew (which hit Louisiana after it hit Florida), we stayed up in my Aunt's house eating gumbo and talking all night. Wow. How, like, totally stereotypical of us.
Finally--the MeFi thread also took Louisianians to task for not "demanding" that flood walls and levees be built. Let me tell you a little story about the Army Corps of Engineers. Actually, let this PBS story on The Flood of 1927 and this article from Tulane tell you why the federal government has screwed up our river system and made our flood problems worse by fixing the path of the Mississippi. Added bonus? Widespread coastal erosion. No more free-flowing river = no more delta deposits. This Slate article also mentions some of the Corps' more recent scandales. And regarding floodgates, well, anyone who's seen the New Orleans episode of Insomniac with Dave Attell knows that a very friendly guy named Ellis mans the floodgates--when he's not watching musicals.
Anyway, let's focus on the people in and around Mobile, Alabama, who are going to bear the brunt of Ivan around 1 AM tomorrow morning, not on deciding whether New Orleans "deserves" to survive.
Related: New Orleans Times-Picayune special report, Washing Away and a New York Times story from 2002 (archived at hurricane.lsu.edu)




For anyone else with family or friends in the New Orleans area, you can actually watch WWL's nonstop hurricane coverage live on the internet:
http://www.wwltv.com/cgi-bin/bi/video/wmPlayer.pl?title=beloint_wwltv&props=livenoad
If that link doesn't work, go to wwltv.com and you'll see the link. It plays within the browser, but you probably needs Windows Media Player for it.
(You get the local commercials, too : )
After finally making my first trip to the big easy this past weekend seeing people swimming like sewer rats isn't all that rare, just look at them at 6 am in the morning.
It is this recent trip that has me tuned to the tube to make sure that everyone gets out okay. It's a great city. And look at the records of the weather people, even if it was set to make landfall on top of new orleans, would have nevermade it. Remember when Ivan hit Florida proper? Yea, that was a blast.
leslita,
i was watching WWL streams all day yesterday. i love it when they interviewed the serious hillbillies in the bayou and not even the reporter had a clue what the person said. not to mention those crazy off-road wheelchair commercials.
Then I switched to a Mobile station but the stream seems to be dead at the moment. Give it a shot later. Another fun one is the stream from Mobile police radio.
here are some excellent info-graphix on "the bowl" phenomenon:
http://www.nola.com/hurricane/images/nolalevees_jpg.jpg
http://www.nola.com/hurricane/images/goingunder_jpg.jpg
part 2 of the Times-Picayune is particularly horrifying.
i was glued to WWL, too.
here's an interesting tidbit: the Red Cross doesn't open shelters anymore in New Orleans, apparently because they find the city just too unsafe. i wonder if that has anything to do with what happened the last time the Superdome was turned into a shelter, for Hurricane Georges:
"In 1998, people showed up with insufficient or no food, and complained when the Dome served them hot dogs and orange juice. When kept from leaving after the storm because of a curfew, shouting matches erupted with security and police. Some occupants hauled off televisions and furniture."
http://www.theadvertiser.com/newsupdate/html/DEE50643-B81F-410B-AE81-5F63067E47C1.shtml
I also read reports about graffiti in '98--and have heard a rumor about people ripping up stadium seats and throwing them around--but I can't track down a URL. Good thing the mayor frisked everyone for guns and alcohol on the way in yesterday, eh?
i also read yesterday that NO did open a shelter in the Superdome, but only for the elderly and people with special needs:
Maybe their prior experience you describe is the reason for such draconian policies. But to turn away ANYONE to go out into the bad weather with a storm coming seems absolutely ridiculous.
But nothing's crazier than the mayor's recommendation to poor people without cars that they go to tall buildings
Yeah... in these orange alert days of terror, I can really see the security guard at GlobalCoInc Tower welcoming in the bands of underclass carrying sleeping bags and flashlights to zoom on up in the glass elevator to the 40th floor and make themselves at home.
The whole scenario sounds like a concept for a really bad disaster flick.
In general shelters are sparse accomodations with nothing guaranteed other than minimal food & water. Beds aren't a sure thing. Pets and booze aren't allowed. The idea is it's a last resort. If they make them too nice, there's a subsegment of people who will never leave.