The Trouble With Hilary (and Her Fans)

Hilary DuffGothamist happened to post something about Hilary Duff's Lizzie McGuire Movie poster and suddenly the comments are now the place for her fans to tell Hilary how much they love her, how beautiful they think she is, how they would like her to call/email/contact them somehow. It's also the place for her detractors are scoff her fans and cause trouble. (Gothamist thinks they find their way here after doing Google searches on Hilary Duff's breasts.) All in all, it's comedy gold, as reader Wesley commented. To wit, here is a typical comment:

danielle Aug 14, 2003 2:15 AM

Dear lizzie mcguire or hillary duff
hi lizzie how are you I want to know how I could talk to you could you call me i would really like to talk to you in real life after you get this massage could you call me at [] only call the 503 # after the 29 if it's befor then call [] .I'm at my mom's in az but I live with my dad in or. I will be at my mom's till august 29th then i'll be back at my dad's you could email me at [] please email or call .
Always/Danielle wedge

marcus Aug 15, 2003 1:49 AM
Hi Hilary my name is marcus,im 14 years old,i live in [],California.Im a big fan of urs and i hope to meet u in real life.Ever since i first saw u in that show Lizzie Maguire i have been wishing that mayb somday ill meet u.I think about u alot.I think u are very beautiful and nice.U can email me at [], email me anytime. Love Marcus

marcus Aug 15, 2003 2:10 AM
Hey Hilary its me again,i was wondering if u had aim cause i do.If u do have aim then i wanted to let u know that my screen name is [] so put me on ur buddylist plz.If u can give me ur screen name when u email me.U remember my email address do u?Well if u forgot then here it is again [],and if u dont want to email me then u could call me at [], my area code is 93705. Love Marcus

It flatters us to no end that the kids think Hilary is reading this site...but as another reader Tyler fretted whether this really is America's youth, Gothamist is worried. Especially since there's a bit of name calling that makes us crazy (it's totally unconstructive name calling - Gothamist has nothing against witty, with-good-reason name calling). We're not sure if we're supposed to get parental on these kids, because God knows we're immature, or if we should just let them get it out of their system. And Hilary, if you're reading this, please let us know what you would like to do about it. Email us!

Email This Entry


Comments (75) [rss]

user-pic

Given the apparently age of some of these posters, Jen, I think you might have a COPPA violation on your hands.

user-pic

Augh!! Thanks, Anil, and where the hell is my publisher?

user-pic

Jen, UR sooooo cool! Do U know Hilary?

user-pic

im not goin 2 b sooo cool when the feds are on my ass over coppa.

I am worried. Is it the assumption that they are actually talking to Hilary Duff, or the disconnect with reality, or simply the blind faith that she'll read their comments, call them and live happily ever after? I'm not sure which.

But I do check the thread everyday, thankfully, your top stories box makes that easy.

It's like watching a terrible social experiment.

Thank you Gothamist, thank you. ;)

rats! i missed observing the terrible social experiment due to fears about coppa and i don't even think i understand what coppa is. those kids are delusional though if they think little miss duff will ever reply to them this way. sad. very sad. hilarious (and so weird!) though that duff fans are using gothamist to claim their love.

user-pic

Sophie, I put them back up. I can't make up my mind about it. So see it while you can now!

user-pic

don't quote me on this, but i believe the law only pertains to requesting personally-identifiable information from children under 13- i don't think you have a problem if it is inadvertantely supplied without request.

user-pic

Yeah, I emailed with Anil after I freaked out about it and he said he was sort of kidding, so the comments are back up. But I still feel icky about them.

I wrote about Sharron Osbornes fight with terminal cancer once and I got tones of stupic comments from people trying to write her about quack cures. There are some really really stupid people who are not on the net. I started a special page just for these kind of stupid comments. I also get people trying to email Jackie Chan and Velma from Scooby Doo

I think about u alot.

My teen boy decoder ring says this means "I masturbate often to a nude picture of you I downloaded off of the Web". Perhaps that should be a checkbox on that thread going forward? Might eliminate a lot of redundancy.

user-pic

jkottke - good idea. I'd like to add "U R SOOOO HOT" and "I luv U" to the checkboxes.

And Jake of 8bitjoystick.com, I love the stupid comments page idea. I got an email from a 53 yr old person yesterday, asking me how I could be so depressing cynical at such a young age, based on my post about James Lipton. I wanted to say, "I just call it like I see it - it's called the truth." Jake said I should write, "It's the booze I drink and violent movies I watch - why are you such a pussy?"

I was going to comment that at least Marcus had the good sense to write "urs" instead of "ur's," which would have been grammatically incorrect, but then I realized from his repeated use of "im" that the apostrophe key is probably just broken on his keyboard (and the shift key appears to be a bit on the fritz as well), and given the opportunity, he probably would have written "ur's" after all.

Oy, kids these days.

user-pic

I don't think these kids know what the apostrophe key is, quite frankly. I remember an article that stated kids would write their papers in that teen leet speak.

Also, who's going to be the first to get the hduff2003 AIM account, IM with the posters in that thread, and post the transcripts to the Web?

Is it just me or are kids getting so friggin' lazy that they won't even take the time to type complete words? They're Hoodlums, I tell you, with their jean pants and their portable radios playing that dirty, dirty rock and roll !

I was going to post to that thread, but then I thought that it might violate the restraining order so I didn't.

Just noticed that the Hilary Duff post has reached the 100th post mark. Woo-Hoo! Congratulations, Jen!

That's some deep-fried comedy right there.

This two year old piece I posted has been steadily getting some of these ridiculously silly comments over the last couple of months. Not on the same scale as the Hilary Duff posters, but equally inane.

dear hilary,
i think ur HOT!!!!!!!!!!!
can u email me back at silverarrow150@hotmail.com?
will u go out with me
(just jokin')
luv ya,
mark

hey
when are u comin out with another movie?
luv ya
mark

Those were totally bogus. I could tell by the apostrophe.


GUYS! I'm waxing my pug!

Whatever.

Q: What's 25 feet long and has no pubic hair?

A: The first 10 rows of seats at the next Lizzie McGuire movie.

...Is this thing on? Wow, tough crowd.

Hey you might think this is another person pretending to be hillary duff, but it's not. This is actually Hillary duff pretending to be a 20 year old man who is pretending to be Hillary Duff.

The other day I was just hanging out in my underwear that says Thursday and my The Strokes t-shirt on thinking about how I wish I could hang with my fans. I'm always on tour and would love to hook up with local fans. after the show we could race golf carts in the halls of the stadium. it's like totaly major fun. Maybe we could play playstaion or just IM. you could be all "gey gurl 'sup?"
and I would be all "nuttin much jus' hangin' out in orlando FLA giving screches little brother a hojo."
and you would be all"word? oh snap hill you are the itshay!"
and I'd be all "yeah but you got to keep it on the DL cause my publicist doesn't know. you know how it is."

So send me a email and we can hang.

i thought hilary spellt her name hilary not hillary

it is spelled Hilary, i think that ws a fake

I'd like to say waz up to all my fans!!! You guys are the bomb-shiznit-diggity. Please ignore those other imposters. I just got done watching the VMA's and they were soooo dope! Madonna, Britney and Christina are like living legends! Anyway, gotta run.. I just bought my new ride and I gotta take it for a spin to the set of the movie we're filming. Oh, life is soooo crazy when you have to balance a tv, music and film career... ugh.. you guys will just never know!!!!!!

bye x-o-x-o!!

Hilary Duff

Hey Hilary if u EVER c this would u e mail me i think it would b awesome to talk 2 u. I dont want 2 sound Obsessive (which i am not) I just think that u would b an awesome person 2 talk with. Im also 15 going onto 16 so i think we would have alot in common if we ever talked. Ok peace out if u ever c this. Ur 1 of my teenage Idols

user-pic

HI im ten plese email me and if you do plese give me your sn I think you cute and nice.

dear hillary,
i have wrote u at about 3 other websites telling you about one of my friends named luke. He is 13 and has been fighting cancer for about a year now. Luke really likes you and i think he would really like if u could find the time to like come and see him or something. I know this has nothing to do with gothamist or what this is supposed to be about but my friend has went through alot this past year and you will never no how much he would love to actually meet you. Please write my back and think about this. Luke doesnt know i am trying to do this for him and i will be dissapointed if you cant do it. I hope this gets to you.

Hey Hilary,its Adrew.I was wonderin if I could have your screen name plezzzzzz!!!! If its better for you you could give me your personal phone #. Tell me soon bye!

Your best fan,
Andrew

Hey Hilary,
You rock! I am such a big fan not as big as my friend Steven though. lol Hey will you e-mial me in person cause I get kind of embarassed writing in public! How is your life you have the life I want so bad! I'm working on it though. See I am in a band with my friends I'm a singer. We are all really good! My friend tanner thought we were really good! We are practicing singing
R-E-S-P-E-C-T. I would like to hear you sing it. My e-mail is Nicole.Easley@cox.net thanks hilary! Love ya Nicole

DEAR HILARY,
HI I'AM ONE OF YOUR BIGGEST FANS. I'M TEN YEARS OLD. I LOVE YOUR SHOW ALOT. I THINK YOU ARE VERY
SWEET,KIND,TALENTED,AND YOU LOOK LIKE A VERY GOOD FRIEND.PLEASE CALL ME AT 932-9022 OR E-MAIL ME AT LUCKY_LADYBUGZ@YAHOO.COM
I HAVE ALL OF YOUR MERCHANDISE THAT I CAN FIND.
PLEASE CONTACT ME!!!!!!!

SINCERELY,
SELENA RODRIGUEZ

Hi, Hilary I love your Music and your Talent to act If you read this call me at 1-718-982-6383 because I want to talk to you it is very Important If not Im me at XionXemuXeno15@aol.com

Dear HIlary,
Hi my name is Amber I'm a very big fan of your. Can u please call me or something at 215-338-6480or im me at Prettybabyblue02 I'd really want to talk to you. MAy whole family is saying I am dumb Becuase alll my life I wanted to be an actor and they are telling me NO I wont make it i dont think they wanna see me get crushed? You are like my role model just like Haylie is your? Please im me I need a friend right now?

HI HILARY THIS IS CHARLES I'M TRYING TO BECOME A ACTOR/MODLE AND SO FAR I'M DOIN GOOD COULD U PLEASE CALL ME AT 513-9422192 OR INSTANT MESSAGE ME AND CLMATUNC2 SO I COULD GET SOME ADVICE AND GET SOME HELP FROM YOU PLUS I WANT TO KNOW MORE ABOUT YOU AND I'M VERY INTRESTED IN UR TIPS........HAPPY B DAY I LOVE YOU PLEASE GET AT ME

If you want to know ANYTHING about Hilary duff you can E-mail me at tadpolee56@netscape.net

And hilary if you dont want me to tell them then just E-mail me saying yes or no if its fine


thx, ^^Hil fans^^

Hello hilary duff im hayley adams and im a big fan of urs i watch ur show practically every day i would like to meet u but i dont think i would be aloud to meet such a famouse person like u but i did enter ur competition u know the one that if u win one of us gets to meet u i REALLY hope its me im seriosly gonna run around my house sycho and jump in my swimmin pool wif my DRY cloths on but thats IF i win i hope i do but even if i dont youll still be my best actor and singer well anysway id be happy if youd email me at disco_deeva18@hotmail.com pwease well i have to go now but once again UR THE BEST ACTOR AND SINGER their could ever be well toodles

hey hillary Duff this is kelsey soos i am the biggest fan of urs i hope that someday that we can meet in reall life one day. i live in the santa ynez valley and go to solvang school i am 12 years old and in 7th grade pleeze contact me at BbAlicious4 and GOBIGMJR they r both my screens names pleeze write back my email adress is BbAlicious4@yahoo.com i love u alot pleeze write back buhbye

Hey Hilary I just wanted to say that I don`t
enjoy your music or acting. I did wanted
to tell you that there are people who are
dieng of starvation on the streets. For a
fifteen year old you certainly care alot
about money. So whenever you see someone
dieng THINK OF ME

Hilary Im your#1 FAN I mean i have your lizzie mcguire clothes calender cartoon doll barbie school susplices and i have an inground pool and a tramp like you. e mail me some time oh 1 question did you really get fired?

hi i would just like to say hi to everybody out there exept for ugly people i would not like. all the hot guys please e-mail me and send me a pic

and my e-mailis tinamoody_09@hotmail.com and hi hilary duff

user-pic

Duff has gotten our attention. As I travel the world I get sick knowing that she's driving that damn car while children are dropping dead everywhere I turn. Make sure you're happy Duff. Make sure that you continue to make such an amazing impression on our youth today. You're just like all the rest. SELFISH!

Hi Hilary Duff! I love ur show! When i grow up, I plan to have my band sounding perfect so i can meet u! Ur so cool! ur my idol! please e-mail me at marion.casselman@sympatico.ca or call me at
962-6728. Please!

Hi Hilary Duff! I love ur show! When i grow up, I plan to have my band sounding perfect so i can meet u! Ur so cool! ur my idol! please e-mail me at marion.casselman@sympatico.ca or call me at
962-6728. Please!

tina ffs "your just like the rest of us ?

wtf are you talking about you are fu

Dear Hilary i am a big fan of your but you probally hear that alot.Anyways i was just writeing to say i would love to meet you its always be a dream of mine.I like you i think your pretty.so maybe you can email me sometime my email address is Toolband203@aol.com and as allways love ya

hi hilary, i loved all your movies and i would love to meet you.

I really need to speak to you.Do you want me to not hate you?Then please write to me.THANKS.If you quickly write it to me.Suzanne Wong

thats child porn my friend ^_^

HELLO HILLARY DUFF,
I KNOW YOU DON'T KNOW ME AND I DON'T KNOW YOU EITHER BUT I SEEN YOU AT SCHOOL WITH YOUR FRIENDS I THINK YOUR PRETTY COOL AS A TEENAGER.WELL I'M JUST WRITTING TO YOU JUST TO SAY HELLO AND HOPEFULLY YOU READ THIS NOTE AND WRITE BACK JUST TO TELL ME HELLO, WELL GOT TO GO, SEE YOU LATER AND I SEND YOU LOTS HUGS!!!!!!! LOVE NELLY

I think its cool that Hilary takes the time to read posts. Most celebrities just ignore all articles and fan mail. Some are hate mail, some are teenage boys declaring their love.

Hilary Duff's coming to Australia! So yay. On Tuesday, at the Arias at the Sydney Olympic Park.

I think this is absolutely wrong HIlary Duff is a sweet 16 year old just trying to do her best in life! and here I see people lying about her. You don't even know her. I met her and she is very sweet. She isn't trying to show-off, people keep bugging her, give her a break she has it hard enough and I suggest that people get to know her the way I do. I know everything about her and she is really a sweet girl.

Guys, none of you will meet her period.

no s#!t but hay 22nd pit street mall weeeeeeeee

hey hilary,
sup? Nothing here just chilling. so my name is Jessica you can call me Jesse for short. You have no clue how hard i been trying to hang with you i have been trying to see or talk with you ever sents summer of 2002. So i was thinking can we get together and can u try to get me on the disney channel or make me get an acting part too i will even play boy parts and yea. so my aim is shotchinkeye so talk to me later bye.

10 bux says she cant drive a car yet ^_^

where's hilary duff in her underwear

hey i love hillary you rock my world and when someone thinks i did something i think what would hillary do !!!

hi can i have your sn?
please
im desprate

I hate you,too. Hikary Duff is UGLY

I think you are very ugly.Contact me HHHHHIIIILLLLLARRRRYY DUUUUGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG.

does anyone have hilary duffs street address? i am her biggest fan! any1 plz help a 12 year old fulfill his dream?

Hi Hilary, My names Mathew. I know you think im just another fan but my dream is to meet you, you are my idol! So Plz get back to me.
Mathew_w_td@hotmail.com

luv from mat

dear hilary
my name is troy im an australain im 15 years old and my dream is to fly over to america and meet u i think ur very very beutilful and i hope to chat to u on my computer my email is iwantfood4me@hotmail.com and could u please email me when u get this letter.
luv u lots and lots urs faithfully troy

I am your #1 fan! Please email me at Lizziegurl94@Aol.com

I am your #1 fan! Please email me at Lizziegurl94@Aol.com

user-pic

What a bunch of suck-ups... and I'm nearly close to their age. Who honestly cares about Hilary Duff? She's only an actress still trying to make it big by manufacturing herself like her clothing line, makeup, etc. I hope these people grow up someday.

user-pic

What a bunch of suck-ups... and I'm nearly close to their age. Who honestly cares about Hilary Duff? She's only an actress still trying to make it big by manufacturing herself like her clothing line, makeup, etc. I hope these people grow up someday.

Tips

Get your daily dose of New York first thing in the morning from our weekday newsletter, now in beta.

About Gothamist

Gothamist is a website about New York. More

Editor: Jen Chung
Publisher: Jake Dobkin

Newsmap

newsmap.jpg

Contribute

Latest Tip:

It's the same media that NEVER mentioned Muslims' hatred of Israel as a possible motive for 9/11.
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Gothamist.

All Our RSS

Follow us