Drinking During Your Civil Duty

Water bottle

Oh, no. It turns out you're not allowed to drink when you're serving on a jury. Damn. A juror during the trial of Samuel Brandon (a firefighter accused of stealing objects from the WTC site) is at the center of the defense team argument that Brandon should be retried, since Juror John Anastas admits to drinking during deliberations. Anastas and the other jurors found Brandon guilty of petit larceny (and Gothamist always thought it was petty larceny), but Anastas had been drinking from a Poland Springs half-liter bottle, filled with water and vodka. Defense attorneys grilled Anastas on how much he drank ("I didn't count, because I just sip."), while the prosecution got Anastas to admit he ate "half a ham-and-cheese sandwich during lunch." He claims that he would have come up with the same guilty verdict and that he was in complete control - he just took a big swig after deliberating and then finished the bottle on the way home to East 4th Street.

Gothamist feels that jury duty is an important civil duty (more information from the NY State Unified Court System about NY Jurors). That said, here are some ways to get out of jury duty in the NY State court system. But iVillage says jury duty can help your career. And trials that could lead jurors to drink: The Tyco trial, the Martha Stewart trial.

Email This Entry


Comments (4) [rss]

"He claims that he would have come up with the same guilty plea and that he was in complete control"

Speaking of drinking on the job-- I think you mean guilty verdict. But you'll be happy to learn that other courts have held that drinking and sleeping jurors do not = retrial.

user-pic

Aha! Thanks for the catch - I actually haven't had my early morning nip.

user-pic

what about that episode of the simpsons when homer was in a jury and he had those glasses to make him look like he was awake. actually, several pairs of those glasses.

The lush is a Greek. I am bursting with national pride.

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

Get your daily dose of New York first thing in the morning from our weekday newsletter, now in beta.

About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung
Publisher: Jake Dobkin

Newsmap

newsmap.jpg

Contribute

Latest Tip:

A tenant of the Christodora House (143 Ave. B), on the condo board, has been arrested and indicted f
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS

Follow us