Got a Tip?
tips at gothamist
About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung Publisher: Jake Dobkin

About Us & Advertising | Archives | Contact | Mobile | RSS | Staff

Favorites
Newsmap
Contribute

Latest tip:

Red Sox in the ALCS!!! Where are the Stankees?? [more]

 

Latest link:

 

Latest Photo:

 

Subscribe
Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS

July 12, 2004

Hamilton-Burr Duel Redux

Antonio Burr and Douglas Hamiltion reenact their ancestors' duel; Photo: AP, Marko Georgiev

In a boon for history buffs and duel enthusiasts, in honor of the 200th anniversary of the most famous fight in American history (with pistols - not chads), the Alexander Hamilton-Aaron Burr duel was reenacted in Weehawken, NJ. You remember it from your history/social studies books in grade school - Thomas Jefferson's Vice-President Aaron Burr and Treasury Secretary Alexander Hamilton hated each other (even though Burr and Hamilton shared a law practice early on, Burr blamed losing the presidency on Hamiltion's doings) and decided to duel. This was crazy to Gothamist the first time we learned about it, sometime in the fourth grade , because what politicians go around killing people - in the broad daylight, that is. Now, NY and NJ residents got to get their "recreate ye olde days" jones on, as Douglas Hamilton, fifth great grandson of Hamilton, and Antonio Burr, descended from Burr's cousin, played the roles of their ancestors in a recreation of the duel, complete with pistols (with blanks). There was a really great NY Times article about the preparation for the duel, as well as ingoing emotions from the Hamilton and Burr descendants, historians, and town of Weehawken, in the Times last week. Apparently Weehawken's 40% Hispanic population contributed to the interest in a duel and Douglas Hamilton fell to his knee "instead of staggering around and resting wounded on a rock as his ancestor did" because some older relatives didn't want Alexander Hamilton to look so low again. Also, various busts of Alexander Hamilton keep getting vandalized while there isn't even one of Aaron Burr.

The town of Weehawken pulled out all the stops for the reenactment: Hamilton and Burr arrived by boat (from Floating the Apple), just as their forefathers did, for the duel, and arranged tours of Burr's and Hamilton's houses. And it was all-Hamilton this weekend at the NY Times: Ron Chernow's Op-Ed piece about Hamilton is excellent ("he was reviled as a foreigner, a bastard, a mulatto (no solid evidence here), a cocky upstart and an adulterer"). Chernow has just completed a book about Alexander Hamiltion (Gothamist also recommends his books, The House of Morgan about J.P., etc., and Titan about John D. Rockefeller). The Times magazine's Hamilton piece by Ted Widmer referenced the move to replace Hamilton on the $10 bill with Reagan.

More on Aaron Burr and Alexander Hamilton, plus the Aaron Burr Association, visit Hamilton's house and you knew Hamilton College was named for Alexander.

17

Email This Entry







Advertisement: Gothamist Continues Below!

Comments (8)

I was there! I rode my bike from Queens to Weehawken (advice: wear sunscreen) and had a great spot for all the dueling action. HAMILTON SHOT FIRST!!!!!

 

Gore Vidal's Burr has the most fantastic "fictional" (nonfiction novel) representation of the duel, and the horror and awe with which most citizen's regarded Burr with afterwards.

 

Yeah, I think Hamilton stumbling around before falling over can be internal monlogued as "Ouch, ouch, ouch, ouch, ouch, ouch, ouch, fucking OUCH, ouch, OUCH!"

Burr was a shit.

 

Poor Alex. He should've won. Still, my alma mater is proud of him anyway. Those of us who've bothered to learn something about him, that is.

 

Hamilton shot first? He gentlemanly fired his shot in the air - an intentional miss! Roar, Lion, Roar. Somewhere, Burr is burning in hell.

 

One of the worst recreations of anything I have ever seen. It's like they got their costumes from the same place "Medieval Times" gets their crap.

By the way, tons of real people were shot this weekend in NYC. None of them were fancy rich people playing dress up.

 

"By the way, tons of real people were shot this weekend in NYC. None of them were fancy rich people playing dress up."

Did any of them help start a country or draft the Constitution?

Did any of them set up an artillery redoubt on the south side of the Raritan to repulse advancing British troops, giving other elements of the Continental Army time to effect a retreat?

Did any of them found one of the largest banks in the world?

Hamilton's worth remembering.

 

Ron Chernow's book The Prize is an incredible history of the oil industry from start to present (or 1993 anyway). More politicians should resort to, if not gunplay, at least fisticuffs. I'd pay good money to see Ted Kennedy or Rick Santorum whacked with a folding chair across the back.

 
Post a comment (Comment Policy)

2003-2008 Gothamist LLC. All rights reserved. Terms of Use & Privacy Policy. We use MovableType.

Site Meter