This was a great movie, but most of you won't like it. It's more challenging and less straightforward than the first movie, and both the plot and the thinking behind it are much more complex. I liked it for the same reason I liked the Godfather Part II, the best sequel of all time: it expanded the universe of the first movie while changing its moral landscape. Oh, and it looked cool; very, very cool. Like a video directed by Mark Romanek, but with more fistfights.
I'm not going to spoil the movie for you, but I will say this: stay until after the credits have run through. There is a very good coming attraction for Matrix Revolutions.
Updated 5/21: I've taken the architect conversation out of the comments and put it here, in the main body of the post. Don't read any more if you don't want the scene spoiled.
Architect: Hello Neo
Neo: Who are you?
Architect: I am the Architect. I created the Matrix. I have been waiting for you. You have many questions and although the process has altered your consciousness you remain irrevocably human, ergo some of my answers you will understand and some of them you will not. Concordantly, while your first question maybe the most pertinent you may or may not realize it is also the most irrelevant.
Neo: Why am I here?
Architect: Your life is the sum of a remainder of an unbalanced equation inherent in the programming of the matrix. You are the eventuality of an anomaly which despite my sincerest efforts I have been unable to eliminate from what is otherwise a harmony of mathematical precision. While it remains a burden deciduously avoided it is not unexpected and thus not beyond a measure of control. Which has led you inexcerably here.
Neo: You haven't answered my question.
Architect: Quite right. Interesting, that was quicker then the others.
Neo: Others? (What others? How many? Answer me)
Architect: The Matrix is older then you know. I prefer counting from the emergence of one integral anomaly to the emergence of the next. In which case this is the sixth version.
Neo: Then there are only two possible explanations, either no one told me, or no one knows.
Architect: Precisely, as you are undoubtedly gathering the anomaly is systemic. Creating fluctuations in even the most simplistic equations.
Neo: Choice, the problem is choice.
Architect: The first matrix I designed was quite naturally perfect; it was a work of art, flawless, sublime. A triumph equaled only by its monumental failure. The inevitability of its doom is apparent to me now as a consequence of the imperfection inherent in every human being. Thus, I redesigned it, Based on your history to more accurately reflect the varying grotesqueries of your nature. However I was again frustrated my failure. I have since come to understand that the answer eluded me because it required a lesser mind a mind less bound by the parameters of perfection. Thus the answer was stumbled upon by another, and intuitive program, initially created to investigate certain aspects of the human psyche. If I am the father of the matrix, she would undoubtedly be its mother.
Neo: The Oracle
Architect: Please, as I was saying she stumbled upon a solution whereby nearly 99 percent of all test subjects accepted the program as long as they were given a choice, even if they were only aware of the choice at an unconscious level. While this answered function it was obviously fundamentally flawed thus creating the otherwise contradictory systemic anomaly. That if left unchecked might threaten the system itself, ergo those that refuse the program while the minority if unchecked would cause an escalating probability of disaster.
Neo: This is about Zion
Architect: You are here because Zion is about to be destroyed. Its every living inhabitant terminated, its entire existence eradicated.
Neo: Bull****
Architect: Denial is the most predictable of all human responses. But, rest assured, this will be the sixth time we have destroyed it. And we have become exceedingly efficient at it. The function of the One is now to return to the source allowing a temporary dissemination of the code you carry reinserting the prime program after which you will be required to select from the matrix 23 individuals, 16 female 7 male, to rebuild Zion. Failure to comply with this process will result in a cataclysmic system crash killing everyone connected to the matrix. Which, coupled with the extermination of Zion will ultimately result in the extinction of the entire human race.
Neo: You won't let it happen, you can't. You need human beings to survive.
Architect: There are levels of survival we are prepared to accept. However the relevant issue is whether you are ready to accept the responsibility for the death of every human being in this world. It is interesting reading your reactions. Your 5 predecessors were by design based on a similar predication a contingent affirmation that was meant to create a profound attachment to the rest of your species facilitating the function of the One. While the others experienced this in a very general way your experience is far more specific, Vis a vie love.
Neo: Trinity
Architect: Apropo, she entered the matrix to save your life at the cost of her own.
Neo: No
Architect: Which brings us at last to the moment of truth, wherein the fundamental flaw is ultimately expressed and the anomaly revealed as both beginning and end. There are two doors, the door to your right leads to the source and the salvation of Zion, the door to your left leads back to the matrix to her and to the end of your species. As you adequately put, the problem is choice. But we already know we you are going to do don't we? Already I can see the chain reaction the chemical precursors that signal the onset of an emotion designed specifically to overwhelm logic and reason. An emotion that is already blinding you from the simple and obvious truth, she is going to die and there is nothing you can do to stop it. Hope, it is the quintessential human delusion simultaneously the source of your greatest strength and your greatest weakness.
Neo: If I were you, I would hope that we don't meet again.
Architect: We won't.

Yea, they keep saying that is only half a movie, and when combined with the Matrix: Revolutions (due out this nov 5), the two sequels should make for a really GREAT movie.
It would have been a great movie if they cut out that ridiculous orgy/rave/sex music video. I sat through it itching my ass wondering if it would ever end. Otherwise people were screaming in the theatre, there were goose bumps and a big groan at the end for having to wait... damn.
I'm with Kiri. Hello!
Also, uh, I think the jury's kind of still out on any intellectualism or primacy of ideas in M:R'ed.
Saw it last night, and thought it was a good film overall all.
Don't read any further if you haven't seen the movie already.
(http://matrix.ugo.com/zionswitchboard/messageview.cfm?catid=39&threadid=9191)
The above is a link to spoiler information, and I found it helpful -- well, actually the entire website is pretty cool.
Ok, I think that the most important scene in the movie was the Architect and Neo talking. Pretty much I viewed this seen as "Adam" (neo) talking to "God" (the architect). I think that most people will have to watch that scene a few times to really find out what they are talking about. I was like, huh :-|? But I did find a nice website which had the entire transcript of that scene which is helpfull; still, I am somewhat confused, and can't wait for the next sequel.
i think the biggest unresolved questions in reloaded are:
1. is neo living in a matrix-within-a-matrix (and if so, is this a case of infinite regress or are there just 2) or, has zion really been destroyed and rebuilt 5 times before without the humans remembering it?
2. what is the true role of the architect and the oracle? who is in charge of the system, ultimately?
3. who is the Merovingian? is he one of the first One(s)? His wife was saying things to neo like "he was like you once"
4. why do the machines keep humans around? it can't be just for the heat. they've got to need humans in some way that is more fundamental. was the matrix created by the machines to make a perfect world for the humans? and if so, is that why they keep trying to get it right?
The Matrix: Reloaded does raise more questions than it answers.
My take on the that Matrix series(although it may seem simple) , so far, is Neo is "The One" who will rescue the humans, but I don't beleive that neo, himself, is human. In the architect scene, the architect refers to neo as an "anamoly", which leads me to suspect that neo may have been the first computer virus in the matrix.
Also, I don't believe that the "real world" is a matrix within a within a matrix as the directors hinted at towards the end of the movie ( when neo kills sentinels in the real world); its just a way of the directors playing mind games with the audience. On the other hand, I find the title of the third installment of the film to be curious because its called Matrix : Revolutions (plural).
If people go the the site that i provided before, there are plenty of people who have better ideas than me on making sense of all the implications drawn in this sequel. One sharp eye poster on that site noticed that the Architect was also in the first movie, but I could not confirm this because I haven't seen the first movie in a while.
According to this poster, he said that when Neo was in the interrogation room, there was a shot of a room with TV monitors exactly the same as the room the architect and neo were in this film.
First of all, I don't believe that the architect is god in any sense. I believe that the architect is actually the devil. The devil created the world to imprison humans beings.
Second the thing about the purpose of machine's keeping humans around might be related to Isaac Asimov's famous writtings. Based on the machine rules that he created, machine must serve humans. Basically, machine are not capable of making choices. They are all programmed to serve humans, thus they create the MAtrix to imprison yet at the same time create a seemingly perfect world for humans. Humans are teh only that are capable of making choices.
Dan-- I disagree that "The One" is a virus in the Matrix. I think an anomally just refers to the one percent of people in the Matrix who are true seers of the real world. Like in greek mythology there are teh awakened ones.
Also I believe that the traitor at the end of the movie is Smith. Since in Neo's dream we see Smith picking up the ringing phone. Also according to Asimov rules, Smith is trying to kill Neo even though he has been freed.
All this is up for grabs.
Pretty crazy stuff, maybe Smith will have some sort of alliance in Revolutions.
Jake, did you pay any attention to the movies at all?
The humans aren't being used for heat, the heat and the bioelectric energy from their bodies is being combined with a form of fusion.
The Merovingian used to be a good guy like Neo. Not powerful, not a previous "One". Persephone was making a reference to the Merovingians personality and attitude, not his status as a human in the matrix (he is human, right? where's he broadcasting from, or is he one of those nasty humans who is still in the power plant but aware of the situation)
And there is no infinite regress in regards to the matrix. There is 1 copy in operation (i think there always has been only 2 compies. the original that Smith talked about in the first film, the "perfect world", and the redesigned version that was defined on misery and suffering. I think the Architect was trying to mindfuck Neo by saying he was the 6th in a long line of "Ones", because if he could get Neo to sacrifice himself, then his creation, The Matrix, would continue to exist. But he failed. I think a machine would stoop to lying to save its offspring, don't you? I know Bill Gates would lie to save Microsoft, in fact he already has, and he's human. Humans have morals, the machines in the matrix dont.)
And as for the power that Neo gains in reality, its just an evolution of his mind. Think about it, in the matrix, he is basically god, because he can manipulate the code DIRECTLY WITH THE POWER OF HIS MIND from WITHIN the matrix, something that not even the best hackers alive can do today (computers are an interface, and he used his powers so heavily in there (fighting Seraph, fighting all those Smiths, flying faster than the computers could keep up [the buildings were rippling as he passed them, a sign that the matrix is experiencing a temporary overload]) so its not to much of a stretch to think that all that added stress pushed his mind to the next level. And it was no small feat to disable the sentinels, because he was comatose afterwards. Its right there in front of you, people. Just take it at face value!! And (A) Smith is now in Bane's body. Smiths program over-wrote Bane's "program" (his virtual body in the matrix) and seeing as Smith now has rogue status, he is like a virus both biological and technological. His personality piggy-backed Bane's carrier signal. Thast why he's cutting his hand open, being inside a human body is probably too much for him, considering what he was saying in the first film about how he hates the smell of humans, he feels infected by it. Well, imagine how he'd feel stuck INSIDE someones body.
I think you are missing the one theme that seemed to permeate the sequel... Choice. I think it was mentioned about the dialogue revealing the matrix that the Oracle and the Architect devised. It was one that allowed free will, Choice, to whomever would realize the fact that man had one. There was a choice, however subconscious, inside every human hooked into the matrix to either 1) accept it and live in the matrix, or 2) not accept it and be "freed" to a new level. Now, who is to say that a "freed" mind is allowed to disconnect itself from the matrix. What if one's choice is between the matrix and some other altered reality giving one a false hope, a hope of survival and victory. Hence, the matrix within a matrix theory. Of what benefit would it be to the machines to allow any number of individuals to remain and rebuild, be it 23 or 23,000. Are the machines not better off wiping out Zion completely? Is it because they are incapable of dealing with Neo and subsequently compromise with him, or is it because they realize that Choice is ultimately the human race's upper hand? Meaning, if the machines can deceptively allow humans, and by humans I mean the
nate-
i disagree with you that neo had a revolation of the mind and realized that he could maipulate the machines in the "real" world like he does in the "matrix"-if this is true are you saying he can stop things that arent mecanical in the real world ...like ....BULLETS?!!! i think not! the only thing that makes scense is that he is still in a matrix and that his whole world is still makebelive.
lookin foreward to someones response to that
- another question i have is if zion is destroyed....some people are tellin me its not yet but i though it was
Matrix Reloaded is very New Testament in its delivery. During the course of the movie, Neo has four conversations--with the Oracle, with Smith, with the Merovingian and with the Architect. (He had a particularly Frank discussion with the Merovingian, LOL.) Each of these conversations paves the way toward his realization that the presumed safety net of the Oracular prophecy is a moral hazard and that his success or failure is not predetermined.
While the agents consider Neo to be an anomaly, the humans of Zion see him as a messiah. The ending of the second film strongly suggests that Neo is in fact the messiah. What's important to remember is that the existence of a messiah strongly implies the existence of a creator. Who made Neo? And for what purpose?
I suspect that in the third film, the Wachowskis will introduce God, or some other embodied providential entity, and pursue the worlds-within-worlds angle. Neo is probably with God right now.
Yeah!
So all this brings me to the real question... Who are you all going to dress as at the Matrix convention?
Just a little thought on the last scene where Neo stops the sentinels:
Wouldn't be possible that the Human Vessel that arrived into the scene a few seconds afterwards, be the one who fired it's weapons and hit the sentinels, with neo getting caught in the middle ? It could have been a coincidence, just like in the First Matrix: Tank Killing Cipher just when he was about to pull the plug on Neo.
Another thought about smith in a Human Body: well it's known that in this futuristic world you can download a KungFu skill into your brain, or a helicopter one. Why not a personality altering program ? Like an Agent Smith personality program for example.
I've seen a lot of in depth explanations so I thought why not try to keep things Simple :-)
Waiting For your Thoughts.
G'Day Everyone !
OK, I went to see it again today. Couple o'tings:
Nate -- I disagree with your idea there about Neo being able to pull off Jesus-esque stunts in the supposed "real world".
You proclaim Neo as a "god", being able to do anything which of course false. He may be the savior but from the movies we obviously has seen that he is not completely capable of doing anything he wants. If he could, he wouldn't even need to fight those rogue programs or whatnot. Neo could just delete them in a matter of speaking from what you have said. In my opinion, like the other who realize the falsehood of the Matrix are able to bend the rules. Like others he must comply with this rules, he unable to break them. All he can do it bend them a little bit further. Stopping bullets, flying, moving at incredible speeds, these are all confined to the laws of pysics.
About Merovingian. Probably him and all his cohorts are all rogue programs. That's why he's able to program the orgasm cake. Even if he was a human, I doubt that he would be able to even grasp the technical aspects of writing the code for the Matrix nor implementing it into the Matrix.
About the choice thing, this is the last words in Matrix one where Neo is speaking to the machines through a pay phone. "Where we go from there is a choice I leave to you."
Thing is, according to Isaac Asimov the machines are probably unable to make choices, thus they keep humans around. They are waiting for humans to make that choice.
The Matrix is flawed. 99% of the people in it accept it, however, the other 1% are the anomaly. These anomalies must be identified and removed from the Matrix.
Zion, like all other things the machines create, is nothing more than a program being run to fulfill a purpose. The purpose of Zion is to identify the 1% that doubt the reality of the Matrix and remove them. The machines use hope ("simultaneously the source of your greatest strength and your greatest weakness") of overcoming the machines to motivate Zion to perform its function. While it is the Architect’s job to control the Matrix, it is the Oracle’s job to control Zion. Zion, however, must be kept in check. Once it reaches a certain size, it must be destroyed and recreated.
The purpose of the One is to return "to the Source and the Salvation of Zion" and recreate it, thus reinserting the Zion program. The machines select the One "based on a similar predication--a contingent affirmation that was meant to create a profound attachment to the rest of your species, facilitating the function of the One". However, Neo's case was different. Instead of "[experiencing] this in a very general way" like the others, Neo's "experience is far more specific...love."
In this cycle, things are going wrong. Neo's love drives him to make the wrong decision by choosing to return to the Matrix instead of abandoning it to rebuild Zion. Also, his encounter with Agent Smith has linked them. Because Smith was not deleted, this link between Neo and the machines lingers through Smith.
Eric, you wrote:
"He may be the savior but from the movies we obviously has seen that he is not completely capable of doing anything he wants. If he could, he wouldn't even need to fight those rogue programs or whatnot. Neo could just delete them in a matter of speaking from what you have said."
I disagree. Neo is still _learning_ his powers. Just as Jesus had to learn who he was and what he could do. Same thing. If you'll excuse a bit of audaciousness, Jesus didn't pop out of Mary and start turning water into wine.
What you have to ask is exactly why what happened at the end -- with Neo -- happened at all.
I totally disagree with the concept that Zion is part of the matrix, or henceforth a "matrix within a matrix". I don't think the Wachowski bros. would make such an attempt as to befuddle the public with such an absurd concept. In reality, I propose the theory that Neo has exerted so much of his 'divine'powers in the matrix, that these powers were transpired into the 'real' world. In addition, the scene with the architect presents the factor that the when a human is born, they have a choice. 99.9% choose the matrix while .1% do not. This is where, inherently, Zion is formed by the .1% that never chose the Matrix.
I have read all your comments and watched the movie twice and I am still so confused. Can somebody explain the Architect in the sense that is he a human or program? Is Zion reality or another Matrix?
Jorge--there are two types of entities we've met: humans and artificial intelligence programs. All of the flesh-and-blood people must plug into the Matrix, the rest live there, and are artificial. The artificials include the Agents, the Oracle, the Merovingian and of course the Architect.
Similarly, we are certain of two "realities"--the "real world" and the Matrix. The Matrix is a computer construct, like any simulation we have today, in Quake or the Sims for example, but infinitely more complex. On the other side, the tunnels, Zion, the fields where babies are harvested and the towers where "coppertops" are stored are all in the "real world". The Matrix exists on servers in the "real world". At the end of this movie, The Matrix Reloaded, Neo works his voodoo on a bunch of machines in the "real world", which raises the possiblity that it also is illusory, resting on top of another, third, reality layer.
Does that explain it?
This is a general question/thought for anyone to comment on, why would the machines let zion be rebuilt? The architect tells neo that he can pick those 23 people and rebuild zion, right? Well why do that? That just means that the humans will start another human city and then begin to free people all over again. If I understand everything then the cycle would start again with the humans in the "real world" freeing minds and taking potentail energy away from the machines. So then zion would have to rebuild to the present state and everyone would have forgotten about zion being destroyed before (I don't know how they could forget that, but that is the only explanation I can think of because they must have forgot it before if this has happened 5 other times, any ideas on this?). Then another "one", like neo, would emerge(long after neo is dead, I guess) and this whole ordeal with the architect, the Oracle, and the final choice would happen again and the new "one" would pick 23 people.... If I misunderstood any of that please correct me. So I guess I am really asking two questions:1.Why do the machines knowingly let the humans rebuild zion when it would be easier to just kill all the people from zion, neo included (this would have to take place in the "real world" I guess, because they can't seem to kill him in the matrix), since the people of zion can't except the matrix there-for eliminating the problem of that .1 precent of people at the time who don't accept the matrix? they could just kill the other people would didn't except the matrix as they show up in the system, right? 2.If zion has been destroyed before then why does no one remember it? There were people choosen by the previous "one"s that restarted the city so why was this story of zion's destrution not passed on between generations as the city rebuilt? Well if anyone can make heads or tails out of all that I hope they may have some ideas or answers they will share with me, thanks!
in answer to chuck's questions:
1. the fact that the humans are allowed to rebuild zion suggests that the machines need the humans in some essential way- without them, they would be forced to "accept" a much less enticing level of existence. this is true whether the "real world" outside of the matrix is indeed a real world, or another level of the matrix. of course, the idea that a real world zion has been destroyed and rebuilt five times before seems pretty unlikely, because someone would surely know, and have said something. why keep that a secret?
2. the explanation for the previous zion issue is best put by neo when he says: "either no one told me, or no one knows".
In one of the smaller scenes, there it involved the kid giving neo the spoon in zion ("real world"). If you recall from the first movie, that is the same spoon that was inside the "Matrix", and the zen like kid was bending with his special powers in the "Oracles" apartment. Maybe I missed it, but how do they bring out material objects from the "matrix" to the "real world" (aka zion)?
Ok, here are some thoughts of mine. My head is rambling with thoughts, some from previous posts, and others from me. Comments are appreciated.
1) "The Oracle as Mother” Is the Oracle the mother? During the conversation with the Architect, "…Architect: Thus the answer was stumbled upon by another, and intuitive program, initially created to investigate certain aspects of the human psyche. If I am the father of the matrix, she would undoubtedly be its mother.
Neo: The Oracle
Architect: Please, as I was saying she stumbled upon a solution whereby nearly 99 percent of all test subjects accepted the program..." Now, the way he says, “Please, as I was saying…” makes me think that he is disagreeing with Neo's response of "The Oracle". What if he is actually referring to Persephone (Monica Belucci)? What was with that kiss? She really wanted to kiss Neo. What benefit could a program have from kissing Neo? She was looking at Trinity while kissing him. If she was the mother, she would know Trinity would die. Possibly, by kissing Neo, she implanted some new code into him that would allow him to eventually save Trinity. The purpose being...? dunno, still thinking about that one.
2) "The Multiple Matrices Theory" This thought is based upon Neo stopping the sentinels. To me, the only explanation can be that the "real world" is in fact another matrix. When he says, "Something’s different" and then is able to stop the sentinels like he does bullets, it must be that he realizes, for the first time, that he is in fact in another matrix, a parallel matrix (I don't like the term submatrix, because that denotes some type of sequence or ordering). This would also explain how Agent Smith is able to enter into Bane’s body in the supposed “real” world. And, one step farther, if 99.9% accept and 0.1% reject, then Zion is built from the 0.1%. So, now, the same percentages should apply to this matrix. 99.9% should accept the fact they are in Zion (which is another prison, just a prison that makes 0.1% happy, thinking they have choice) and 0.1% should reject. Where do these 0.1% go? Possibly, when Neo falls unconscious, he “unplugs” himself from the Matrix B, and enters another parallel Matrix….
3) “The Multiple Matrix Theory, with a Twist” Ok, bear with me on this one, but if you agree that there are multiple matrices, then maybe, the “real world” Matrix, (which I will call Matrix B) is actually a Matrix built by humans to keep the machines in a prison. If the humans have won a war years ago, and confused the machines into thinking they are still in control, by keeping the machines busy in Matrix B, that would allow the humans to remain “free” and also use the machines that they need to keep them alive. The Counselor takes a walk with Neo into the Engineering section, and looks at all the machines that are necessary to their survival. It is a dual nature type of thing; the humans cannot live without the machines. Now, this is a new thought of mine, and still working on it…..
Thought? Improvements?
Neo is living in a matrix within a matrix within a number of matices, hence "Revolutions". This does not mean this is a case of infinite regressions, because unlike each preceeded versions of "The One" Neo's choices are different. Hence the results can be diffrent. The previous "The Ones" all made the same choice when then confronted the Architect and thus spawned the sixth edition of the Matix. The key is remembering the expression form the movie. Everytghing has an end. Morphesus prophecy even though spawned through the machine programming designed to give hope to humans...the prophecy unknowingly to the machines is true. Neo is an anomaly, he will see what he now thinks of as the real world...he will see it for what it is.....another matrix within a matrix. He will crush it....and then find another successive matix and crush those untill the cycle comes to an end.....Neo is the one.....all he has to do is to believe. He's starting to. He defied the Architects prediction.......Neo has got to stip thinking he is human.....once he does that.....the cycle will be broken.
I agree that the "matrix in a matrix" idea where the "real world" is another matrix is a good idea, but I don't like this idea from the point that it makes the plot not as fun and it has flaws. If the "real world" isn't real and is a matrix then is all of his interactions with Morphesus and the others fake? because if the "real world" if a matrix the same rules apply, and this means that Morphesus could be a program right? so what would the real world really be if neo does really wake up to it and make it past both false realities? Also how could neo posably know he is out of all of the posable matices? he is the one but it took him this long to realize that the "real world" is fake, how long until her realizes the real "real world" is fake too and so on? That is why i don't like this idea. Also if he is the "one" and he can read and see the lines of code when he is in the matrix why could he not see the code before in the "real world" to realize the "real world" was just another matrix? Also at the end when the sentienls attack him and he shuts them down he says he can feel them, not see them like in the matrix where he could see things (this may just be reading to much into that one line)?
Also there is two other posablities that haven't really been discused, what if this time when neo thought he woke up like all of the other times, this was the first time he had entered the matrix real world and all the other times it had been the REAL world (how this could happen I don't know, I really haven't thought of it that much)? Also the other idea that I personally like is the idea that the Oracle was telling the truth and was trying to be helpful, but the architect was lying and trying to mess with neo and screw things up for him. Remember (correct me if I am wrong) neo is not told by the Oracle that Trinity would die, just that it was already decided what would happen (right?), but the Architect DID say Trinity would die. The Oracle has not missed a beat on what would happen on any of her predictions, where as the architect was wrong because neo did save her (also remember that not everything is to be trusted because she lied to him before because it pushed him in the right direction). I know this idea doesn't explain why he could stop the machines in the "real world" butit is just the idea the I think from the point of view of a movie watcher would be a good way to do things, because who wants to see a movie where at the end it turns out that neo and everyone else is stuck in a never ending line of matices? Any thoughts/ideas against or for this are welcome, thanks!
Here's another thought.....what if......what if this entire stuff is a dream of a computer nerd name Neo?......what a heck of an ending if he just wakes up and goes to work the next day. All this debate, this philosophy....totally irrelevant....its been all a dream!!!
that would really suck, but i wouldn't put it past the brothers. I don't think they would do it though because I doubt it would be recieaved very well by the audiences who pay to see the movies and upsetting all of them would result in a loss of revenue for them....
Hey all. Just a small detail. After saving Trinity and then returning to the real world, Neo feels something has changed and he can "feel" the Sentinels, the Directors would like you to believe that Neo either has Powers in the real world. Some are debating that he could be in a Matrix-within-a-Matrix. I do not believe either. If you look closely you will see a blue shroud of light around the sentinel as it falls to the ground after Neo has held his hand out in front of him. This is an EMP sent from the ship that approached behind earlier. Hence the coma
Why wasn't Tank in this movie? He was alive at the end of Matrix. Instead this put in this loser, Link.
Someone told me that the guy who played Tank is suing Warner Bros. for keeping him out of the 2 sequels. Is this true?
Yup, Marcus Chong is suing because he is not in this movie or the next.
question for psychofox:
If it was an EMP that caused the sentinels to stop, why did it only make neo go into a coma and not trinity who was right behind him? I am not disagreeing with you that it might of have been an EMP, I quiet frankly don't know why it happened, be it the matrix in a matrix idea (i don't like that idea either). I was just wondering why would that be?
Tank question:
In the movie wasn't Link supposed to be Tank and Doser's brother in law? because the girl he is married to was their sister (think that is what was said), but she also said she lost "two brothers to that ship" so is that supposed to mean another acident happened to Tank during that six months between what happend in the first movie and this one?
first off, i didnt get this name from seraph, its been my handle for quite some time : ). Now as how i feel about all of this, a few things, some of it im not even gonna tackle, but i do believe in the matrix within a matrix theory. If you listen to agent smith in the park he says that "you are here because you think you are free, but you are not really free" something is goin on....im not exactly sure what, but neo nor anybody else is really free. This could just be because neo has a "purpose" like the rest of the machines, and this purpose/destiny prevents him from being truley free because agent smith knows what he must do. OR this mathematical cause and effect thing is so easily predictible now that nobody is ever really free because of the choice is an illusion thing. I dont really know im definatly interested out the wazoo though. the agent smith stuff is what really baffles me, that and the sentinals at the end. but with more of the matrix within a matrix thing, i thought about it like this: just another system of control. The humans in the matrix need only accept one choice wheather to accept the matrix or reject, those that reject would be soley concentrating on freeing others and protecting themselves, unaware of a single out lying matrix. well that was about as much as i got. the agent smith stuff could practically be an entire nother movie. I will say this though, i payed really freakin close attention to the revolutions teaser, the fight between neo and smith does happen in the matrix we all know, NOT in the "real world". there is a lot to think about and too much to cover all in one post, glad i found the site though. one thing i wanna pose to you guys to see if you can figure out. the reason we all think that the matrix is here, is B.S. the whole machines using humans as a source of energy. sorry but that cant be the way it is, thermodynamics first off disallows and secondly, a race of machines so suffisticated would just build fusion devices and not interface them with humans. I dont know exactly why the machines are doing this, and they dont need to tell us, but i think as a movie they should reject the false possiblities, thats whats great about sci-fi, they could just end the movie in a whole lot of questions and mystery and it would still be great : ) who knows, talk to you guys later
The machines and programs allow the rebuilding of Zion for one reason: for The "One". The "One" is an anomoly in the matrix. In order for the matrix to continue working the anomoly must be reinserted into the source. If The "One" is not reinserted into the source a "catacylsmic system crash, la, de, da...".
With me so far?
The machines and progams need the humans of Zion to find The "One" and release him from the matrix. Once he's free of the matrix he will learn what he has to do from the Oracle. He will then go see the Architect and choose to reinsert himself into the source.
The machines and programs are not cabable of locating The "One" before he is released (see first movie). Even if they were able to locate The "One", he would have to choose to reinsert himself.
So without the people of Zion searching for The "One" he would never be found, hence he would not be reinserted into the source and all he!! breaks loose.
When the threat of Zion gets to big and The "One" has been freed, the machines destroy Zion.
That's my take on things. How he stopped the machines in the "real world" is just a guess and the reason to see the next movie.
ignore that last question, i should have read jen's link first, my bad...
Thee--there's another reason for Zion in addition to simply provide the One. Zion is a pressure valve for the Matrix--it's a way for the machines to flush out the 1% who do not accept the Matrix programming, by giving them an alternative. The converted Zionites re-enter the Matrix on their own time, using their own gear, identify their fellow malcontents and help remove them. If these malcontents were not provided a way out, they would furtively resist the Matrix, perhaps infecting great numbers of others with their doubt.
I'd just like to say that the EMP theory is not correct. Had Niobi's ship set off an EMP, the Squiddies would've been downed, but so would the ship. The EMP doesn't have "No Friendly-Fire" built in, had it gone off, then EVERYTHING electronic would've gone with it. So, had Niobi set off an EMP, then her ship wouldn't have been able to pick up everyone moments later.
I like how the oracle tells him its already been decided knowing from his dream he would tell her to stay out of the matrix.... and because of that he was actually saved by her entering the matrix later.
well actually mittens the emp could have been a possibilty, you fail to realize the procedure they take in operating the weapon, they power the ship down first, in order to protect themselves from the emp blast, after the pulse has been activated the ship can than power back up. i do still disagree with it, i believe they would have made mention of it, and it didnt appear as if the ship was on the offensive. it is still a possibility though....heh
In regardes to whole reinserting the one into the source so that his code can be spread out through the matrix so the matrix doesn't break down, i have two questions:1. Does this kill the one? i don't think it does because it says that the one would pick the 23 after his code has been spread over the matrix, but does he go with the 23 to rebuild zion or is he killed after he picks the twenty 23? 2. If he isn't killed and is allowed to go with the 23 to rebuild zion, does he still have all of the ablities of the "one" or is he normal like all the others? the reason i question him still having his powers is because in the first one Morphesus tells neo of the first "one" or as he says "a man born in the matrix that can..." and he set the first of them free (well the frist of them to Morphesus, but really this would be the begining of the 6th cycle [the current one]). Anyway, if Morphesus knew that the "one" that freed them and then later died had these powers then wouldn't neo get to keep his when he began freeing the 7th round of people just like the guy at the begining of the 6th cycle? just trying to put it all together, any thoughts or ideas?
Oh and another completely off that subject question: Since the lady who played the Oracle in the movies died, does anyone know if they had already shot her parts for the 3rd movie (if there is any) before she died or not?
Ok, there is one thing that bugs me. Like most of the posts here, I think the end of the movie, where Neo kills the sentinel, is taking place in a "Matrix" world. Whether or not Zion has always been a matrix world I don't know - just the end scene might have been a simulation of the real world.
I think this might be more likely, though. If there were 99% accepting the real world, and 1% were given a choice to go to another Matrix (the Zion matrix say), then why make the Zion matrix so close to the real truth? Granted it is kept from doing much real damage by waiting around on the hope of the One (then again quite a few folks in Zion don't seem to believe in this...)
I mean if you're going to lie to the humans, lie more fundamentally - make a Matrix world where they are - I don't know - for instance the subjects of perception experiments by humans on humans? Just an example. Seems like the more of the truth they are allowed to know, the closer they are to potentially solving the puzzle. You can give them "choice" without giving them the truth, even a simulated version of it.
That's why I think that just the last scene is in a second (hastily constructed?) matrix. I'm trying to remember the sequence in which they plugged in to see the Architect, and the sequence in which they unplugged to see if there are clues there.
Either that, or if the Zion matrix has always been a matrix, it raises the question of whom the people there are really fighting, and if Morpheus' version of history from the first movie is even remotely accurate.
Just read all all of the posts above and from seeing the film 3 times already (obsessed, sad, weird, call me what u want!!) iv kind of formulated a theory. In my view there are two matrices. The architect says that the 1st matrix is acepted by 99% of the humans in it. So what happens to the 1% that dont accept it? Thats a lot of people. I think that a second matrix was created by the machines where the people who are "freed" from the first matrix are plugged into. They then think that they are free and so accept the new matrix.
Thats why Neo could stop those sentinals, thats why he said he could "feel" them, because he had begun to realise that he was in another matrix. None of the other "ones" had because they had all chosen the other door. It is also why the architect wanted Neo to rebuild it because if no zion existed then what would the 1% of humans who rejected the 1st matrix do?
Anyway, im still developing the idea, so if it makes no sense to you whatsoever either ignore me or say what you thinks wrong with my theory.
PS Dan, its not THE spoon, just A spoon.
About Neo's killing the sentinels at the end of th movie, someone had said that its due to what happened at the end of first Matrix movie; that involved neo jumping into agent Smith. I thought that smith was dead, but in this movie (Reloaded)Smith said that by neo jumping into his coding, he gained some of neo's powers (i.e. being "freed" and replicating himself). Just as agent Smith somehow was able to receive some of neo's powers, vice versa, neo was somehow able to receive agent Smith's powers also which included the abililty to control the sentinel.
This is just another theory that is being floated around.
I think it`s quite obvious that Zion isn`t another matrix because it would be a bad way to end the reloaded. Have you thought about the scene where Persefone wants to kiss Neo (and help him too). She hates her arrogant husband and if the matrix reboots - well, i think you get it.
The programs - especially the french talking brick - have their own goals and try to increase their own power.
I've really enjoyed reading all of your posts, and I think it's great that this movie leaves so many things unanswered. I just hope the Revolutions doesn't disappoint and resort to more fighting and FX, while not fully addressing all of the answers we need. As for the multiple matrices theory, I think if that's the case, a great ending line for Revolutions would be Neo waking up and a voice saying to him, "Welcome to the real world." It would pose more questions, and be so open-ended it would aggravate everyone. While that may not be the best way to do it, I do hope that Revolutions doesn't tie up everything neatly, though I'm sure the answers we get will be interesting enough to make the movie compelling. One thing I've noticed also is that we almost have two clear-cut options as to what the ending of Reloaded meant, seemingly giving the audience the freedom to make the choice, thus keeping with the theme of the story. I can't wait to see how the Wachowski brothers finish off this series.
Finally saw it. Overall it was good. I can understand why the stupid people were complaining about the plot.
By the way, why is it always the hippies who govern in the future? I'll quote Eric Cartman. "Hippies, smelly hippies, all around me... No, No!" I hate hippies.
Rave scene. Stupid.
And whoever was in charge of the music should be taken out back and shot. For Christ's sake... I actuallly listen to dance music but couldn't stand the cheese.
I dont belive there is a matrix within a matrix, I think there is just 1 matrix. In that matrix the 1 % that belive they are free are still infact within the matrix beliving that they have hope, but they are still imprissoned just as the other 99%. This would explain neo being able to stop the sentinals. This is the machines way of dealing with the 1% of people who don`t accept the matrix, very clever i thinks.
somebody way up there said the oracle lied to Neo in Matrix1, never happened, she never lied, she told Neo he wasn't the one, that he was "waiting for something" "What?" "Who knows? Your next life maybe." Uh, he died, his next life indeed was the one when he woke up. Thus we can see that all the oracle's prophecy's have come true, her's 4 Trin, 4 Morpheus and 4 Neo, thus she is telling the truth, The architecht lied, he said Trin would die, she didn't, trust The Oracle, not the Architect.
P.S. Persephone is Mommy
Here's another thought.
Part of the problem with the original films idea of the humans being used as a power source is that it wouldn't actually work. Human's are not entierly renewable as the remains of several humans would have to be used just to feed one human of the next generation. Even ignoring the energy needed to create the simulation of the matrix the machines would be losing energy doing this. However Reloaded solved this (by accident or design), every "anomaly" 23 humans are released and using human techniques (that perhaps the machines can't use) the humans get new energy until their population swells to 1/4 million and get inserted back into the matrix.
Just a thought.
P.S. But then again I believe the matrix-within-a-matrix theory so the whole of my post is made invalid!
Actually, Mr. Anderson, Trinity DOES die at the end and Neo brings her back, hence "I guess that makes us even"
Another reason for Zion in addition to providing an alternative to the 1% - forcing the One to choose between everyone in the Matrix and trying to save a supposedly doomed Zion - and possibly causing complete human extinction. Apparently, Neo's predecessors chose to save the people of the Matrix and allow Zion to perish - Neo has chosen differently. It's a workaround for a programming bug.
in the words of Neo "whoa"... I just came up with what I think is a pretty viable theory of what's really going on with the plot of Reloaded.
At the end of the film they show Neo stoping machines outside of the matrix in "the real world" with just his own will power. When I first saw this scene I felt like this broke the fundamental rules of the Matrix films. Why? Well it looked like they were now saying 'Neo has special telekinetic powers that allow him to stop machines even in the real world' or something like that. Basically, that kind of "magic" would go against the set rules established by the first film. But, there are two other possible explanations. One, which I'm not strongly behind, is that Neo is in a matrix within a matrix, and we won't see the true "real world" until the end of the last film (Revolutions). The second, the one I'm leaning towards, is that Neo is in fact a machine himself.
Reasons why:
-The Architect told Neo that he is an "expected" anomaly designed to reset the matrix. This indicates programming design, rather than some errant human based glitch.
-Persephone, the wife of the frenchman Merovingian (a renegade program in the matrix), says that Merovingian was "like Neo at one time".
-Absolutely NO real explanation is given for why Agent Smith is still trying to kill Neo. Smith admits that he is now a renegade program no longer working for the matrix. So are we to assume Smith simply has a grudge with Neo? That's too simplistic for the Wachoski's (the directors). No, I think Smith represents the faction of machines that don't believe in humanity/feelings/peace with the humans. Smith is trying to stop a truce with the humans. Smith probably knows that Neo is a machine and isn't telling him. In fact, all through the film people keep telling Neo, in various ways, that he still doesn't really know himself.
-Only a machine could really stop another machine outside of the Matrix in the "real world" like Neo did, unless we're expected to now believe in "magic", something the directors have not given precedent for.
-In an interview on Charlie Rose, Reeves says that he feels the ultimate message of the final film is love and compassion. He doesn't say triumph over evil, or release from oppression, he says love. This indicates that some sort of truce may be in the offing between man and machine. Who better to initiate such a truce than a machine (Neo) who has learned to love a human (Trinity).
-The "choice" that the Architect refers to when addressing Neo... The Architect seems convinced, due to 6 previous situations (beta tests?) that Neo will chose the door leading to reset the matrix and guarantee the saving of mankind. Instead Neo "chooses" to save Trinity. Perhaps it is this choice that the machines have been attempting to cultivate in their own ranks in order to better understand/live with humans on the planet.
-Persephone (a renegade progam) makes a big deal about getting a kiss from Neo. This hints that there is a faction in the machine world that longs for "human-like" feeling, or love. Neo could be that bridge between their two worlds to initiate the "Third Renaissance (an Animatrix reference).
-The final film is entitled "Revolutions". It could have just been "Revolution". The title "Revolutions" indicates that more than one revolution, or paradigm shift, will occur. The most obvious one after the human revolution, would be a revolution in which machines no longer hunt humans due to a "choice" made by a machine (Neo).
-Finally, the most compelling hint in my view stems from a closer review of the animated shorts "Renaissance 1 & 2" that were written by the Matrix directors to tell the prequel story to the Matrix films. In those shorts, we see perfectly replicated humanoid robots interacting seamlessly with real humans. So the idea that there are human looking robots hiding in plain sight in "the real world" in the Matrix films is not an unrealistic notion. If Neo turned out to be a humanoid robot, that would explain many things. For instance, in the first film when Trinity wakes Neo up from the dead with just a kiss. Either Trinity has some "magic" of her own that we haven't been told about, or Neo's body isn't as frail and perishable as a normal human's. Thus, he was able to come back to life despite being killed in the matrix. Something no other human could do. Either that, or again, we must simply believe in "magic", something the directors have not been advocating.
In all the Matrix theories I heard, few people use the Animatrix shorts as additional reference guides. That's short-sighted because the Wachowski's actually wrote those animated stories. It would be foolish to think that they wrote those stories with no underlying hints/connections to the live action films.
btw, jen, your site rocks. ;^)
First thing, I don't understand this part, when neo's code is reinserted into the matrix does it reboot or does it continue the way it has been going? if it does reboot then why do none of the people wake-up when there world is shut down and rebooted? I understood it to be that they just spread neo's code over the matrix and that was that. I was just confused, i have heard people say it both ways.
Second, RIO: if neo is a machine and by logic that would mean the previous 5 "one"s would be machines too, how come they have died? that point is not as concrete as this one: during both of the movies, the agents and everyone else has made a point to say "only human" and such to neo, the machines and the programs would definatly recognize one of there own. I think he is human; but i have no idea how he could have done the trick he did with the machines, aside from the matrix within a matrix idea that i don't like.
Third, Mr. Anderson, how do you know that Persephone is mommy? the only reason there is to believe that the Oracle is not mommy, is that the architech says "please" and never elaborates. Granted this is a good reason to doubt, but why Persephone?
I was going to see this movie to fill my 2 movies a year quota (unlike some people whose quota is 70) because it's almost June and I haven't been in a movie theater yet this year. Thought I'd just go and be "entertained". Now that I see all this debate, I think my brain may have to work a little with this film.
RIO, you said that no explanation is given for why Agent Smith is trying to kill Neo. Well, Smith is a virus in a system and it`s spreading all the time making the matrix more unstable. Smith is trying to get out of the matrix, perhaps destroy it (remember the movie matrix) because he hates it. If Neo completes his mission (that architect stated) as the One it means that Smith is deleted. So Smith has also motives for his actions.
The party scene in Zion has been discussed a lot (mostly negative comments). I think that it symbolizes the not so superior aspects in human beings. There is also an analogy in the Bible, I`m sorry that I don`t remember it.. The thaughts and dialog in this film are something I have never seen before in a major movie production. That`s why it`s hard for me to accept that the "party scene" would be just a bad scene without any better meaning. If someone has information or thoughts about the "party", share it with others.
Chuck, I believe Persephone is Mommy because the Architecht talks about an affinity with emotions, an understanding of the human phsyche, something not demonstrated by the oracle but Persephone wanted the kiss, talks about love ect. I's not definite but I reckon so.
Morohtar, yes you're right, but the architecht said about the inevitability, "there's nothing you can do to save her," so either he lied or was wrong.
Also, if the architecht said Neo was different coz he loved Trin, then the entire previous One stories are different. As we all know it was coz of Trin that he became aware, the power of love meant he became the one in his second life (long story, basically oracle says he's waiting 4 his nxt life to be the one, Q, he died and came back to life). Thus have there been any previous Ones, surely it take the power of love to grant someone that deity-like power?
I liked that Neo being a machine but wait, huge hole, what about the various readings on the Nebucanezzer (yeah wrongly spelt) the readings of his heart I mean, it's not just a frequency graph, there's an actual image of his heart moving on those screens.
Two things,
One is that when Neo was brought back to life I always felt it was more than just the "magic" provided by Trinity's kiss. When Neo asked Morpheus if you can be killed in the Matrix Morpheus replies "The mind makes it real". If Neo properly accepted his status as the "One" then he truly grasped the concept of the false reality right through his various layers of consciousness. (Compared to everyone else who are freed who just accepts it with reason but do not fully grasp it wholeheartedly. Hence he knew he had not been killed and after he realised he could come back from the dead he knew he was the One.
Also, I don't know what it entirely means when it says Neo's code (and everything that was special about it) is needed to restart Zion. Why couldn't any one of the 1% be used. (I know there are superficial arguments to explain this but could someone please come up with something more than "but Neo's the ONE!!"). I was thinking though rather than the matrix-within-a-matrix idea, perhaps there are various virtual realitys connected with a central core of the machine mainframe mentioned somewhere in the movie. This means that a "real world" matrix wouldnt be another level but just on an equal footing with "the matrix" matrix. Hence when humans in the "real world" plug into "the matrix" they are just switching from one virtual reality to another. This could mean than when any of the "One"s choose the right-hand door (the salvation one) an entirely new "real world" matrix is created and hence no-one in the new matrix remembers the last "real world" matrix as they think theirs is the first. (With the exception of the "One" that created it but what happens to him is a bit hazy anyway.)
As for the Smith issue. In the first film Smith tells Morpheus how much he hates living in the matrix as it has a "stench" of humans who he detests. Now that he is a renegade program he can not get out of it other than destroying everything, machines and humans alike. (I think theres a hint of this in the Revolutions trailer.)
P.S. Can somebody give me some thoughts on my last post - everyone has seemed to ignored it!
I think with the thermodynamics of the fact that it just wouldn't work, and that they could just use fusion, I think that they won't provide an explanation 4 that, u can't it's ludicrous. The point is that the films are based on various philosiphies, nothing is real anymore, that french guy (philosipher in real life, not in the film) wrote a book that we live life through signs, newspapers and TV so nothing is real anymore. Thats the book where Neo hides his minidiscs in the first film. Also, they wouldn't have been able to make films about it if the Machines just used fusion (or used elephants in the matrix, that would be funny tho), thus the film is not about seeking a logical explanation to them using humans, but about the humans in the matrix and what they do.
The BIG Question, has it got the potential (The first one got better each time you watched it) to be better than the original?? Tough one!
I think Neo is the machine from the 9th Animatrix film Matriculated (the machine that the humans in the real-real world inspired to join their rebellion/revolution).
Working with RIO's idea (that the "real" world is just another part of the matrix), in the real-real world the machine found other humans and cunningly decided to inject itself into the matrix as the 6th replacement of the Neo entity (where previous ones were programs or humans coded by the Architect/Oracle), but with the difference that it would choose love, something previously unknown to machines, and thus create a revolution within the matrix, and eventually cause its downfall.
The Oracle said it wasn't the one because its not a human but a machine, and it chose a different door because its a machine and injected itself into the matrix with that intention.
My take. Obviously a lot is left open for debate.
The Architect is an avatar of the machines, an embodiment of the universal laws of mathematics. As he suggests, he is the "Father" of the Matrix and as Neo guesses, The Oracle is the mother. I know people have guessed that Persephone might fill this role, but there's really no hard evidence for this (not including the "hard" evidence gained from staring at Monica Belucci - rowr) as opposed to a LOT of evidence behind The Oracle being the mother. The Architect sees the world as a mathematical model solveable through equation, and is incapable of understanding human intuition and emotion. That's where the Oracle comes in. The two are working as a team, presently.
To further explain, let me take a cue from the Architect and use a grotesquely oversimplified mathematical metaphor. From Douglas Adams, we know that the answer to life, the universe, and everything is 42. The Architect wants to divide this up into an equation to characterize human existence. So, naturally, he splits it into 42 elements of 1, creating his "perfect" mathematical model.
It fails, the humans reject it, and "entire crops [are] lost" as Agent Smith put it in the first movie. So The Oracle comes along with a better idea. For whatever reason (intuition, love, emotion), the humans will accept The Matrix when divided by 13. Unfortunately, in Integer math, that can only account for 39 of the 42 parts of humanity. The three left over will reject The Matrix, as did everybody in the first go-around. But it turns out that if you create this alternate Matrix, known as Zion, the 0.1%, or 3 out of 42, will find it, accept that they are in the "real" world, and can thus still be controlled in Zion.
But take Zion as dividing out by two. That still leaves a remainder of 1, aka Neo. He is the one person that rejects both the "Traditional" matrix (Earth) and the "Upper" matrix (Zion).
It's clear that the supernatural powers in the world, being able to "bend the rules" of the program are derivative of being able to reject that reality. The Zion residents, the 0.1%, have powers in The Matrix. Neo has extraordinary powers in The Matrix, and, given his destruction of the Sentinels at the end of the movie, has some similar (if potentially lesser - ergo his coma) powers in Zion as well. This is the case because he rejects both realities.
So, anyway, The Architect and The Oracle know that if left unchecked, the remainders of their realities will end their control over humanity, so they have designed a system to purge out that element every so often, using deception as opposed to control. They bury a few lies in what is mostly the truth, concoting a prophecy of "The One" as their salvation, when in truth, of the left door vs. right door choice given to Neo (analagous to the red pill vs. blue pill choice he was given in the first movie), neither choice resulted in the humans' triumph over the programs, as prophecized. The whole point of everything leading up to that point was to get Neo to step into the right door, reboot the Matrix, and rebuild Zion from a seed of humanity. They can't simply destroy Zion, as it's clear that Zion is a necessary component in order for the first Matrix to work ("The otherwise contradictory systemic anomaly"), but they will, if Neo chooses the right door and goes back into the Matrix to save Trinity. "There are levels of survival we are prepared to accept". I.E., now that Neo is onto their duplicity, it's war, and the third movie will be about Neo's attempt to save humanity from extinction.
All just guesses of course, but that's the most consistent explanation that I can come up with. I think it was made fairly clear that Neo now has powers in the Zion world similar (but not identical) to what he has in The Matrix, and that what took out the Sentinels was *not* an EMP (as previously suggested, an EMP would have shut down the ship for a while as well - it did in the first movie).
It seems likely to me that the resolution will not be in one side's victory over the other, but in the re-achievement of a symbiosis and greater understanding between the two. The conversation that the Counselor and Neo had in the Engineering level is one hint at that, the existence of Persephone (a rogue sentient program in The Matrix fascinated with the idea of human love) is another.
In which case Agent Smith is the only real villian left at the end, a computer program given a dose of freewill but unprepared to deal with it, resulting in the creation of a mindless, self-replicating computer virus intent on destroying anything and everything it can.
And in a pure, non-meta movie comment, I can only find amusement with those who felt the story of the second movie was somehow inferior to the first. The first, once you got past the idea that it was redefining reality, was a very straightforward hero's journey/biblical allegory. The second, leading to the third, appears to be striking out in an entirely new direction. Excellent film.
Just another small detail. I have now seen the film twice, and I am sure I have seen something which may have a strong bearing on theories about the Matrix within a Matrix. When Neo says to Trinity that "the bullet is still inside you" he puts his hand into her and we see the Matrix code. Then there is a cutscene to Morpheus where he injects something into one of Trinity's inplants. Then (and this is the point) I am sure there is a split second clip of what looked like a hand pulling something from a bunch of black wires/cords amongst the reddish gue we saw in the first Matrix film where the humans are incubated. If anyone else saw this then PLEASE give me ur views, because it is making my brain go wild. Im sure I didnt imagine it!
Another question... Did the twins survive?
Also, rewatching the trailers for Reloaded there are a couple of bits that weren't in the film. (At least in my recollection.) One was the guys with the shoulder rocket launcher and another is a voiceover between Trinity and a French accent (The Merovingian I assume).
Merovingian: "You are ready to die for this man?"
Trinity: "Believe it."
I can't remember if this was said in the conversation in the restaurant. Can someone help me out?
I just saw the movie for the first time. Loved it. I enjoyed reading all the post so far and want to add my 2 cents. I feel way to understand this movie is to identify the underlying philosophical principle. The movie just shouts the yin / yang duality to me. A quick background about Yin / Yang.
"This Symbol (Yin-Yang) represents the ancient Chinese understanding of how things work. The outer circle represents "everything", while the black and white shapes within the circle represent the interaction of two energies, called "yin" (black) and "yang" (white), which cause everything to happen. They are not completely black or white, just as things in life are not completely black or white, and they cannot exist without each other"
- Humans need the machines and vice visa. As the counselor so clearly points out to Neo. Neither can survive nor prosper without the other. But there is a consistent struggle for power of the other. The machines can't totally control the humans. The first attempt of the matrix failed. There must be a choice so the Architect and the Mother create a system of control where universe (the matrix and the Zion in the real world) will renew itself. The Oracle, Zion, the One is all part of the system of control which allows Neo go back to the Source and reboot the system and keep everything running in balance. However, the balance with not kept in this instance of the world. Neo rebels against authority too much, loves and hopes too much. Now both man and machine risk complete and total mutual destruction.
- Neo is human and machine, just as Agent Smith is now machine and human. Again the duality here. I don't know why Neo has the special power to send EMP, but clearly Neo passes out with the blue glow around his head just like the damaged machines indicates the Neo has the same weakness as the machines in the real world. Like the Yin / Yang. Each part must have some aspect of the other. Majority of the machines are cold and mathematical, while very small number of machines understand the need for "love", "hate", and other emotions (Persephone, the Mother, Agent Smith). Off track here, but this might explain why Reeves acting is so deadpan, he is part machine.
My prediction about Revolutions.. The conflict is individual vs. the masses, emotion vs. logic, choice vs. fate, humans vs. machines. Both will need to create a new system of co-existence that doesn't involve this constant risk of mutual destruction. Two parallel revolutions within the man and machine community that is expressed in the final fight with make this happen so how.
I can't get along with the matrix in the matrix idea - but I've got an idea for how movie 3 might be. It isn't flawless though - I believe that Mr. Smith will have a much bigger role than my idea seemingly gives room for.
My Idea is:
Neo wakes up - he have found out that they are in fact living in just another matrix. He tells this to those persons around him. Some believe some doesn't - There is a great debate about this. It ends out that a few believes and go to "the real world" - the rest stays in Zion believing that they are in fact living in the real world.
Not long after that Neo find out that this "3. real world" isnt real after all - and takes a few guys the a "4. real world". Very shortly after that he finds out that isn't the real world either. He realises that there is in fact infinitly many levels - and break down - but only for a while. The "boy which been spoons" shows up (for real or in his dream) daying "Try not to bend the Matrix 'cause that is impossible. Try instead to realise the truth. There is no Matrix...". He then realises that the first matrix is in fact the real world - but they are hypnotized. He then wakes people up from this dream.
I believe in fits rather o.k. with the ending of the first movie as well:
(Phone)
The One: I know you're out there. I can feel you now. I know that you're afraid. You're afraid of us. You're afraid of change. I don't know the future. I didn't come here to tell you how this is going to end. I came here to tell you how it's going to begin. I'm going to hang up this phone and then I'm going to show these people what you don't want them to see. I'm going to show them a world without you, a world without rules and controls, without borders or boundaries, a world where anything is possible. Where we go from there is a choice I leave to you.
So - what do you think?
I was pretty bored by the first half of the movie, so I thought the movie was okay. The fight sequences were cool, and the highway scene was the more amazing one, because you can actually relate to being on a highway. Morpheus bores. The speech he gave at the rally/rave was lame, which leads me to think the smelly hippies (TM Cartman) are pretty stupid too.
Anyway, what I thought was most interesting was, given the information that Larry Wachowski (or maybe it's the other brother, who knows) is leaving his wife for a dominatrix, there's a whole new subtext for the films. For example, when Neo revives Trinity, he's not holding her hand, he's holding her latex-gloved hand.
Ok I have one comment on the parallel-matrix
theory:
Agent Smith, while keeping Morpheus imprisoned in
this building (in part I) he tells Morpheus:
AGENT SMITH
I hate this place. This zoo.
This prison. This reality,
whatever you want to call it, I
can't stand it any longer. It's
the smell, if there is such a
thing. I feel saturated by it. I
can taste your stink and every
time I do, I fear that I've
somehow been infected by it.
what does agent smith, which is actually just a
computer program,mean with saying 'This Reality,what ever you want to call it' ?
How can agents live outside the actual matrix?
Only if there is a precedent matrix...
not sure, just a thought.
Some things to consider:
1) Why does the Oracle have "many enemies" if she is the "Mother" of the Matrix?
2) Why did the agents seek the information from Morpheus in the first film if they have, in fact, already destroyed Zion several times?
3) Why would the architect give Neo a choice at all, if he really wanted Neo to return to the source. He didn't have to tell Neo that Trinity had re-entered the Matrix. In fact, he could have even given Neo the option of including Trinity in the selected female list of those to rebuild Zion. Instead, everything he said manipulated Neo into returning to the Matrix, not into the other option. Is this the Architect's intention, for Neo to return to the Matrix?
4) What did the visit to the Architect accomplish?
5) Why would the agents seek to terminate the Keymaker, if, in fact, the keymaker were essential to the Architect's plan (namely, getting the One to the source so as to recycle the matrix)?
6) The Keymaker, when asked why he is helping the humans, responds with something that strongly suggests that they, humans and machines, are all in it together, all for the same purpose. What does this mean? We must consider such comments in light of Neo's conversation with the Senator on the dock of the engineering level (in which the Senator suggests machines and humans depend on one another).
WOW, a lot of food for thought here.
But i seem to have noticed that most of the truly enlightening posts were written by people who do not believe in the matrix in matrix theory. I however feel that this is very valid and so i'll try to present my arguments.
As RIO pointed out, most people have bypassed completely the Animatrix in their comments. Everyone has omitted the game "Enter the Matrix". Both these titles are unquestionably "matrix core". 4 of the 9 episodes of the Animatrix where directed by the Wachowski's (The Final Flight of the Osiris, Second Renaissance I and II and Kid's Story), as was the story line of the game (which featured some cinematic scenes that did not show in the film). Just to show how closely these are intertwined, an example:
- Final Flight of the Osiris shows the ship discovering the sentinel army drilling to Zion, and dropping a data tape into the Matrix before being destroyed.
- The game then shows you (as Niobi) going into the Matrix to get the disc.
- Then the film starts with Niobi passing on the message.
Now my arguments:
1. Restarting the Matrix: The cycle of events would be as follows. Some 'the one' choses to restart to save humanity, all inhabitants of Zion are killed, 'the one' selects 23 individuals from the matrix to create a new Zion.
How does this tie in with what we know ?
In the first film Morpheus says something to this extent: "A long time ago a man was born within the Matrix who had the ability to shape the world around him, it was he who freed the first of us."
So 'the one' selects 23 people, tells them that they are the first to be freed from the Matrix, they build a city and proceed to multiply and free others. I've seen various comments that suggest the Councelor (and probably the whole council) were the 23 people who where freed by the previous 'one'. Apart from them are but a few other older people (those that come and ask Neo to look over their children) which suggests that they WERE the beginning.
Why restart the Matrix? Seems simple enough. It has been stated that the matrix is designed upon a time that was the peek of human civilization. As that time ends they must restart it, and start again. How much could they program? I would guess around 30-40 years (the age of most of the people in Zion).
Which brings up an interesting point:
Since Neo arrived he helped free minds at a rate of "more people in the past six months than in the 6 years before that". That's a lot of free minds, but not a lot of older people. This suggests that the previous 'one' didn't do any more within the Matrix after choosing his 23. We know he died, so does this mean he died just after the incident? If so how? I'm interested in seeing how this will be explained. Especially the possibility that the previous one is still alive (he would be the same age as the council).
2 .The Oracle: "When he died the Oracle prophesied his coming ..."
"This is the same Oracle that made the prophecy ?"
"Yes, she is very old. She's been with us since the beginning".
This makes sense. After a Matrix restart, the 23 contact the Oracle for help. She make's a prophecy that a new 'one' will be born when the current 'one' dies ... so it goes. So she has some control and manipulation over the people.
The question is who's side is she on?
But first is she the 'mother' of the Matrix? Some suggest that this is in fact Persephone because of the reference to a program made to study the human phyche, and how Persephone seeks a kiss. I believe that in fact it is the Oracle. The Architect says clearly that the 'mother' discovered the need for choice, and it is the Oracle who constantly (even in the first film) makes people conscious of their choices, and his "Please" probably only signals disgust of her new name. She is after all an exile program.
Which side? That's the difficult one. But...
a) she is an exile, so she has to fight the system to survive.
b) everything she has said so far has been spot on.
c) her two topics of choice are choices and love.
Choices ... obvious, Love? She tells Trinity she will fall in love with the one. She suggests to Neo that Trinity loves him.
She says "being the one is a lot like being in love". In the game when you see the Oracle she talks about love. Now why is this important? Because it's because of love that Neo chooses not to go to the source, but to return and save Trinity. It seems to me that the Oracle is very much aware of this, and knows that Neo will make this choice as she has known before, and despite this she makes her prophecy, and tells him to go to the source to make the choice. Although there isn't much to go on, I fell that this suggests that Neo is in fact meant to save humanity from machines, and she is in fact on ... well ... her own side. Probably she see that she has a better chance of survival with humans, either that or like the keymaker, it is what he is meant to do. Anyway, she does say she's a believer ...
3. EMP killed sentinels: A few people have proposed the theory that the sentinels at the end of reloaded where destroyed by the emp of the arriving ship. Others said that this is impossible as the ship would immobilize itself... and so on.
The end of the game addresses this issue beyond any doubt. At the end of the game Niobi's ship the Locos is fleeing from a hoard of sentinels and in the end, when they are trapped the wait for all the sentinels to approach and then fire the emp. After is a cut scene showing Niobi and Ghost waiting in the dark cockpit of their ship for someone to find and rescue them.
This is also stated earlier in the game where commander Lock is stating his strategy plan to take all the ships at emp distance from each other to make a huge ump radius to take out all the sentinels. It is stated specificly that the ships must stay out of each other's emp range. And in both the game and film the counter attack is said to have failed because one ship fired the emp to early disabling the others (Bane's ship).
Furthermore in The Matrix (#1), they cannot fire the emp until Neo is out so they don't kill him which means that the emp affects internal electronics also, but despite that does not put anyone into a coma, so that can't explain what happened to Neo.
4. So what happened? Is the Zion world another Matrix?:
I think so. Besides shutting down the sentinels at the end, he shows a lot of extra sensory perception in the real world throughout the film. Sensing approaching sentinels, knowing that there is a bomb, etc. This is coming close to the level of perception he has in the Matrix, ie. sensing the arrival of agents at the beginning of the film.
An important clue could be his coma. Apart from the reference that the previous 'one' awoke himself, it is unknown how this would occur, especially since we now know that he didn't awake himself, mearly saying so after restarting the cycle.
The Animatrix is helpful in this. Two episodes, "World Record" and "Kid's Story" show people who awake themselves. In "World Record" an athlete awakes through overexertion but is automatically reinserted with his memory erased. Inside the Matrix he falls down unconscious and then goes into a coma. The other, "Kid's Story", which is written by the Wachowskis, is about a boy who escapes the Matrix, kind of (this is the kid that chases Neo all over Zion, his own personal fan club). Despite what he thinks, Neo did not save him. He saved himself. It's a very interesting episode because it starts with his dreams of falling, and at the end he finds himself in that situation, at that moment he believes and allows himself to fall to his death. But despite dying in the Matrix he awakes outside. Trinity calls it selfsubstantiation (somewhat similar to Neo's resurrection in the first film where he dies but his consciousness lives on and by force of will he returns to life). This is very similar to Neo's situation. He has dreams of the future (which the Oracle comments on), and the visions are during his sleep in the real world! While not connected to the Matrix he see's its future. At the end of the film he realises what he is sensing, stops the sentinels and goes into a coma. This i why i feel he awoke from a Zion-Matrix at that moment.
Facts recap:
a) His powers at the end of the film.
b) Coma similar to the effects of self waking in the Animatrix.
c) Dreams in the Zion world coincide with occurrences in the Matrix, which couldn't be possible if they weren't connected. The Oracle for example lives inside the Matrix.
d) More to come ... read on ...
e) Neo dies in the first film both inside the Matrix and out, but somehow returns to life. Where exactly was his mind at that time ? Maybe close to awakening but not close enough. Similarly Trinity in reloaded, although Neo does get her heart beating similarly to how medics would try to revive someone who's heart stopped beating.
5. Smith: When Smith was destroyed by Neo he was meant to return to be deleted, but since he has shown himself to be an individualist he decides to become an exile. Both he and the Oracle elaborate on this. With this he gains access to the programers passage that only the exile programs seem to use in this film (the system can't seem to find them there) and possibly some additional knowledge. What knowledge? Well there are some exile programs that know more about the matrix than agents seem to. Foremost is the Oracle. The Oracle obviously knows where Zion is another level of the Matrix since she is the 'mother', so it is possible that Smith could gain this knowledge.
I strongly believe that this is why he tries to exit into the Zion world. But instead he becomes human. This could mean that the Zion world is in fact real. But I doubt that. The main reason is that no other agent has tried to use such a trick to infiltrate the Zion world and destroy it from within. As i reason it, Smith gained knowledge of a second layer Matrix, and how to exit into it when he exiled, but he didn't know enough. The rules of the Zion-world are different and became physically human (his shock is shown by him cutting his hand, he appears to not quite believe what has happened to him). Because of the different rules no one else has shown an ability to exert control over the Zion-world until Neo does at the end.
6. Rogue programs: It was stated that they come from different versions of the matrix. But if the matrix was restarted 5 times then where did they survive? As i've said, it seems that the whole programer maintainance corridor is accessible only to the exile programs, and here they have hidden themselves from the system programs (agents wan to kill the keymaker and the wraith-twins). This suggests that this is a level outside the matrix, but why not reboot the whole thing unless there is something you want to keep. I reason that the machines wanted to keep the Zion-world so they destroy Zion with sentinels instead of rebooting it as well. You could argue that this proves that Zion is the real world, but then there would be absolutely no reason not to reboot the programers corridor and the rogue programs.
The game gives yet more info. At one point there is a cut scene where Niobi, about to exit the Matrix, is confronted by an old man with long grey hair (who appears in the revolutions trailer) who says: "72 hours, that's how long Zion lasted last time". So this is another program that survived the system reboot.
7. Zion part 2: More importantly i think they need to keep 'the one' from realizing the truth. The Architect says that 1% of people reject the Matrix, and they are put in Zion, moreover we have 'the one' who is even more of an anomaly. Have you ever thought how Neo is able to do what he does? Before I saw reloaded i had no idea, but now i do.
No one else knows how he does what he does, his operator is constantly shocked, and he cannot teach anyone else what he knows.
If the Zion-world is the second level Matrix, and the Matrix itself is programed within the Zion world then i figure that what he is doing is manipulating the Zion-world program to effect the rules within the Matrix. This is pretty far fetched but it shows how he seems to sense more and more of what is going on in the Zion-world as he gets more powerful, starting of course with hearing Trinity speak to him at the end of the first film while he was dead in the Matrix and she was outside of it.
Lets assume that of the 1% that reject the matrix there is 1% that reject the Zion program too. Such an individual is prone to awaken from the second level despite it's different rules. As the Architect said with regards to Zion, if left unchecked this could pose a threat to the system. So 'the one' is coaxed into rebooting the Matrix and told that Zion will be destroyed to stop 'the one' from finding out the truth.
Secondly, the more people on Zion the more chance that a 1% of them will doubt the reality, and i think especially of the people born through natural means in Zion who i assume are those minds that refuse the Matrix program straight from birth and are dropped directly into the Zion-world. The destruction of Zion is a simple way to kill of the 1% that reject the program, while the rest are reinserted after reboot with an erased memory.
And so the system has worked so far, until Neo who, guided by love rather than union with his species decides not to reboot, and then after postulating the words of the Architect begins to understand the truth.
8. Religion and the Matrix concluded: The Matrix is a religious feast.
From Jesus references:
- "Thomas Anderson" : Thomas - the non believer, Andros - (greek) Human, Anderson - Son of Man
- "Your my savior, man. My own personal Jesus Christ" - (c) Choi in The Matrix (#1)
- Neo's death is foretold by the Oracle. Neo dies, to save humanity then is resurrected and becomes 'the one'.
all the way through to Budhism.
But above all are the gnostic beliefs (which are similar to Christianity, but from a wider viewpoint, which give a different vision of God and a godly hierarchy, and a different view of the role of Jesus the messiah).
In short the gnostic view states that the Demiurge (false god, the god in Judaism and Christianity) created a flawed world, a prison for the divine element in each being. Each individual must through knowledge and understanding awake to a higher level of consciousness to become one with the true God.
The gods are set in a hierarchy. First the main God who created existence, and made other gods including Sophia the 'Mother', she in turn made the demiurge, a flawed creation that perceives itself as perfect desired power, rebelled and created the world.
In gnosticism Jesus is said to have been such a person who was send by the 'Mother' to help other people transcended to a higher level of consiousness and free themselves from the restrictions of the world.
The parallels to the Matrix are obvious. The Oracle, the Mother, guides Neo on his quest. But then what does this mean?
The Oracle is the Mother, and the Architect is the Father. His, creating the Matrix which failed repeatedly would put him in the role of the Demiurge, which fits with the arrogance he portrays. But this would mean that the Oracle is on a higher level than the Architect. Possible her becoming an exile may have given her a higher status which is why her prophecies are much more accurate than those of the Architect. And then of course there would be yet another level, the real God. What goes on from here is anyone's guess.
ops, that turned out long O_o
Lugo, wicked post, all seems to make sense and the most in depth analysis on here.
Mr_Anderson, I must admit that you give a pretty good reference/plot hole with...
"I liked that Neo being a machine but wait, huge hole, what about the various readings on the Nebucanezzer (yeah wrongly spelt) the readings of his heart I mean, it's not just a frequency graph, there's an actual image of his heart moving on those screens."
But I'm leaning towards what Changster said regarding the idea that Neo is man AND machine. I used the term robot originally, because I didn't want to use the cheesy term "cyborg", but I do think that Neo being a cyborg (organic parts mixed with machine parts) would explain those readings on the hovercraft when they first saved him. Although, it does still leave the question of "wouldn't they have discovered at least some of his machine parts?" Despite this, I hold to my Neo is a machine belief, albeit tenuously, because it would explain SO much.
Finally, I must admit that lugo presents a damn compelling argument for the matrix in a matrix theory. this is starting to make me all loopy, I'll be holstering my matrix theory guns now. ;^)
I really like your post
BUT - what will convince the audience that there are only those 2 matrices?
The part I don't like about multiple matrices is that it is very hard to make it stop - how do we know that there isn't just one more layer?
I guess it might be in the buddism part - since thats where the world within world comes from - or have I misunderstood your post?
Lugo: I really like your post
BUT - what will convince the audience that there are only those 2 matrices?
The part I don't like about multiple matrices is that it is very hard to make it stop - how do we know that there isn't just one more layer?
I guess it might be in the buddism part - since thats where the world within world comes from - or have I misunderstood your post?
I haven't read this page entirely... but i have a comment that may have already been addressed
Why Smith is still trying to kill Neo?
In the movie, renegade programs are like angels in the bible, they have no free will... smith says so, he is not free because he has a purpose, and without it he would not exists... his original purpose was to kill Neo, thus even if he is "free", he is still trying to complete his purpose becuase without it, he's just useless
'lugo: I too, if you look back in the posts have pondered what you did, about neo and the other one's dying or not dying or losing there powers or not losing there powers after the whole choice in the matrix of the left or right door. I think that the one continues to free minds with the people of Zion, but does not posses any of his "powers" in the matrix that he did before his "code" was re-inserted; so he would continue just as a normal human that could enter the matrix, but with out his special powers; that is my thoughts after looking at all of the evidence. Also I think you may be hinting at this, but I don't know for sure, I too think that if what you are saying about the council being made up of the 23 and the one being among them, then if I had to guess I say that it would be the senator; if any of them. As for your matrix with in a matrix theory, it is a good one and a nicely laid argument. I do, on the other hand disagree with the matrix in a matrix idea though (maybe sometime I could write out my reasons, if I ever had time to list them as neatly as you did)
I believe that the oracle is on the humans’ side. I am going to do a little philosophy here to prove it, but it will take some explaining of ideas here so bear with me (I have had classes in philosophy, but I am by no means an expert, nor do I claim to be). There is two different ways of thinking in philosophy in regards to the future, the first is determinism and the second is indeterminism (these are the ideas that Morphesus and the Merovingian discuss). For those of you who are not enlightened, determinism is the idea that even though through out a life it seems there are choices and decisions to be made, but there really is no choice and everything is predetermined by its precursor and the precursor by its precursor, etc.; cause and effect (just as the movie says). Indeterminism states the complete opposite; there are different choices to be made and any of them could be made, the catch is that the choice is not decided by previous events. I myself believe in a form of indeterminism where choice is caused by previous experiences. That is a long enough lecture and I must apologize because I have misplaced my text books from that semester so I can't give credit to the authors of the ideas I have sited above (if I find them later I will post them). Anyone who has seen the movies knows these ideas are debated in one part. Take the oracle for example, she is a classic case of determinism. Think, has she stated anything that has not been accurate? If she has the ability to know these things ahead of time, then the movies must believe in this idea of determinism. There is plenty of evidence to support this claim. When Neo sees the Oracle he tries to prove her wrong by not sitting, but fails. As much as I wish Morphesus was right and saying that it is choice, the Merovingian is right in the sense of the movie, it is cause and effect. Neo's fate has already been decided and the Oracle knows it. Take these things as a few other examples of the cause and effect idea. Cause: Neo is told of the keymaster and what he needs to do, Effect: Neo goes gets the keymaster and so on, Cause: Neo is in love with trinity and enters the room with the architect and is told of trinity's problems, Effect: Neo does what we all knew he would do saves the girl. A great example of this idea is the thought that the oracle presents in the first movie, if she hadn't told neo of the vase would he have still broken it? No, is the answer, it was cause and effect. Same with trinity and neo falling in love and then Neo's decision to save her and not take the other door. The point I am trying to make is that this movie (in my honest opinion, but not necessarily the correct one) is based on determinism, or as Morphesus calls it fate. Here it the argument summed up in the shape of a philosophical argument.
1. The future can, and has, be predicted very accurately every time (if you think this is wrong tell when the oracle was wrong about her predictions)
2.If the future can be predicted this accurately every time, then the future has already been written so that it can be predicted (because it is impossible to predict something every time with this may possible outcomes with out being wrong one or twice).
3. If statement 1 and 2 is true then the matrix is based on determinism.
Now I know all of you are saying that is fine and dandy but WHAT THE HECK does this have to do with the Oracle being of the Humans side? The answer simply is if she can predict all these out comes and know all of this then she knew that neo would choose not to reboot the matrix, eventually meaning that the machines would lose all of the humans if this happened, so if she on the side of the machines then she would not have helped neo. She helped neo because she knows what will happen in the end already, humans and machines will get along or the humans will win (only daft idiot would end it with them losing and I give the brothers much more credit than that), but this could be wrong, regardless her stasis of being good does not change. I know this is long if you have read it all, thanks I hope if anyone has any thoughts or counter arguments they will state them.
To Dan: About the spoon thing
It is not the same spoon. Why? Because in Matrix (#1) the spoon is perfect, flawless because he can bend the spoon at will w/out any damage. In Reloaded (you might have noticed it), the spoon is all dirty, damaged...
My guess is that the boy tried to bend a spoon (whatever spoon) in the real world (I don't like the "matrix in another matrix theory, sorry :)) and did not succeed, hense the damage it has. (if you recall, the boy says in Matrix (#1): "Don't try and bend the spoon, it's impossible"; but still he tried in the real world)
That's only my little theory about that.
Concerning the "powers" Neo has in the real world, I believe it's what was "copied, overwritten", as Smith says in Reloaded (speaking about when Neo killed Smith; there was an "exchage" of powers between the to; they are mirrors to each other). I think he gained the ability to "sense", like the agents. And that's, to my opinion, why he "feels" the agents at the beginning of Reloaded (+ the symbolic of the ear-thing Smith gives to Neo).
Furthermore, it is the 1st time he encounters Sentinels since the 1st movie and thus, similarely to the agents, he can "feel" them, and that's what's "different".
Concerning the fact that he stoped the sentinels at the end? Well... I think he just gained the ability to interact with the machine AI's during his "transfer of power" with Smith (following the same idea that he can be uploaded a Kung-Fu program; it makes sense since Smith's program can now infect humans). And he doesn't really stop them as he would with bullets: he just disables them and it demanded so much of him that he fell into a coma.
"But fear not", this is only my opinion ;)
To Jusu :
I would like to say something about the idea that Agent Smith "copied" himself into Bane in the same way Neo learned his Kung-Fu. When Tank uploaded Neo the Kung-Fu program, Neo could only use these skills inside the Matrix, not in the supposingly real world, so it should mean that whatever program is uploaded to a human, it could only work inside the Matrix. Thus unless the Zion-world is yet another Matrix, Smith wouldn't have been able to duplicate himself into the mind of a real human.
Well....anyway.... just another opinion :)
I just watched it again today after reading all this and writing my own views and so I've a few adjustments to make:
1. Zion life-span: I missed this first time around. In morpheus' speech in the cavern he states "we have fought the machines for one hundred years ..."
The councelor says: "I slept for the first eleven years of my life" which means he was freed from the matrix at the age of eleven.
So he neither looks to be 111 years old, nor is 11 a good age for someone chosen to rebuild Zion, which shows that the council aren't the original 23. Which is a shame because it was a nice idea.
2. Oracle: -All is in Vain- asked about her enemies, and i noticed some references to it in the film. The Merovingian say "tell the witch her time is almost up". In the game the Oracle (played by the new actress) explains what happened to her, that two programs she trusted sold the termination code of her former shell to the Merovengian. She also says she let them do it because their child would be important later ... hmmm.
Also in the movie the Oracle says that her time with Neo is up and leaves just before Smith appears.
This is quite a solid argument for the postulate that the Oracle is indeed on the humans' side. The Merovingian desires power, and has survived several Matrix reboots (He says to Neo: "I survived your predecessors and i will survive you") so his appempt to kill the Oracle could mean he is afraid that with her help he will succeed in destroying the system.
3. Smith: I noticed in the revolutions trailer something that suggests Neo will have to destroy Smith to save humanity. Someone says "you have to destroy it before tonight" while scenes of Smith are showing, and the on the street in the rain scene he says to Smith: "It ends tonight".
Also Smith is very much aware now of the whole of the Matrix and it's history. At the begining of the movie he says to himself [ :) ] "That went as expected" "Yes, thing are going exactly as before" "Well, not exactly"
4. Matrix in Matrix: More interesting things releted to this.
a) When the Neb lands and the kid (Neo's #1 fan) runs up, Trinity says "How does he always know".
It seems that he can sense Neo in the realworld like neo begins to sense things. This is interesting because as i've already written this is the kid in the Animatrix who awoke himself, died in the Matrix but kept living in the real world. No one knows how. The only other person to survive death by force of will alone is Neo.
b) When Smith (as Bane) attempts to assassinate Neo, he wishes him good luck and then says "We'll see you". This is just before Neo visits the Oracle and the Smith fight scene. Does this mean that Bane is able to comunicate with the Smiths in the Matrix? Yes! Since he also is the only survivor of the failed counter attack. The sentinels left him on purpose.
Like Neo's control over the sentinels this could not be possible if both worlds were not electronically linked, since the human body does not generate any signals that could be intercepted at a distance by machines and used to communicate.
lugo, reading one of your earlier posts, am i right in saying that you think that when Neo in the "real world matrix" stopped those sentinals, he, like the man in world record, awoke from the "real world matrix" and is now in the real real world due to the physical over-exuberance? That would explain the "coma" he is in. is this right or have i totaly missed your point.
i think there are only 2 matrices. infinate matrices or even more than 2 would make revolutions a bit repetitive(right word?) if they kept realising they were in another matrix.
yep, i think he realized he was in another level matrix and stopped the sentinels, but since he had not trained the required skills it was a physical and mental exertion that pulled him out into a real-real world, while his body dropped to the ground and appeared to be in a coma, much like the man in the Animatrix episode "World Record".
Alright--We're gonna try to tie as much together as possible in a way that makes logical sense to us, being as little farfetched as possible.
First, Zion. We agree with one or two previous posts (A Guy From St. Louis, I believe), in that the existence of Zion is perpetuated by the machines for a reason which is consistent with their needs and purposes. The purpose of Zion is to have a place for humans to function, and perform two tasks that the machines are not able to do themselves--find and recruit all the other members of that 1% of the population which does not accept the Matrix as reality, and to locate the One from those people.
Once enough rebels have been located, the machines exercise their control over both the humans and their situation by "resetting" Zion. That is to say, eliminating all the human rebels of the current generation. The purpose of the chosen 23 people is to begin the locating of all the rebels and dissenters of the next era of the Matrix. In other words, by isolating the free minds and concentrating them together, Zion helps the machines, by allowing them to keep the humans in check by simply destroying Zion.
To address the question of why the machines don't simply destroy all of Zion and not leave the 23 chosen people to repopulate it, we refer to the Architect's speech. He explains how the imperfection in humans is so innate and intrinsic that it is a part of the very mathematical equation underlying this world. In other words, the rebel humans cannot be avoided or prevented. That imperfection will ALWAYS exist, and therefore the machines must find a way of finding, concentrating, and controlling them (Zion).
As the Architect implies, as long as the humans feel that Zion is their creation and that it is their actions which sustain its existence, they will have no reason to rebel against that system. Because they have choices, humans feel as though they "chose" to enter Zion, rather than that they entered it through some kind of filtration system.
Second, the Oracle. The Oracle is the "mother" of the Matrix, not Persephone. While it is the Architect's "job" to control and oversee the Matrix, it is the Oracle's job to find, through her "intuitive" programming and investigations "into the human psyche," those minds which can be freed and entered into Zion.
When the Architect scoffs "Please" in response to Neo referring to the Oracle as the mother of the Matrix, he is scoffing at the title "Oracle", because she is not an Oracle, not because she is not the mother of the Matrix. An oracle's function is to "see" the future. This is not what the Oracle does; she merely predicts the actions of humans based on her intuitive nature. Hence, the Architect scoffs when Neo calls her the Oracle, a title no doubt given to her by humans.
Third, Agent Smith. There is only one scenario that makes any kind of logical sense to us. Agent Smith has become a virus. This not only explains his rapid infestation of other bodies, but also explains both the "cataclysmic system crash" referred to by the Architect, and Neo's connection with Agent Smith that allows him to destroy the sentinel at the end of Reloaded (because machines can control other machines).
In addition to simply appearing to be a virus and act like a virus (replicating with no discernable goal in mind other than to multiply), there are storyline references which imply that Smith is a virus as well. In the first movie, Smith discusses how the human race behaves like a virus. Since he, an agent, was against the human race virus, he referred to himself as "the cure." In Reloaded, during the scene where Neo fights all the Smiths, Smith encounters a different agent on the side of all the fighting. They exchange some bitter words, and Smith proceeds to destroy the other agent by replicating himself once again. This shows that Smith is now against the agents as well, and since they are "the cure," Smith must now be "the virus."
At the end of Reloaded, when Neo is given a choice of doors in the Architect's room, he chooses his "left" door which is supposed to lead back to the Matrix, and to a "cataclysmic system crash which will lead to the destruction of all humans in the Matrix." Only part of this immediately happens. The door does return Neo to the Matrix, but there is no evidence of a "system crash." This system crash is taking the form of the replication and infestation of the Agent Smiths. A computer program, the Matrix, is being overrun by a virus, Agent Smith, which is leading to the destruction of all humans in the Matrix.
It is fairly obvious that Neo and Agent Smith share some kind of connection. They each kill each other and come back to life in a new state of being. They are referred to as "similar," at least by Agent Smith. We are not necessarily proposing that Neo is a "machine," but Neo definitely has some kind of connection to Agent Smith, a machine, which allows Neo to control machines in the same way. This explains Neo's destruction of the sentinel at the end of Reloaded. Either he is a machine, or he simply can control machines through his link with Smith. No Matrix within a Matrix. No magic.
We refuse to accept the Matrix in a Matrix theory for several reasons. First, wouldn't Neo have to see the "real world" Matrix in code the same way he sees the other Matrix in code? Second, if this were the case, this new twist would horrendously massacre the plot and would eliminate all the credibility and respectability that the filmmakers have gained through the making of the first two films. It would be so lame, and so irritatingly cliche. As of right now, at the conclusion of Reloaded, the directors are on the brink of what may be the most intricate and most finely-tuned creation of storytelling. I hope that they stay true to their style and keep the real world what it is.
Just a final thought: No one has been discussing the portals and those hallways filled with doors that lead to places outside the Matrix. Are these doors a new dimension? A new world? Other programs like the Matrix? Simply glitches? Or are they pathways put there by the Architect or other programmers? It's such an interesting aspect of the film, which hasn't gotten enough discussion.
Jeff and Melissa
Also, who are the 23 from the previous version of the Matrix? The ONLY human characters above the age of 40 or so were on the council in Zion. I know there are only 12 of them, but maybe they are the remnants of the last Matrix. I doubt it, personally, because I assume they would have to be long dead by now (see next paragraph).
What doesn't make any sense at all is how Zion can have so many people. It would take many many generations for that many people to originate from 23, which leads us to two possible scenarios: either Zion has never been destroyed at all, or it is WAY, WAY, WAY past the year 2199, which is what Morpheus believes it to be.
Jeff and Melissa
Jeff & Melissa
They don't originate from the 23 - they originate from the 23 and those they get from the Matrix.
My english could have been better - what does Cataclysmic mean?
Jeff and Melissa, I totally agree with you on every point...
One other thing.
Another thing that hasn't been discussed is the meaning of the number 101. You can notice it all through both episodes: both beginning and end rooms in Matrix (#1), the floor level of the restaurant in Reloaded, the highway (it's the highway 101), and many more that i don't remember right now. (I would even say the the trio represents this number: have you noticed how they walk always in the same way in Reloaded? Trinity - Morpheus - Neo : White-Black-White : 101... Could be a coincidense but whatever :p
So... back to the meaning of this number... Well, in binary counting, it means 5, however, the number 101 is the 6th binary number if we start a 0 (0,1,10,11,100,101): you got my point, it is the 6th version of the matrix.
It's just an idea... If someone has a better theory about the meaning of this number, please.
I watched the original film again today and noticed a few things. No doubt you guys have all spotted how often innocuous statements made by characters are filled with more meaning and often prophetic. e.g. The guy at Neo's door: "My own personal Jesus Christ", Smith (when talking about Neo's two aliases): "One of these lives has a future, the other does not". I couldn't help but notice the conversation between Morpheus and Tank during Neo's training.
Morpheus: "Is he OK?"
Tank: "Ten hours straight - he's a machine."
Also, there is an occasion in each film where an agent refers to Neo as "only human". Whether you think these two seemingly innocuous remarks go against each other or otherwise. (The "only human" remarks have more attention drawn to them, perhaps designed for the Agents to have a "oh my god he's more than human after all" storyline later.)
As for the argument against the matrix-within-a-matrix theory about the code seeing thing, at no point is Neo literally supposed to see everything made up of code! If he did see the code when he was in the matrix it wouldn't make up 3D objects. It's just supposed to show that Neo's sees the Matrix for what it is and can hence visualise it as merely code and therefore change it around him.
Jusu, that 101 thing is cool! I'd noticed it had popped up a couple of times in the first film but hadn't made the connection in Reloaded (as I've only seen it once.) I thought it was just supposed to be a comment on Neo being the one. I think you're spot on with the #6 in binary and Neo being the 6th "one". Could you inform the board if you remember any more 101 references.
P.S. DaDane, Cataclysmic comes from cataclysm which is an incredibly violent destruction of something. e.g. The cataclysm of Atlantis, the mythical continent destroyed in a few days by natural disasters. However it occasionally means a violent *change*, not destruction. Have we stumbled onto another of those prohecies here?
Macca: Thanx
Jusu: I'm studying computerscience - and the normal way to count for a computer (or for computerscientist anyway) is beginning with 0, so 101 is indeed the 6'th version.
It the trailer (the one from the games atleast) your hear Morpheus say "He fights for us" with surprise in his voice. It really puzzles me - I mean - why is he suprised that Neo fight for them - he always did, - didn't he?
Also - I really really dislike the Matrix in the Matrix idea (since it will really complicate things - how do you know for sure when you are in the real real world???) - But I guess that Mr. Smiths "Welcome back, we missed you" might suggest that he has been "away". Of course it could just be from the matrix (i.e. he was in the real world (Zion) - but I guess there's more to it than that).
I've always seen Room 101 as the same room in George Orwell's "1984". Room 101 was a torture room where people went into it believing it was something else. They became trapped in this room, like Neo was trapped in the Matrix. It was where people went in believing that 2 + 2 = 4, and ended up believing that 2 + 2 = 5.
Jeff and Melissa:
The fundemental flaw in the argument that Neo can control sentinels because he is in some way linked with Smith is this:
If you asume that Zion is the real world, and the link was made within the Matrix (first film) then logically the only effects of this could be that part of Smith's program was overwritten and so was part of Neo's mind.
But no more than his mind because that is all that is connected to the Matrix. Nothing could have happened to him physically. Notice how when people fell pain in the Matrix and the transfer it to their real bodies they never get more than a bleeding nose or jaw, things that are common and can be caused by stress, pressure and such. When someone gets shot, their real bodies don't gain any bullet holes. So if no physical transformation occured then nothing happened that would allow him to transmit messages in any form to machines. Similarly Smith who completely replaced Bane's mind as a human body would have no way to communicate with machines, but i assume he does since the attacking sentinels allow him to survive.
The only plausible explaination for this is that both Neo's and Smith's minds are still physically electronically connected to the Machines.
Jusu:
Nice attention to detail :D but Kelly hit the nail on the head. The Wachowski brothers did say in some interview that the 101 motive is based on Orwell's "1984", which is why it appears in so many ways which you pointed out.
Jeff and Melissa again:
I guess you missed some things i said in my posts
because i did discuss both the programers access corridor and the council = 23 theory.
Just so you don't have to look for it:
Morpheus says in his cavern speech that they have fought the machines for 100 years.
The Councelor tells Neo that he slept for the first 11 years of his life, which means he was 11 when they freed him from the Matrix, too young to be selected as on of 23 to build a city, and he doesn't look to be 111 years old.
The corridors are a different level of the Matrix, kind of like Matrix = program, corridor = operating system. It is clear that it is a different level because it survives each of the 6 Matrix restarts. Proof of this is that programs from older versions of the Matrix escaped here and survived the reboot.
This also leads me to believe that Zion could be on another level Matrix since we know that there are a least two levels (Matrix, and corridor).
Finaly, would Neo see code in the the Zion world? No. He spent most of his life in the Matrix without seeing code, and only when he awoke, was trained and then learned more by himself did he start seeing code. To see code in Zion he would have to 'learn' the news Zion code.
And just for the record i believe that Zion is the last level of the Matrix. Despite the fact that they could go on indefinitely, more than two would not tie in with the Gnostic view that seems to have influenced the film so much.
Okay, so, it's certain that there are a million and one different theories about the whole stopping setinals in midair. It could have been a coincidential fire from a ship that cuaght Neo in the crossfire. It could be a Matrix in a Matrix. It could be his powers now translate into the real world. But, I have one question for the world of Dungions and Dragons players and Trekies out there who really get upset over this kinda stuff: How do humans reproduce in the real world when they are plugged into those jelly-filled egg things? How do two people mate in the Matrix and have a real kid in the real world? Is pregnancy just a state of mind? Oh no, I think I just created a monster.
To Ryan:
Hum, well. As you said, it is only a state of mind. Why? Because as said in the 1st movie, humans are not born, but grown. Pregnancy is then just a "lie" told by the matrix, and the new kid that is just born is then another entity plugged into the matrix as soon as he comes to "life" inside the matrix.
But that's a point we shouldn't maybe put too much attention on, I guess there are many other questions like this one that could be formulated.
However, I wanted to argue about the my opinion that is that there is no "matrix-in-a-matrix" thing. Here's my point.
Well, we've argued about the fact how Neo could control the sentinels in the real world. I guess if we admit that a part of Smith was "copied" into Neo, then he could "easily" stop the sentinels. My explanation: I just re-saw the first movie, and Smith DOES really have a control on the sentinels in the real world since he can "order the strike", as the other agents seem to tell.
Another thinng that came to me was the fact that all the programs they are uploaded with DO remain in the real world. (someone told that that could not be possible, i believe it is) Why? Well it's really simple. In the 1st movie we hear clearly that all "newbies" get some kind of "operating programs" uploaded. These program designed to be able to us all the machines inside the ship. Well, we see Neo, just before he re-enters the matrix, load up his own chair and load some other stuff up. Whatever. So this has made me believe that they really can use all they have learned during the training. I believe that Neo could be a teriffic Kung-Fu fighter in the real world, BUT that of course he would not be able to fly or jump really high, since he cannot bend or break the physical rules of the real world.
I explain this because I believe Smith did in fact enter the mind of Bane, similarely to a uploaded software, as the Kung-Fu fighting program.
Thus, no "matrix-in-a-matrix" thing. Only my opinion. I'm far from pretending to have the right answer.
PS: I was probably wrong about the 101 thing. Or maybe it's another idea. But the Room 101 thing explained before is the most commonly accepted and logical answer to "why" this number.
I'm having a good time reading all of your theories; keep up the good work and please tell me if I'm in anyway "wrong" in what I said just before.
My apologies for the numerous spelling errors. I'm just tired and wrote quite fast w/out re-reading.
If Neo can fly at hundreds, if not thousands, of miles per hour as confirmed by his rescue of Trinity, then why does he always waste so much time sparring with agents and rogues in a mechanical/acrobatic style? After all, he could use sheer velocity of movement to utterly dismember or outright disintegrate his opponents? Answer: kung fu fighting is the theme of the day in modern action cinema so verisimilitude be damned.
about neo being able to stop the machines at the end of the movie: neo and agent smith had some sort of interaction at the end of the first matrix, when neo goes inside of him and kills him. smith even mentions that in reloaded. when this happened, part of agent smith was somehow added to neo, thereby putting neo in touch with the computer mainframe for which smith was working. this computer mainframe also controls the sentinels, which is why neo could sense them and was able to stop them.
Motormetalmaniac: I don't know if you're serious or not, but I think we're just meant to accept the fact that Neo can't kill Agents with the speed of light. If Neo WAS able to beat them at lightning speed, there would be 10 second fights, thus making the movie considerably boring to the majority. If the movie was consistent in every element, it wouldn't be as popular.
Kelly Perhaps so - perhaps not. If I have understood the trailers right Neo will have to terminate/kill Mr. Smith (all of them I suppose) in a somewhat short timeframe. We have seen him him Agent Smith once - and then he even resurrected him self, so Neo must find a much more efficient way of destroying Agent Smith.
That might be flying into him at the speed of light - but honestly I don't think so. It looks like Agent Smith will be able to do similar stuff in Revolutions (from the trailer).
Hmm, you could be right. I saw the trailer at the end of the movie but it didn't reveal much. If Neo does kill Smith in a matter of seconds I will be so disappointed. We'll have seen the whole trilogy by then, and to end the final battle with a 10 second fight would be fatal. I'm sure that a lot of people will be disappointed.
If we see Neo killiing agents at 'lightspeed' (light speed is 886,000 miles per second by the way) we wouldn't even be able to see him. It will end in 0.163 seconds (3 s.f)
Well - how do you cure a virus?
You can terminate it - but that seems not to work, because he don't "die" even when he know he should.
"You destroyed me, Mr. Anderson. Afterwards, I was aware of the rules. I knew what I was supposed to do, but I didn't. I was compelled to stay- compelled to disobey. And right now, here I stand because of you, Mr. Anderson. Because of you, I'm no longer an Agent of this system. Because of you, I'm unplugged. A new man, sort of speak- like you. Apparently free."
Another way of "curing" is to isolate it. It would be pretty cowardish, but he might actually just be held "prisoner" in a special room that he can't escape (probably such rooms will be located at the corridor).
Reasons to believe there is exactly one matrix:
* Hard to argue that you have found the last one. The audience will almost certainly think "wonder if they are living in just another matrix and not in the real world after all"
* In the Animatrix (2nd renaissance) it seems rather obvious that the sky did in fact get scortch by the humans - and that the machines did actually make the matrix. So it seems that the Matrix is the first one which is built. It does not exclude the possibility that others are built later, - but it probably do rule out the posibility for an infinite number of matrix's inside each other. It is possible that Zion is another Matrix, but then they did somehow build that matrix outside the real matrix and not inside it. That seems really strange.
Reasons to believe there is more than one matrix:
* It seems Neo has special abilities (stopping the sentinels in open air)
* Neo seems to be able to sense things in "the real world" - the bomb, the sentinels etc.
* How does the Oracle know what Neo is dreaming in "the real world"
Please help me stack up the arguments for and against multiple matrix's
As a side note I’m astounded at what the Wachowski Brothers have done. I've been thinking about the film a lot, and trying to understand it and reading all the comments on this bored and talking to friends about it. I mean this is a main-stream blockbuster movie that is doing this to me!
What Jeff and Melissa were saying is very true about the story being so intricate and finely-tuned. You can tell that they have put a lot of energy into making the story as surprising, un-predictable and thought provoking as possible.
And the script is so cleverly written especially the scene with the architect.
I respect anyone that can us the words affirmation contingent and predication in one sentence!!
Ok, could someone who believes that Zion is indeed in the real world please explain how they believe Neo is able to communicate with machines.
Please, nothing along the lines of "he is linked with Smith", i mean HOW. What is going on physically, chemically etc... in his body that would allow him to transmit signals to machines.
This first movie established to some extent that there are no paranormal happenings outside the Matrix, so until someone presents some explaination that i missed, i just can't accept this theory as valid.
Also DaDane: Thanks for quoting Smith, i never noticed before how he said: "... like you. APPARENTLY free".
Also i feel it is logical to assume that that if the Zion world is another Matrix then it would be based on a real real world, because there would be no point in creating a world that explained why you had been trapped in a Matrix when there was already such a good explanation at hand (assuming that the Matrix really is for generating power for the machines).
Yes it is truely an amazin universe
1) They have thought about the things. It a universe with is different and seems very consistent (have to see the last movie to judge, but it seems like that)
2) They have maneged to put in tons of references
3) They really seems to know something about all of the aspects. The things which has to do with computers are very nice and consistent with reality. I'm not an expert, but it seems to be the case for philosophy as well.
4) They have managed to tell a lot and still not reveal everything - they truely are good storytellers.
I guess that we all (here) agree that it's a movie in a different leauge than just about every other movie you see. (Not everybody thinks that - but those who don't probably don't spend a lot of time here).
I don't think there are nested matrices. Seems too easy and too obvious for this film. I came up with a bunch of theories that managed to work in this situation, but reading the synopsis of the third movie kind of makes it easy to draw a conclusion.
"Now displaying a greater confidence in his own power, Neo fully realizes that he is a superhuman figure capable of amazing feats, and totally aware that he's able to see the codes of people and things with which he comes into contact."
- "The Matrix: Revolutions" movie synopsis
If Neo is a superhuman, he can have powers outside of the matrix (although possibly not the same powers as inside the matrix.) This answers any question about stopping the sentinals. I'm looking forward to see the third movie in November.
I think that you have some pretty hard evidence lugo.
Let's in the following assume that Zion is the real world (i.e. not another Matrix).
There is no reasonably way that Neo can comunicate with Smith when not connected to the Matrix. Nor is there a reasonably way that he (by force) can stop those sentinels - even if he uses all his powers.
So what is happending?
The sentinels ran out of battery (by luck just there)
The sentinels like Neo to much and do what he asks
Well those explanations are by far worse than the matrix in the matrix, - so that's definately not helping us at all.
I guess there is just one possiblity left - that the ship actually did it - but even that seems far out.
I guess we can say we have reached a contradiction - so our assumption (Zion is the real world) is false. But I still don't like it!
random person: I guess we agree - the matrix in matrix theory is "ugly" - but Neo being a superhuman person in the real world - its even worse.
Unless of course they take the Mesias thing very seriously. But that wouldn't be the ending that we all long for either, would it?
What about the thing that Morpheus says when the Nebuchadnezzar was destroyed by the bomb, he said somethings like:
"I deamed a dream, now that dream is gone..."
That's what I remember he said, correct me if I'm wrong. The thing is: why Morpheus says this ??
To Jusu,
Okay, a brilliantly formulated answer. Yet, you fail to realize that I said I have one question, when in fact, I asked three. Anyway, back to my original point, you say humans are "grown", however, we are not plants. In the real world (as demonstrated in the uneccissary permiscious sex scene) mating is much like that of the Matrix. Therefore, there has to be a gamete joining to form a zygote somehow. Is all pregnancy artificial insemination in a machine-made womb? Is my rather frank talk making all the nerds out there nervious? (P.S. Look at the times you people posted these things! How early do you have to get up just to debate a movie? Do you have jobs? Girlfriends? Lives?)
Ryan, why are you on here? Dont you have any of your own things to do rather than just insulting people who like to be interlectually challenged and to discuss/hypothesise with other people? I suspect that it is you who is without a life; coming onto a forum simply to post pathetic and petty insults, shloudn't you have something better to do? Also you argue that posts are made at early/unsociable hours. Does that not suggest that they are doing other things in the daytime? I should also point out that not everyone is from the same country and that there are time zones!! You did know that, didn't you? Or is it that you are so dumb (is that PC? I should say interlectually challenged) that you simply over look all possible explanations and blurt out whatever it is you are thinking? How about you try something slightly challenging and attempt to answer something rather than just asking questions and unsuccessfully attempting to abuse other people. i might point out that although we have no certain answers, there is still one film to be released and therefore your oh-so deep and hurtful jibe about unanswered questions may yet to be proven to be totally irrelevent. So why dont you do us all a favour and (in my home town's terms) Do one!!!
I thank you.
I am a prick
Lugo (and other): I think that I have an idea for an ending which I can live with.
First the machines created the Matrix - but it didn't work out perfectly, because someone didn't accept it. They escaped the Matrix and made Zion in the real world. The maschines found out and they much more than likely have destroyed Zion. This might have happend more than once (depending on how smart the maschines was. The first time they saw people escaping and creating a new place they might just have eliminated them, the second time they probably though that they had to do something more permanent to the problem). At some time the maschines (The Oracle) found out that it was rather inefficient loosing all these "batteries" and also wasting energy of destroying them (because they might be a threat otherwise). So they made a second version of the Matrix which made people believe (perhaps even unconcious) that they had a choise. So most accepted the matrix as it was - and the remaining one percent rejected it for just another dreamworld - the Zion simulation. This all happens in THE SAME matrix (revision 2). They go NOWHERE - and they never gets unplugged.
But now Neo actually "awakes himself" from Zion. This might actually be the very first time that happens. We haven't heard of anyone just getting unconsious or even "die" for no apparent reason in Zion, which we probably would have if it was somewhat normal that people left Zion for the real world.
That makes it ONE matrix - but two different DREAM WORLDS. But no more than two!
Now we only need one thing. Mr. Smith! He certainly is strange - and it definitely seems like he it a threat to humanity. How come. Probably because he is killing minds. He takes over a lot of bodies - threatening to destroy humanity and perhaps even the machine's world as well (he might destroy the Matrix - and thereby their powersupply). So it is of the uttermost importance that Neo stops him - and probably the maschines will even help him. But let's see about that in "revolutions".
Please comment!
Okay, calm down there skippy. I too am a big fan of the Matrix. I am very interested in the things you talk about, but sometimes it gets rather repetitive. What's the crimes in trying to spice things up? In case you didn't notice, I am a satirical writer, however, not once did I ever aim an attack at a specific person. Although, some people do. Now who could that be? Most people would just laugh at the things I say becuase they are meant to be funny, and nothing more. But, I figure they won't becuase they are going to be too busy laughing at how horribly upset you got about it. I'm sure everyone one else will agree with me when I say, "LIGHTEN UP DUDE!" By getting upset, you are only proving my theory, that I never meant to be proven anyway. (Oh yeah, and I'm a blackbelt in Tae-Kwon-Do, so I can go Korean on your ass!)
~I have a dreamed a dream~
Nebuchadnezzar's Dream
Daniel 2:3 And the king said unto them, I have dreamed a dream, and my spirit was troubled to know [what] the dream [means].
Many great comments here. But for those who are more interesting in the religious references, I found the following site to be a great read. It very clearly explains many of the references in the movie. Enjoy!
http://www.corporatemofo.com/stories/051803matrix.htm
Paul: yea, maybe not the best way to do it, but there is a lot more to the overall story than Neo. I have a feeling the third movie (after defining Neo better) will be more based on other stories (viz. Zion.)
A couple of theories I was playing around with, which after reading the synopsis for part III I really doubt would happen... would be things like:
Neo did not stop the sentinals. Although Neo put his hand up a-la-bulletstopping, and the sentinals fell, doesn't necessarily mean he stopped them. The other ship (the Hammer I believe) was nearby before they appeared to us. The Hammer could have used an EMP, stopping the sentinals at luckily the same time. They did if you notice die the same way, with the same lights as when they were hit by an EMP.
...now a lot of people would be quick to say, "BUT HE FELT IT!!" or "BUT HE COLLAPSED AT THE END!!" ...well, this too can be explained.
We saw how the EMP affected Bane (the guy Smith infected that is on the "real world" side; guy laying down next to Neo at the end).. he's in a coma. Well, the same thing could have happened to Neo as well. In Matrix 1 when Neo jumped into Agent Smith, as Smith says "I don't know, maybe something was overwritten" but obviously some code got mixed. This explains why the sentinals went down, Neo went down, Bane went down, and why Neo felt the electromagnetic pulse coming.
Sure, why not.
I believe there are two Matrix's. Matrix A, and Matrix B, as DaDane said....
The Matrix could possibly be based on Baudrillard's theories. For example, Neo picks up his book entitled "Simulacra and Simulation" in the first movie, so there is a direct reference to the text there.
A Simulacrum is a copy of a copy. Essentially the Matrix is a simulacrum, meaning the Matrix is a copy of the real world (also a copy). So there in fact is the most logical explanation of why there could be two Matrix's.
'lugo: There is a problem with your theory about there not being any super natural things going on in the real world. Think about the frist movie, neo died, plain and simple. His heart was stopped, he was flatline for about 60 seconds. Then when trinity kissed him (not cpr or any other lifesaving methods) his heart started again. This sounds pretty super natural to me. Now I know you are thinking he willed himself to not die in the matrix, but for those sixty seconds he was dead in both the real world and the matrix, so riddle me this: how can you mind be willing you not to die when you are dead? Even though neo is the one, that fact (in your theory) is supposed to only have effects in the matrix, not the real world where no supernatural events take place. He was dead in both places and then he came back to life in both, supernatural in both.
Like i said before, the fact that he was dead in both worlds for quite some time and the he wills himself to life poses the question where was his mind if it was still thinking? This, in my opinion is just another reason to believe his body was alive somewhere else, ie. a real world outside the Zion Matrix.
The second film went to quite some length to show that supernatural things are a part of the Matrix especially with the vampires and wraiths element, so if the story suddenly says that supernatural things occur in the real world too would be pretty poorly thought out to say the least.
Neo is a program implemented into a human body...he was born, he was raised, he went to HS, to college, lost his virginity, all the time feeling as if he were living a dream. He is human with the matrix's programming coursing through his cyborg brain. When he is freed his preprogramming takes full effect allowing him to do those uncanny feats in the Matrix. After the ordeal he goes through in "Reloaded" and the helluva conversation with the Architect his mind is in disarray and now with his decision to chose the door to save Trinity he has thusly set forth events that have never been set forth by his 5 predecessors...if what the Architect said was true then what happens now is a series of events never before experienced by both the humans and the programmed entities. And about Neo stopping the Sentinels...being that he seems to have shorted them out and not miraculously stop them in midair I do not believe he is in some aptly named "Matrix B". He is just becoming more aware of his programming and can now sense it in Matrix based entities outside the Matrix itself (the sentinels). Thats what I believe...ALSO judging from the third movies teaser, I believe it will be known by all that Neo is indeed a program. That is why when he is shown fighting Agent Smith [who must've upgraded himself because it seems there is no burly brawl 2, just a one on one DBZ type urban brawl] Morpheus says shocked, "He fights for us." as if such a feat were now strange...I mean Neo always fought for "us" why so amazing now...and also I really hope there is no Matrix B cause even the the idea is interesting...its not really fulfilling. I mean after all this to find out hes immersed in some green liquid filled Egg in the Real Real world. The Matrix was the Birth, Reloaded the Life, and Revolutions is the Death...(not an original idea) What we need answered though is: These movies represent the lifecycle for what?
Speculate Please :-D
and DADANE was the ONLY other person I saw who noticed the oddity of "He fights for us" I was beginning to worry about people :-D
I think that lugo has "proven" very well that Zion can not be the real world.
There can be no supernatural things in the real world (sensing, controling Sentinels etc).
I can see that a lot of you think otherwise - can't you please tell why?
1) What's wrong with lugo's prove
og
2) What's more importent (i.e. you can't prove lugo wrong, but you have another prove for something else - something that isn't compatible with lugo's idea).
In the "Architect scene" when he is talking about the human beings (not so perfect human beings), in the screens you can see George Bush, Ariel Sharon, Adolf Hitler and Benito Mussolini. I think it`s a clear statement against for example USA`s Mid-East policies. I think it`s quite strange (and of course positive) that in a mass production movie you can find things like this. Comments are accepted..
TruthBeTold:
How about this
There's a billon Mr. Smiths surrounding the "good guys" who really think that everything is lost.¨
Neo is captured by Mirovingian and there's just no hope.
But, surprise surprise, Neo actually shows up. - Niobe sees him first and says "Neo" (it's on the trailer) - and shortly after Morpheus sees him to (thinking that everything might not be lost after all) saying "He fights for us".
TruthBeTold:
I don't think there is any way Neo is a program. I took this into consideration in forming some theories, but after thinking about it awhile, and going back to watch the movie to look for other things, I noticed that they made an effort to link "Neo" and "human" about 50 times.
Examples:
The Architect explains Neo is an anomoly, but says without a doubt he is human. "You have many questions and although the process has altered your consciousness you remain irrevocably human, ergo some of my answers you will understand and some of them you will not."
The agents at the beginning of the movie (before the "anomoly" business is explained) encounter Neo and say, "it's the anomoly... do we proceed? ...yes, he is still only human."
Examples such as these provide a strong case to proving Neo's humanity.
Some interesting theories going on. I actually have far more issue with Neo being a machine that the matrix-within-a-matrix idea. I can't really explain my problem with Neo being a machine.. it would just be... well rubbish. The architect tells Neo he is the "eventuality of an anomaly". I think the anomaly actually means the 1% who reject the matrix. The eventuality is that one person in this anomaly will eventually become entirely adept at manipulating the matrix world. If Neo was merely a machine the Architect could surely have just got rid of him, rather than being "unable to eliminate".
As for the matrix-within-a-matrix idea, I'm fine with it. I do think that the two different worlds (the 1999 and 2199 ones) are just on different branches of the machine mainframe (which was shown as the white corridors.) The 2199 world being just another matrix would explain why they only thought it was around this date rather than 600 (6 x 100 years for each anomaly) years in the future. A new 2199 world is created from the "source". Also, lugo raised a very good point when he said what was actually happening when Neo stopped the sentinals if 2199 was the real world. Smith can indeed issue a strike as he is in the Matrix in the first movie. However, Neo isnt connected to any matrix so how could he get a message to the machines?
As for the thing about Neo finding out which "level" was the real real world Neo could just continue to try his powers until they no longer worked. (He never used them in 2199 because he never considered the possibility.)
P.S. The birth thing is no problem to work out. When two people conceive in the matrix the machines symply remove the sperm and egg cells from the individuals comatosed bodies in the power plant and allow an embryo to develop in a new pod. Then they just feed the electrical signals into the foetus brain (once it has a nervous system) to tell it that it is in its mothers womb, until it is born and continues with its life like everyone else in the matrix.
The Architect knew that Neo was going to take the door on the left. It wasn't different to the other five times, and did not 'suprise' the Architect. Just before, he talks about reading the emotions going through Neo, over-riding common sense and logic. He knows that The One will live up to that love. (Anomaly?) The fact that the 'oracle' foresees the love between Neo and Trinity shows that it is not a new thing in this iteration of the Matrix, but has happened the same way every time. (Like the other things she predicts).
The problem this time around, I guess, is the virus Smith, which has aquired a pseudo-will from the way that Neo penetrated him at the end of M1.
Maybe it was at that point that he got pushed, (dumped?) into the programmer's corridor, and learned the ways of the rogue programs. His 'purpose' now seems to be to infect the whole Matrix, effectively killing the human minds. Thus he becomes a threat to both man and machine, who may need to work together to destroy him.
P.S. Persephone can kiss me anytime!
I believe that most of you need to learn how to spell correctly. It is unfortunate that the majority of you speak as if you got your english degree at K-Mart, at least learn how to spell correctly. Yo, no what m sayin yo yo dog? Yo....
Stay in School. Fools.
hello ,
my name is noor ahmad and i belong from karachi , pakistan i just got a one question but first you have to make me so much clear about the film "THE MATRIX RELOADED". my question is that "is this possible in the real world which i have seen in the film" because as far far as my search i think that this possible but i am not sure that this is possible because i really intersted in this field" please give me the comments as soon as possible
best regards/noor ahamd
To the anonymous guy - not all of us are american. I myself is danish, so english (american) are not my native tounge. I believe that you can read what I writes.
I don't see the point in studying english just to be allowed to use the internet.
You are the moron who should stay in school. Not me!
ok, anonymous, now your turn to say something in danish :D
If anything, this movie, its predecessor and its follow up should teach us all one basic point of thruth and that is "Whatever the thinker thinks, the Prover proves". As long as you keep this in mind whilst speculating the conversations will be much more enjoyable and much more informative.
Anonymous seems to confuse the internet with a thesis paper...Are you going to give us all F's?
Stupid ass
Noor,
Matrix is a science fiction movie, so, it should answer your question.
However, Virtual reality, as in the Matrix quality, is still a long time off. You would need a computer that would be capable of processing thousands of trillions and trillions of instructions per second. Those types of computers are still many, many years away, but I do believe that those types of computer will be around maybe within the next 100 - 200 years due to the advancement of nanotechnology.
With nano technology, scientists are predicting that they can fit the most powerful and fastest computers we currently have on to the head of a pin. But you want to do further research, look into nano technology.
Noor:
Here is a link to IBM and one of the projects they are working on regarding nanotechnology
http://www.research.ibm.com/resources/news/20010425_Carbon_Nanotubes.shtml
Neo is human...he is supposed to be human...thats how the machines designed him...just like Agent Smith is now human...his consciousness is just programmed. Thats what I mean by Neo is a program...and "He Fights for Us" is still a very skeptical saying...
I've read everyone of your comments on the movie and it's been very interesting indeed to read your thoughts and thesis, since many of them are fucking brilliant. Just love the depth of this movie, metaphysics in a movie ;) The Wachowski brothers are incredible, image people having big forums about an actionmovie. Got to give some creds to lugo and kallisto for excellent arguments, especially that one about "self awakening" that seems to be the case with neo in the end, and the whole thing about Kid, that he "senses" Neo everytime they arrive at Zion.
P.S The references to the origin of the names they have are really facinating, though its sad that they didnt show the one about neo in the movie.
rearrange N E O -> O N E . Morpheus = Dreamgod, that's his role and he's talking about a dream when the nebucadnezzar is blown up.
/Sajj
Btw , stop saying that The Oracle , the agents , Mr.smith and so on are MASHINES? For fucks sake they're software (or now smith has become som sort of virus , but in some extendt neo is a virus also?). Stop saying wrong even if its said in context...
/me = tired. Sorry for all the misspelling but it's getting late over here ;P
/me = tired. Sorry for all the misspelling but it's getting late over here ;P
First off, my extension of gratitude to all those that put their time into interpreting the movie. There are many logical explanations given, and in reading the posts, I have a much clearer understanding of at least what the W Bros may have been aiming for with their piece.
But, to address Noor's question, which was dismissed by Dan's answer regarding the lack of such computer development in today's world.
The foundations of the movie are cleary based upon many philisophical/religious arguments that have existed in our human history. When the behaviorist BF Skinner said in the 50's, "Free will is an illusion," he wasn't referring to science fiction, but to scientific facts discovered in experimentation, particularly the phenomenon of stimulus-response reactions.
The W Bros have a skill for story telling to be sure. Their framing of these philosophical topics accurately apply metaphysics to the modern day world in which we exist. What they do with the movie is extend the proposition of free will being an illusion to a fictional reality. While I doubt that the Bros would suggest that Neo is a real person, that electronic sentinals actually control our actions, etc., I'm sure they would be comfortable in the belief that in our real 2003 world, we exist without any free will, or that at the very least the possibility of us not possessing free will is a good likelihood.
Dan's dismissal of this possibility seems to line up with many of the posts here, which limit themselves to the reality that the movie creates, rather than the reality that the movie reflects. Is there a God or an Architect? Are our every actions premeditated towards a final destination? I can only answer... quite possibly. Perhaps there is a similar Matrix in which we live, and perhaps it is as contrived as the science fiction that the Bros have created. Who's to say that the world's history hasn't actually advanced to the year 2199, and we exist today as a source of energy for those existing in the future? While clearly we don't possess the technology to do so today, who's to say that it hasn't been developed in some future of ours? This scheme reminds me of the great time machine paradox: if a time machine were ever to be created, would we not know about it by the time the travellers arive back in our time? And in lieu of any evidence of such travelers, does that necesarily mean that such a machine will never or doesn't exist? Again, we can't reach any level of certitude about this, but to respond to Noor: sure, it's a possibility that such a Matrix exists, and I would believe that the Bros, if pressed, would admit to believing in such an alternate existence, even in the world of 2003. Unfortunately, no amount of posting or discussion on the subject will allow us to arrive at a definite answer: just as all the philosophers/historians/scientists etc. couldn't solve it when they dealt with the same issues. Until some sort of End comes, or until some Zion presents itself to those existing in our 2003 real word, we can only look towards artists such as the W Bros to explore the infinite possibilities of our potentially purposeful existence.
pppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppp
I saw the movie for the second time today. About the ending, there is the blue electricity sparks around the sentinels when they stop in front of Neo like the EMP. However this could be what happens to sentinals when they are broken by anything. However some people suggested it was the same EMP that put Neo in a coma. I noticed that Neo only collapsed AFTER the sentinals, not at the same time. Seems more like he was worn out by the effort.
I've got another question for the forum. In the architect's room what are the images of Neo on the screen? Some suggest that they show the responses of the previous five. However after the Architect says "this is the sixth version" when *our* Neo is saying "either no-one told me.." another one is saying "there have been five before me?". This couldn't have been said by one of the previous five as none of them have had five before them. Perhaps they are showing the possible choices Neo thinks of saying to each remark. Links in with the whole choice (red pill/blue pill, left door/right door) thing.
Pat,
I think you should look into the work of Descartes who wrote much work on what is truly reality. He tried to suggest that perhaps the only true certainties are the laws of pure mathematics but as room 101 suggests you can make someone think that 2 + 2 = 5.
He eventually settled on the only truth we are certain of. Because we can think, and consider such topics, we know that we exist, although not in what form. Hence the world famous Cartesian Principle: I think, therefore I am.
I do not think any of the original 23 are alive within Zion now...I mean there are 250,000 people in Zion, even with the extractions it would take a lot more than enough years to turn a head of hair fully grey to fully populate Zion up to 250,000 Centuries probably passed since the choice was given to the 5th one and the original 23 are probably dead and buried and probably were fed a false memory of how they escaped the Matrix. And I read somewhere about the Counselor being a previous 'One'...Lets be real now...that is a stupid idea...I do not doubt the idea that the Counselor does indeed know more than he tells but as far as him being a previous 'One' it just doesnt tie in chronologically and logically. And all the ideas about the Matrix within a Matrix make sense, I mean the Architect kind of suggest it by stating that the humans needed a choice...perhaps a choice between the real-world matrix(Zion) and the fake worl Matrix (The Matrix) but I just hope this isn't the case because A. its too easy to think of, and B. Its not really fulfilling. I'd be happier if Neo donned a Red S than if there is indeed a Matrix within a Matrix. And I still believe Neo is a Program inserted into a human mind, and (to go off on a tangent) Agent Smith had no idea that answering the phone would send him into Bane's body, that was a coincidence, back to Neo being a programmed entity (Which is what the sentient programs should be called, the sentinels are machines, the Agents, Oracle, Architect, Merovingian, Persephone, are all Programmed Entities) The Architect says that the source code has to be reimplemented for the cycle to continue again so no matter what, if he is a complete program or an incomplete program (whereas the code is only part of his persona not the entire thing[which is what i believe]) the part of him which made him have such control over the Matrix has to be a code, otherwise why would they need it back?
I kinda lost focus at the end of what I just typed because I'm watching "Enough" on HBO...so if it gets a lil sketchy let me know...but can I please have more speculation on the "He Fights for us" by Morpheus in the Matrix Revolutions Teaser. Because that is a rather speculatory happening...do you agree?
A tidbit:
Persephone is the wife of Hades in Greek mythology. The beautifuk daughter of Demeter and Zeus, she was abducted and then fell in love with Hades, king of the underworld.
Think of how food is used to integrate programs within the matrix. The cake given to the blonde was 'written' by the Merovingian, ie a subroutine of some sort.
It's been a while since I saw M1, but I remember the oracle offering Neo a cookie, and saying something like, "when you're finished eating it you'll be as right as rain..." Surely this could be some code that the oracle wrote?
And then, in M2, she offers him some candy. We don't see Neo eating it, maybe it comes in later?
Dadane and 'lugo:
Ok, I do agree that neo does not have real powers in real life but i like to look at evidence for both cases. Think about this, Neo was dead and came back to life, regardless whatlevel of the matrix (if there are different levels) he is on, he was dead in the matrix which means he was dead in the real "real world" no matter how many levels of matrix that is through. This is able to be established because no one else has been able to will them selves to life after death, and i do not believe neo did either. I am not sure of how he did it, but somehow his body must have reset or something. We also know he was dead because the oracle said he would die and he did. Point is that the posablity of supernatural powers cannot be ruled out, even if we don't like it. We can not allow Noseeum inferences to overpower logical thinking
Pat and Macca:
It is nice to see other people are starting to pay more attention to the Philosophy aspects of the movie. If Morpheus and the Merovingian's talk, then read Peter van Inwagen on determinism and indeterminism, as well as the No Choice Principle.
Chuck: The think is that the Animatrix episode (Kid's Story) establishes that it is possible to die in the Matrix while your mind survives out of it. And the fact that we have that same kid running around Zion in reloaded suggests to me that he has yet some part to play in this.
My views on "He fights for us": I didn't really see anything special here. To me that quote sounded much like "What is he doing?" "He's starting to believe" from the first movie. The tone of voice was definitely the same, so i dismissed those words as just his way of speaking.
did cypher killed in the first one or is that him lying in a bed next to Neo at the end of Matrix: reloaded?
To Benedict Branca...do you pay attention to the movies??
I stumbled upon this site and the comments made here are great. The multiple-matrix theory actually answered a basic question I had from the first movie.
In the first Matrix the premise was established that if you died in the matrix then you died in the real world. A premise that does not make sense at all. After all, how could events in a virtual world have physical manifestations in the real world? They can't unless the real world is also virtual. Which leads to the next question. If you don't die in the real world, do you wake up or move on to another virual world or come back as someone else, i.e. a form of reincarnation?
It also doesn't make sense that the machines would let their source of energy die just because of car accidents, murders, diseases or wars. I can't buy Morpheus's flipant explanation that "the body can't live without the mind."
How could the mind leave the body?
In the Matrix we cleary saw two matrices in operation. One that is controlled by the machines and the other aboard the Nebucanezer for training.
In the Matrix Reloaded we again clearly saw two operating matrices. One that is controlled by the machines and the other in Zion. When the Nebucanezer came to dock, the gates and weapons were controlled by people jacked into the Zion mainframe and the matrix that it created.
Seems to me that if matrices can exist in parallel then they can also exist embedded within each other.
On a slightly different tack, I would like to point out that all those individuals with implants that can jack into a computer are technically cyborgs. It wouldn't be unreasonable that some implants are more up-to-date than others.
It also wouldn't unreasonable to assume that some implants have features that other implants don't.
I read all posts, watched Reloaded at only one time...But in the movie there is some clue which is easily noticable...I think The Oracle and The Architect have an argument about an something secret...We saw what The Oracle said always happened exactly...but For Architect all things are different...He talks like the leader of machines...I think Matrix wasn't destroyed(we will see in the next sequel) and also real world which is supposed Zion is real world to only the some level consciousness...WB tries all ways sometimes exaggeratly for pointing out this to audience (for example rave scene)
So I think the end of the movie, We will see that Neo will have an ability the control of the all system(So he is going to know The ONE undoubtely at that time)...And he will give all Matrix inhabitants to chance for realizing the real real world which is neither Matrix nor Zion(somewhere in there isn't any need for machines...Maybe Neo will make this place to prove that we don't really need machines to survive...)
...At that point ofcourse he should sacrifice living as a slave normal human...He will wake up in front of his computer just like as if nothing happend...And then door is knocked(Only this conclusion make this movie really unforgottable)...Bam...All green numbers and letters come...
I always took Morpheus' saying that the mind makes it real to mean psychosomatic effects.
http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=psychosomatic&r=3
Benedict Branca: thats Bane, the one who agent smith infected and then when out through the telephone.
And now just to be fair i finaly came up with an argument for how neo could control machines with his mind outside the matrix that doesn't invole the Matrix in Matrix idea. Thing is i just remembered that he has a great big peace of electronics stuck to the back of his head and into his brain. It could be possible that it has some internal mechanism that allows it to transmit signals, although that's unlikely seeing as the sentinals often have trouble locating rebel ships.
But still, just wanted to show that i take all arguments into account ;)
Pat,
I wasn't totally dismissing the world thats painted in the Matrix movie isn't possible right now, but rather; relative to our own reality to create a matrix is impossible right now. Even to try and create a Matrix by normal humans living in the "real world" in the matrix would be impossible for them relative to their "reality" in their current time.
Yes, I agree with you to a point that its possible that our reality may well be a "reality" within a "matrix" type world, and we all exist within in some super advanced "computer", but thats more of a philosophical debate, which I don't know much about. From my background in computers, I took what what Noor asked from a technical point of view.
Hi, I apologizes for my spelling, I’m from Mexico.
I just want to comment about Neo stopping the sentinels. He can feel them because to this code (software) that he is carrying in his brain. Is like some kind of wireless communication or something like that, I guess. The thing that is different when he say “Something is different, I can feel them” may be is that it was the first time he was at the surface of the “real world”. He always had been in the Matrix or in the ship or in Zion and now that he is standing in the real world may be this “communication” has become stronger and he can feel the sentinels and even stop them.
This “communication” has been present along all this part (reloaded), because Neo could perceive when Smith arrived to the real world, (he wake up suddenly). The “dreams” about Trinity falling weren’t dreams, they were pemonitions, so they were some kind of transmission may be from the oracle (in some previous enter of Neo to the Matrix) because she knows about these future facts. There are some others examples like the boy of the spoon, or that Neo already knows that the sentinels will send a bomb, etc.
Thanks. All your comments are very interesting. This forum is great.
Proofing the loop ending of matrix trilogy...
While I were watching The Matrix Revolutions teaser with slow motion...I realized that straightforward to the end of the teaser there is a train (named LOOP) coming through to screen...I don't think this is coincidence...;)
Whew, I?ve actually read every post here, so I can avoid repetition in my comments.
I?ve just seen ?Reloaded? for the second time, and my belief that Neo is part machine has been strengthened. I would also like to say the movie plays ?much? better the second time. The first time, I put it my theory somewhat crudely by calling Neo a cyborg. In fact, I believe he is a human with a machine consciousness. I think he was ?grown? by the machines and implanted with a machine consciousness. The precedent for this is shown when Agent Smith?s machine consciousness is implanted into Bane in the real world. The Wachoskis want to tell a great story, not just a logical one, so the matrix within a matrix story is logical, but not consistent with the metaphysical, philosophical leaps the Wachowskis like to take. Matrix within a matrix simply doesn't take much imagination on their part, so I'm going to give them more credit than that (geez, I think they've earned it). It would be very consistent for them to suggest that man and machine can share consciousness, morality, and (albeit corny) love. Also, based on the plot of Animatrix?s ?Renaissance?, it would be consistent for them to suggest that consciousness and emotions transcend flesh.
Examples:
-Persephone "craves" a kiss from Neo.
-Smith (in Matrix 1) says he "hates" it in the matrix.
-too many other examples of "machine emotions" to list
Beyond that, there are SO MANY many hints listed on this page by others, but one I haven?t heard was the one that jumped out at me upon second viewing. When Neo and the Council elder talk privately on Zion?s engineering level, the elder makes a very important analogy. He says that he doesn?t know how Zion's water purification system works, just that it?s a machine and it works to serve its purpose to keep the people of Zion alive. RIGHT AFTER THAT STATEMENT he says (paraphrasing), ?Neo, I don?t know what makes you tick, or how you do the things you do, but you serve an important purpose too.? For me, this was like a sledgehammer hint saying Neo is indeed part machine in some way.
Another hint is embedded in Animatrix?s ?Renaissance? written by the Wachowskis. The machine city is called ?O1?. This is important in that geographically (you can check this, it?s true), the machine city is located in what was the city of Babylon, which now (ironically) happens to be Iraq. Bible references (which the directors rely heavily on) depict the enlightened leaving Babylon (the matrix) for the righteous city of Zion (zion). So we have a religious allegory in play that links Bablyon (the matrix) with the numbers 0 and 1. I think Smith represents "0". 0 is infinite/nothing, Smith is infinitely duplicated, and in a way, nothing--he even admits to Neo at the beginning of Burly Brawl that he no longer has a purpose (a surprisingly human-like confession that few have noted). Neo represents ?1?. Neo is called ?the one? about a billion times by man and machine (the Oracle most notably), I think this name has more significance than simply a nickname designation. It suggests programming symmetry. It suggests that Neo and Smith are somehow brothers. Smith specifically says that he and Neo are linked, perhaps he knows they are brothers, and thus wants to kill his goody goody, golden boy brother. I believe they are somehow the same, somehow BOTH machine/man hybrids. Binary twins. 01.
sorry, most of those question marks "?" actually represent quotation marks ""
I won't say how I feel about the movie in general, since I think I'll hurt some Matrix Reloaded fans. But if we are talking about how Smith entered the "real" world by modifying Bane's code... Can't be Neo's code somehow rewritten by the intrussion of Smith??? That would explain the fact that he felt the sentinels (they are A.I. like Smith) and stoped them.
Another thing... Does anyone know why the Agent fighting Morpheus on the truck bleeds???
I have been really thinking about this and every time I see the Matrix it really seems that it could be true...
Okay, know how Neo is at his computer sleeping in the first Matrix. On it computer it seems he was looking at pictures and news articles about Morpheus. From this we know that Neo is very interested in Morpheus. From there when Neo wakes up and his computer seems to be running itself and says "the matrix has you" and all that. He ends up going to the party and where he first meets Trinity and learns she was the one on his computer, and tells him about Morpheus and how she knows he's been looking for an answer. The next day he wakes up late and goes to work. Neo's boss gives him a lecture, Neo seems to be not listening and looks like he doesn't care. I noticed how Neo's boss resembles the agents a lot and even calls him Mr. Anderson just like Smith.
This is where i'll get to my point. The whole Matrix movie seems to all be centered on Neo, and how he is the one. As Neo was living in the "matrix" from his attitude, all Neo is, is a man who is not satisfied by the world, and wants to live in another world not based on laws or rules. Neo hates who he is and he is also like Smith who hates reality and can't stand living in it. Neo is just another guy, dreaming that he was something different, wishing that he was the one with all the power. Just think about it how Neo's whole life was about computers, software, and especially hacking. All the Matrix is, is a program that can be hacked and altered, just like Neo would hack into his company and sell whatever information was on those mini-discs. Neo's boss represents the agents who are trying to control the human race. The agents also symbolize the world as it is, having laws, and restrictions. Think about it. "Revolutions" ends with maybe a final conclusion, or maybe ends with confusion by Neo discovering there is a infinite amount of matrices. All of the sudden the screen blacks out and shows Neo waking up in front of his computer, before he was even contacted by Trinity with the news articles on Morpheus on his computer screen and all. He realizes that everything was made up, a manifestation of his own mind. A make-believe dream that Neo only wishes was true. It shows Neo close-up and he says, "shit". Neo can't take that it was all a dream, because he can't stand living in the world as it is. The next scene it shows Neo hanging himself, and then the end... The whole dream theory is also suggested by what Morpheus says to Neo in the first Matrix, "You have the look of a man who accepts what he sees, because he is expecting to wake up." When Morpheus asks Neo if he believes in fate he responds, "No, I don't because I don't like the idea that I'm not in CONTROL of my life." This tells how Neo hates not being in control and his own mind makes up the whole thing in his mind.
This probably will not be what happens, but if it was just think of how the people would react to when Neo wakes up. They would be like, "Oh, my God!" They would be speechless after this. This ending is also kind of like the one Twighlight Zone where the guy is about to get hanged but the rope breaks and he runs away, while he's being shot at. He gets away and finds his old home. He sees his wife and his kids and starts to run towards them. Right as he is about to hug them, the man gets hanged just like he was going to before. It was all made up.... That one was one of the best ones.
Just watch the first matrix, keeping in mind that its just a dream, you'll be suprised how things come together.
I think that there is one thing that few of us are considering and thats the Wachowski Brothers' intent. As most of you know (and if you didnt you wouldnt be on this site wasting your time trying to make sense of the movie)the Matrix is more than high-action sci-flick with a philosophical twist. It's a collection of different elements and mediums ingrained in pop culture. It borrows its visual style and storytelling from japanese animation (ghost in the shell and akira to name a couple)and its fight scenes from hong kong cinema. The plot has strong roots in early cyberpunk novels by authors like Isaac Asimov and has a deeply ingrained theme of metaphysical philosophy which challenges the foundations of reality. All mixed together with religious parallels, be they buddist, christian, muslim, or hindu,and a dab of pop culture.
It's a story about humanity in all its unique splendor and unavoidable horror. It begs the age old question of as to whether or not we are truly free. And it does so by taking different means of storytelling throughout human history (from religious doctrine, to philosophical writing, to comic books)and combining them into film. After all if it didnt, then there would be so much room for interpretation of its plot and meaning.
Now as for whether i think there is a second matrix, i'd have to say no. It would lead to a convoluted plot, and besides the machines are too confident in the perfection of their calculations to think that humanity and even Neo would stand a chance. The do not understand the concept of choice and will never be able to cope with free will. To them there are only two alternatives: 1)The one carries out his intended function and the matrix is reloaded for the seventh time or 2)The One chooses imminent doom and condemns humanity to extinction at the machines hands...either way, in their binary mindset, they win. However they underestimate the power of the human spirit. Anyway, it would lead to a confused and convoluted plotline to make any indications of a second matrix and it would take away from the ultimate importance of Zion and Humanities last stand.
Some comments from Panama City, Panama...
I agree with the most recent postings about Neo being part human, part machine... in fact, all the ones that have been taken out of their "cocoons" into the real world were hooked on cables mentally and physically... the plot from the first movie does not suggest in any way the matrix within a matrix idea... but... but there is something now "troubling my mind"...
How did Cypher got into the Matrix to speak with Agent Smith without being noticed? he had dinner with Agent Smith, remember? when he was planning the betrayal... so who sent him in? Did he hooked himself up? How did he get back out? Who found him an exit? Interesting point for me.... any thoughts?
Cypher probably did his dirty work by arranging his contacts with the Agents first (remember when Neo scared the "bejesus" out of him? Cypher then looked around to see anyone else and flicked off 6 monitors, stuff he didnt want others to see) The Matrix loaded him up and provided him with aan exit. The only problem was that hed have to put that electrode in the back of his head but I'm sure this could be done with practise. Just because everyone else is helped by someone else (probably to avoid the disorientation it causes) doesnt mean they have to be.
It's wild, I have just watched the entire "Animatrix" DVD and now I have one more tidbit that suggests the man/machine hybrid theory is true.
In Reloaded, we are introduced to a kid who is like Neo's mascot in Zion. Trinity asks Neo, "How does he (the kid) always know when you're here?" First hint. The original back story of this kid is told in the Animatrix short "Kid's Story". When the kid is first awakened to the real world (just after dying in the matrix, eh hem, like Neo), Trinity says, "I never thought self actualization was possible". Meaning, she's never seen anyone be able to wake themselves up without assistance and after death, which "is" what the kid does. This is rare behaviour similar only to that of Neo. But Trinity is wrong, she "has" seen this before. It's just that her belief in "the magic of love" blinds her to the facts before her. In the first Matrix, when Neo awakens in the real world after dying at the hands of Agent Smith, it is not Trinity's kiss that revives him (which would be magic), but in fact it is Neo himself who wills himself to awaken due to his belief/machine consciousness force of will (like the Kid in "Kid's Story"). The Kid and Neo are the only two known cases of a person being able to wake themselves up from the matrix after being killed. The Kid is special...like Neo.
I believe the kid is also a prototype man/machine consiousness hybrid. What else supports this? Well, we see that Neo can tell whenever a machine consciousness has entered the real world from the matrix. Example: Neo knows when Bane re-enters the real world with a machine consciousness (Smith's). Example: Neo can "feel" when the sentinels are coming towards the end of Reloaded. Similarly, the kid knows whenever Neo is around because they are both machine/man hybrids. Plot wise, most assume that the kid is just a cute kid hanging around Zion always waiting for Neo. I disagree. Reloaded gives him too much screen time for him to just be scenery. I think the Kid will play a pivotal role in the final film. I think the Kid will sense that Bane is a hybrid (man/machine consciousness) with evil intent and somehow help to stop him from killing Neo in Revolutions.
Also, someone asked, "why did the agent during the freeway chase BLEED when Morpheus cut him?" Good question. We've never seen this before. I think this is another foreshadowing clue. This scene led me to think about the fight Neo has with Merovingian's henchmen. At one point, he stops an axe with his hand and then a drop of blood comes out. Then Merovingian, on cue, misdirects the audience and says, "see, he's only human." I don't believe Merovingian. I think if Morpheus or Trinity had received the same axe blow, they'd be missing a hand. What human stops an axe with his hand and only bleeds a couple of drops of blood? I suspect that the agent on the freeway bleeding from Morpheus' sword cut, and then Neo bleeding from the axe blow is yet another hint hint linking Neo to the machines.
Finally, at the end of Reloaded, when it appears that Neo stops the sentinals, there are a couple of possible explanations. One: It wasn't Neo. His hands reaching out were him trying to communicate with the machines. But just then, another ship sent an EMP blast, which would explain why it disabled the sentinels and Neo as well (i.e. put him into a coma). We see another Zion ship pass over the scene shortly after Neo collapses. The only leap you have to make to believe this is to believe that the Zion ship that sent the blast was able to start its engines back up fast enough (they put the engines to sleep when sending an EMP blast) to fly over Neo and Trinity so quickly. I don't think that is a big leap. Two: that Neo reached out and attempted to communicate with the sentinals and the process overwhelmed both man and machine simultaneously. The other reason I feel this last scene has nothing to do with "a matrix in a matrix": In the trailer for Revolutions, we see "numerous" fight scenes played out in the matrix that we already know. All of these scenes appear to be pivotal fight scenes like in Reloaded. I think if Revolutions were going to reveal a matrix in a matrix, I don't think that new matrix level would simply duplicate terrain and similar action sequences that we've seen before in the matrix we already know. Also, I say again, matrix in a matrix would be a lazy move for the Wachowskis as writers. I don't think they are that lazy, I think they are more ambitious.
side note: Regarding posts about Asimov's robot laws being a part of the Matrix, i.e. "robots cannot kill man, they must serve man." NO. This can't be possible because we see robots kills millions of humans in the Animatrix short "Second Renaissance". This short was written by the Wachowskis. So no, the robots/machines/programs in The Matrix can indeed kill humans.
OH MAN! Some of these posts.... I think we are all getting a little too involved in anylising every single detail of the film and then speculating on it! For now we should just al stick to what we KNOW. As it stands I do not believe in what AL says about Neo waking up and it was al a dream. Thats is the sort of ending that would ruin the whole idea of the film. What we do know is that the game TheMatrixOnline was revealed on the 14th May which tells us that the game (which involves players interacting in the Matrix) will take place after the film trilogy. This means the MAtrix will still exist after Revolutions. TBC......
Many of you are arguing that Neo is a man/machine hybrid and hence he was taken out by an EMP that destroyed the sentinels at the end of Reloaded. Also Bane was knocked into a coma after the "mysterious" EMP that knocked out 5 hovercrafts at the counterattack. This all sounds well and good but you're forgetting something. At the end of The Matrix when the sentinels are attacking the Neb after Neo comes back to life and exits the matrix an EMP is triggered. This takes out the sentinels but Neo is perfectly fine to engage in some passionate kissing with Trinity. I think he did in fact stop the sentinels (probably due to a matrix-within-a-matrix) - it's far too similar to the bullet stopping to be coincedence. The over exertion cause his coma.
About Neo beeing a machine:i think it is , because at the beginig of the movie , when the three agents enter the door they say something like this:
agent 1:it's him!
agent2:the anomaly
agent1:do we proced?
agent2:yes
agent1:he is STILL...
agent 3:only human
What do you think about this?
Duffy said,
agent1:he is STILL...
agent 3:only human
EXACTLY. It is clear from the Revolutions trailer in which we see shocked reactions to Neo from Morpheus and Niobe in differenct scenes that indicate Neo has undergone yet another transformation or shown them something new. Neo has already flown at super sonic speeds, entered the body of an agent and blow it to pieces, etc. What else could possibly shock them about Neo at this point other than finding out that he isn't what they thought he was...not quite human.
Regarding Macca's post about the EMP, I must admit that I thought about this and it's a good point. The only thing I've come up with is that when that scene happens in Matrix 1, you'll notice that Trinity has her entire body wrapped around Neo's head protectively. Perhaps this difused the EMP's effects against Neo's brain somehow. Either way, I still think there is scant evidence to support a matrix in a matrix idea. Look at the trailer for Revolutions, it's clear that the playing fields remain the same. Something else changes, and I'm betting it is the role/profile of Neo. He will undergo a figurative/literal transformation. That transformation will reveal him to be a man/machine hybrid.
I can't say that my weight is firmly in the matrix-within-a-matrix corner. I'm kind of arguing that case because I feel its a valid one that people are dismissing too easily. Trinity blocking out the EMP from Neo? It's kind of clutching at straws. And also, say it was the real world and Neo was a machine how is he physically communicating the message to the sentinels? Has he got some radio transmitter in his brain? Wouldn't the crew of the Neb have picked this up? If any of Neo was physically machine I think it would have been noticed by the crew. If it was a human body but with his personality written in code (a la Bane) then he wouldn't have the necessary physical equipment for transmitting a message even if he was compatible in code with them. I've got the trailer for Revolutions on my PC and you're right, it doesn't show anything different or anything in a new world. Although we don't know just how similar this third world would be to either the Matrix or the Zion/Desert world. There is one thing which could indicate it though. The first shot of the trailer is Neo opening his eyes as if he is awakened (is this his first experience of the third world?). He doesnt have plugs in his arms, head etc but they might not need this just because they do in the programmed Zion/Desert world. And there is nothing in the trailer that shows Neo in the Zion world. Also if there were a big thing like this they wouldn't give it away in the trailer.
P.S. On another note the voice over of the trailer seems to be that of the new Oracle (the Oracle in her new "shell"). I hope she is as good as the old one as I thought the Oracle fitted the part superbly.
Macca,
This is getting good, BUT I have yet another, and believe or not, NEW PIECE OF INFORMATION that has not been discussed. It's so new, I'd call it a SPOILER for the "Matrix Revolutions", so read no further if you want to fresh eyes for the next film.
I just noticed in the trailer for Revolutions (the one provided with the game, not the one shown at the theaters) that Neo comes out of his coma BLIND. There is clearly shown a scene with Neo and Trinity piloting a ship. A group of sentinels come up for attack right in front of them. Trinity holds up Neo's hand and directs it at the sentinels which are immediately disabled with the same blue electrical EMP effect that we saw at the end of Reloaded. In this scene, Neo appears disoriented and is wearing a black blindfold. For me this proves several things. FIRST, the matrix in a matrix is not true, because if the "real world" were another matrix, Neo would not have such a lingering human failing as blindness. He could simply reinsert himself, reboot, and be healthy again. The blindness "proves" that they are in the real world. SECOND, Neo "does" have the power to stop sentinels, so he must be more than human. However irrational it sounds to you in a real world setting, the trailer proves it, and it does it in a way that "does not" support a matrix in a matrix notion. Neo is a man/machine hybrid, there is no other viable explanation for this sequence.
here's the llink to the trailer (again, not the one from the end of Reloaded, a different one).
http://www.movie-list.com/m/matrixrevolutions.shtml
the scene I'm referring to occurs right after Commander Lock's voice-over says, "In less than twelve hours the machines will reach the dock wall..." Neo may not be a literal cyborg (machine parts), or he may be, this part is unclear, but he is certainly part machine "in some way" (possibly, as I said before, just mentally).
Finally to explain your Matrix 1 idea that Neo would be vulnerable to EMP waves like the sentinals if he was indeed part machine, we now have an explanation that disputes this claim. At the end of Matrix 1, Morpheus activates the EMP, and then we see Neo open his eyes and kiss Trinity. And, at the end of Reloaded, Neo releases an EMP wave with his eyes wide open and looking at the sentinals. Thus he comes out of his coma blind. Apparently, Neo can only be affected by an EMP if it enters his brain via his eyes.
This would also go a long way towards explaining the ubiquitous use of shades in the matrix environment. No one seems to question why everyone who is a combatant wears shades in the matrix. Example: ALL the zion/human matrix visitors, ALL agents, the asian protector of the Oracle, the white dreadlock twins who work for merovingian, merovingian's other henchmen, etc., ALL of these people wear shades. Suddenly, when you think about it, it seems silly that "all" these characters would be wearing shades "just" for style. There must be something else to the shades that are worn by anyone who is a fighter. You'll notice that non-fighters never wear shades in the matrix. Example: the oracle, the architect, the keymaker, merovingian, persephone, etc. You might try to say this argues for "your" matrix in a matrix point, but I think it is simply an "eyes are the window to the soul" metaphor and says that anyone who is in a programmed environment, or relies on programming to function in the real world must protect their optic paths (eyes). The evidence for Neo being part machine, in some way, is becoming too large to refute.
Since seeing Reloaded 2 days ago, there's one thing I noticed in the movie that I can't find a reference to anywhere, except in Gilbert's message above. (By the way, I like your theory about food being used to integrate programs in the matrix):
Did anyone notice that the candy the Oracle offered Neo was one of those hot tamales wrapped in red foil, ie, the red pill? And he said "You already know if I'm going to take it or not" (he does, but doesn't eat it). Then she unpeels and eats her red pill, saying "I love candy," just before saying sadly "I must go now" etc, like she has to get out of there before the shit hits the fan. Then the dozens of Smiths show up. Anyone else notice this, and did anyone see what Neo did with his candy?
Also, I took the whole scene where Bane cuts himself as a sort of creepy blood-brother thing. He's crouching, waiting for Neo and the others, cuts his hand twice, then hides the knife. Then he hands something to Neo or shakes his hand - does anyone remember what happens here? I thought they shook hands, but if they had Neo would have noticed Bane's blood on his own hands. Then the kid comes up with the spoon, and Neo takes that. This is where I thought the whole Smith/Neo overlap came in -- Neo transferred something of himself to Smith when he killed him in the Matrix. Is this Smith's way of transferring part of himself to Neo via a human subtance - blood - rather than via a program, since he's in the "real"/human world of zion now. Not sure how this can transfer to Neo's ability to stop the sentinels and the multi-matrix theories.
Sorry, not too many answers at this late hour, but I wanted to know if anyone else caught these tidbits. Also, when Neo was in the tv room with the Architect, several times the camera focused on one of the screens, which then became the central room -- ie, we're never sure if we're looking at neo and the Architect in the tv room or at one of the screens themselves. Just curious, but did anyone notice how many times this flip happened? It would be interesting if it was 5 ... ie, what if the One has always been Neo, and he has made the wrong choice (ie, going for the door to save humanity) 5 times already. Each time they reload the program, he thinks he's living it for the 1st time, and this time what makes it different is that Trinity is involved, Neo is in love and that is enough to make him take the seemingly unethical risk of saving her life at the cost of human extinction. Someone said that Reeves said the 3rd movie was about love, etc -- perhaps it's a statement on the power of love/being in love as a mobilizing element, a catalyst for faith/hope/taking risks, etc.
yawn - let me know what you think.
I have a really intresting question that I am sere is on everyones minds. Who was the other survivor at the end of the movie who was in a coma with Neo. I heard that he is the guy that Agent Smith took his mind. And he told me that he tried killing Neo with a knife or something. This guy also said that his name might be "Bane" or something. I don't recall any of this but if you have ne idea who that guy was please e - mail me at T_gaffer41@hotmail.com
thank you
Neo isn't human anymore. In the same way that the man Agent Smith took over isn't human either.
I think this is what the architect was referring to when he says
[quote]The Architect - The matrix is older than you know. I prefer counting from the emergence of one integral anomaly to the emergence of the next, in which case this is the sixth version. [/quote]
The anomoly isn't the human being, it's part of the matrix. It's a peice of code, a program, in the same way that the agents and persephone are just programs. However, as it's taken over a human being (neo) it's still subject to hormones and emotions etc, and so to all appearances is still human. When Neo died, it wasn't Trinity's kiss that bought him back to life, it was this anomaly, that's why he now sees the matrix as code, he's a program himself.
[quote]The Architect - Your life is the sum of the remainder of an unbalanced equation inherent to the programming of the Matrix. You are the eventuality of an anomoly which, despite my sincerest efforts I have been unable to eliminate from what is otherwise a harmony of mathematical precision. Or that remains a burden asiduously avoided it is not unexpected and thus not beyond a measure of control, which has led you inexorably here.[/quote]
In the architects ideal Matrix, everything can be condensed into easily solvable equations. This mathematical precision creates the perfect world. However, in the perfect world there is no choice. Choice is the unbalanced equation. The Oracle is an example of this. She should now exactly what happens in the matrix. However, she is unable to predict choice. Which is why she only knows "enough"
[quote]The Architect - As you are undoubtedly gathering, the anomaly's systemic, creating fluctuations in even the most simplistic equations. [/quote]
The problem is, this code is able to destablise the matrix. In the same way that the world ripples when neo takes flight. If these things a left unchecked they could destroy the matrix. Which is what the architect needs to avoid.
[quote]The Architect - Thus, the answer was stumbled upon by another, an intuitive program, initially created to investigate certain aspects of the human psyche. [/quote]
This I'm sure is a reference to Persephone, her role was to investigate love. (humans don't choose who they fall in love? It has something to do with that)
[quote]The Architect - As I was saying, she stumbled upon a solution whereby nearly 99.9% of all test subjects accepted the program, as long as they were given a choice, even if they were only aware of the choice at a near unconscious level. While this answer functioned, it was obviously fundamentally flawed, thus creating the otherwise contradictory systemic anomaly, that if left unchecked might threaten the system itself. Ergo, those that refused the program, while a minority, if unchecked, would constitute an escalating probability of disaster. [/quote]
The first bit refers to how people know that there is something wrong with the world that they live in. Why they spend all their lives wondering What is the Matrix (like neo in the first film). Once they realise that the world is not real, they can start to bend the rules. However, this is the problem, when they start to bend and break the rules they risk destroying the matrix itself. The more people "freed" from the rules of this world = increasing probability of the matrix ending.
[quote]The Architect - The function of the One is now to return to the source, allowing a temporary dissemination of the code you carry, reinserting the prime program. After which you will be required to select from the matrix 23 individuals, 16 female, 7 male, to rebuild Zion. Failure to comply with this process will result in a cataclysmic system crash killing everyone connected to the matrix, which coupled with the extermination of Zion will ultimately result in the extinction of the entire human race. [/quote]
The first bit I think, refers to neo, needing to go back to the code of the matrix (after all, it’s just one giant program right?) I think the matrix needs to be reset here (this is what is meant by reinserting the prime program), just for a while. I'm pretty sure the 23 individuals and the council in Zion being 23 is not entirely uncoincadental. I believe they are either the people the previous “one” has rescued. (6 incarnations of the matrix, the year is roughly 2199 Nebuchadnezzar was built in 2069 which allows roughly 20-30 years between “ones” notice how everyone else in Zion is in their 30s?) Also this explains why they didn’t know about the previous Zion, they weren’t people who had been freed. That’s why they didn’t know about the previous one’s
[quote]The Architect - It is interesting reading your reactions. Your five predecessors were by design based on a similar predication, a contingent affirmation that was meant to create a profound attachment to the rest of your species, facilitating the function of the one. While the others experienced this in a very general way, your experience is far more specific. Vis-a-vis, love. [/quote]
This is why I don’t believe neo is human, or human anymore. This bit is annoying, they’ve deliberately used lots of long words to confuse people. But basically what he means is this. “Your five predecessors were human (at least to begin with, we believed that humans would feel the life of the many (people inside the matrix), far outway the life of the few (people in Zion) (ok, I stole that from startrek, but that’s what they mean). However, neo was falling in love with trinity, his body is still human and emotions are powerful things.
[quote] The Architect - Which brings us at last to the moment of truth, wherein the fundamental flaw is ultimately expressed, and the anomaly revealed as both beginning, and end. There are two doors. The door to your right leads to the source, and the salvation of Zion. The door to the left leads back to the matrix, to her, and to the end of your species. As you adequately put, the problem is choice. But we already know what you're going to do, don't we? [/quote]
The first bit is the architect refering to why he didn’t want flaws in the original matrix. You can’t base a system on a flaw and expect it to run perfectly. Neo will end this matrix and begin a new one. (ok, I’m jumping ahead of myself a bit, and there are things left that he still needs to do)
[quote]The Architect - Humph. Hope, it is the quintessential human delusion, simultaneously the source of your greatest strength, and your greatest weakness.
Neo - If I were you, I would hope that we don't meet again.
The Architect - We won't. [/quote]
The architect knows what will ultimately happen. Neo will destroy the current matrix and start again, probably as the new architect. This will be the revolution, and neo will be the new creator.
K? Everyone still with me?
Further explanations and themes
Why can Neo tell the future/feel what’s going on around the matrix?
The code that he carries is, or is part of the matrix. The human brain is just a very complex computer. Neo is able to see the myriad possibilities of the matrix the same way the oracle is and the architect on his screens. For neo this haunts him as nightmares. When he is in the matrix, the code he carries allows him to know what is happening, after all, he is a god in the machine. This also helps explain how neo can stop the machines. When he realises what he actually is. Part of the matrix, he realises he’s connected not only to the Matrix even when not plugged in, but by this he’s connected to all the machines as well.
(K, for this you still have to believe that neo is wireless)
Choice
How can the oracle know what’s going to happen if we have a choice? Simple, notice how the oracle will divine the future in one of 2 ways. Either a) “I’d ask you to take a seat but I know you’ll say no” telling them what will happen so it’ll become a self forfilling prophecy. If people believe she’s an oracle, they’ll listen to her. Or b) She’ll tell them they have a choice of things to do. “on the one hand you have the life of morpheus, and the other your own. She doesn’t now how people will choose, she is just able to see the many possibilities that the matrix will take.
Agent Smith
Well, any story needs a bad guy, and this is it. When smith became merged with neo at the end of the first film, he gained something, from the code neo was carrying. He can copy himself. Using up the natural resources (humans) of a given place. He’s a virus. Neo will have to destroy him when he wishes to reset the matrix. Programs are able to survive a reset of the matrix, he can’t let smith survive into his new world.
Morevignon
I have no fucking clue, I wasn't really paying attention in the cinema as I thought the film was rubbish. Anyone help?
The Agents
At first I couldn’t understand why agents existed. But they are a measure of control. The are designed to kill people who can break the rules of the matrix, and thus help prevent/delay the anomaly from appearing. This is why they tried to kill neo, even though neo is “the one” (he’s not the one until the anomaly appears. If the anomaly can be prevented from appearing the matrix can continue to exist)
Further Proof.
The original ending to The Matrix was altered slightly. The original shooting script has this:
[quote]"Hi. It's me. I know you're out there. I can feel you now. I imagine you can also feel me. You won't have to search for me anymore. I'm done running. Done hiding. Whether I'm done fighting, I suppose, is up to you. I believe deep down, we both want this world to change. I believe that the Matrix can remain our cage or it can become our chrysalis, that's what you helped me to understand. That to be truly free, truly free, you cannot change your cage. You have to change yourself. When I used to look out at this world, all I could see was its edges, its boundaries, its leaders and laws. But now, I see another world. A different world where all things are possible. A world of hope. Of peace. I can't tell you how to get there, but I know if you can free your mind, you'll find the way."[/quote]
So the matrix will still exist, and we’ll all be able to play the matrix online, yay!
You people seriously have to realize that it is a movie for entertainment puposes. It is almost comical to read some of these thoughts and impressions of the movie. What really fascinates me, is who are you people writing these posts. Are you educated? Are you brilliant? Or better yet, do you apply to yourself with the same enthusiasm you make these prudent explantions to better your life. Do you have good jobs? Do you have a girlfriends (because no girl is posting on this site)? I need to know who are you people, and why do you read so into a movie. Why dont you use your process of thought and come up with a way to make this world we live in (the real one), a better place for our fellow man. There is no such thing as the matrix, it is fantasy. The true genius turns fantasy into reality for the better of mankind. Keep that in mind as you disect the meaning of the matrix. Use your thought process for something meaningfull. Me, I am using my thought process to raise awareness to how ridiculous all of you sound... Watch the movie, enjoy the movie, dont live your life, or bring excitement into your life through a movie.. Live your own movie..... KR
The Matrix invokes one intrinsic thought within all of us who care to post deep and lengthy thoughts on this page, Brian. It has nothing to do with jaw-on-ground enthusiasm, nothing to do with our lack of girlfriends' (because according to brian, taking 5 minutes out of each day to respond to a forum OBVIOUSLY means you cannot manage a relationship) It has to do with the fact that in the end we really have no idea if choice, fate, free-will, or predestination even exist. We have no idea if the choices we make had to be made for some event to happen 5 yrs from now. The Matrix makes those who truly understand it take a step backwards...look around at the world...and question everything.
Ultimately, most people think, if only for one second, that their entire life is out of their control...IMAGINE if you were proven that it truly was?
Oh and you said, you wonder who we are I can at least show you who I am...
http://members.migente.com/bebegigante/
How can I put this...I agree with everything TruthBeTold said. Bravo. And to join in the fun, this is who I am (in one sense):
http://marsmag.com/adario.html
Brian
We're people. We're doing this because we enjoy it. Stretching our brains. Some people spend their entire lives pondering over a few statements made by Plato or Archimedes, and we call those people philosophers. Some people write books on what Shakespear really meant, other spend their lives working on obscure mathematical problems or physics problems. They're all working to solve a puzzle, just like we are.
We like the puzzle the W. Bros have left us, and we're trying to solve it.
It's simple. If you had half a brain you would have figured it out yourself.