May 1, 2003
Hilary Duff: Not a Girl But Not a Woman?


Fifteen year old industry, Hilary Duff, is featured in the second item of the Observer's New York World column. Why? Because her breasts are stopping men in their tracks. There is some debate about whether or not they are Duff's breasts, but the killer quote is from Elisa DeCarl: "My guess is that they are going for that all-important Humbert Humbert demographic," she said. "The audience will be 90 percent preteens and their parents, 10 percent shifty-looking older men in raincoats." Gothamist thinks shifty-looking older men's ages will start at, oh, 24.
Hilary Duff's official site...and the site for The Lizzie McGuire Movie.
Lynn Harris, who wrote the Observer item, also wrote a Gothamist favorite about guys who like Wilco.
Updated, August 28, 2003: Anil alerted me that we might have a COPPA violation with the kids who comment here, crazy crazy kids who decide to give our their home addresses, home phone numbers, email addresses, and AOL screennames. So Gothamist has closed the comedy gold that were the comments. We may republish them with all the information taken out as a glimpse into the insanity that is today's youth, but until we have an extra 10 hours...
Updated again: We're opening comments back up, while we decide what our next steps should be.




hey hil luv ya ur da coolest ever u r my role model!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ayo!! hilary your the best .. if u eva read this email me .. babychula720@hotmail.com .. plz //
hilary duff is so cool hilary could u email me or any1 email me newsletters about her at nmbr1fan@hotmail.com
Personally, Hillary Duff is not at ALL one of my fave. actresses of any kind. Ever notice that besides those pictures, she has NO boobs AT ALL! Like Britnay Spears except she can "remove" her talent.
ahahhaha OMG dude i g2 agree w/ Jennie. Hilary isn't that great of an actress i mean i aint hatein on her but.....oh n the singing all i can say is sweetie u an oh k actor but baby please don't sing!!!!!!! Jennie if yuh read this email me sumtimes!!! falconsgurl@hotmail.com
Yo Hilary, u r so phat grl, u just so pretty n cute, i love u grl, u no itd be kool if i could meet u in person, it'd be a dream come true, u no if u see this u can email me bak babes, GRL u got a HELLA HOT VOICE, screw wat people say
this is comin from the bottom of my heart. I think your the most beautiful woman in the world!!! I was wonderin, are you currently seein anybody right now? if not then can I be your boyfriend? e-mail me back with your answer.
Hey Hillary,
I absolutley love you
I was wondering if you could email me or something it would be a dream come true
It would be awsome if we could meet for real
Love you Hillary,
Tyler
xoxo
whats ur e-mail??
ur single? lets talk! e-mail me soon
Hilary, you are awsome. email me back @ Peter_Blanchet@hotmail.com
you guys, Hilary doesn't have time to come to this chats and if she does, she wouldn't give out her ad. I mean, c'mon she's an actress and she does a lot more out there, like work and other stuff, so plz. don't expect her to email all you guys. btw, I know her ad, but plz don't ask me for it. you may not believe but it's cool, I don't need anyone to believe me. laters
i wish you could read this i always bein a fan of your work. dont miss none of your show or movies,please e mail me.
hillary.... u look good. u can sing to. i thik your really hott. so is alexa vega but thats another story. i just wanna talk to u so email me back at jason12591@aol.com
can u call me i really want to get a chance to talk to u or to meet u in real life i hope u can call me.
Dear lizzie mcguire or hillary duff
hi lizzie how are you I want to know how I could talk to you could you call me i would really like to talk to you in real life after you get this massage could you call me at xxx-xxx-xxxx only call the xxx # after the 29 if it's befor then call xxx-xxx-xxx .I'm at my mom's in az but I live with my dad in or. I will be at my mom's till august 29th then i'll be back at my dad's you could email me at behvin10@hotmail.com please email or call .
Always/Danielle wedge
i love your music and your music.my name is christopher lee shepherd.age 13.june 3 1990.i;m starting a band soon it's not easy.i like your song but everbody take it the wrong way
how they see it and if they get mad at me so what.i hope you read this or if somebody is reading it please give it to hilary duff don't be mean.so thank you for reading this.
yes this is the same chris.i love animation but i do know that none of these notes are sent to hilary duff here is a song i have been working on. i can't!
she dying to hell fells like flying she need help for her soul she felt this way before.
rage take the plase of evil. for my sake make my fears go away.
shes crying over her body.she sit above and find me.she can't see love shes lying again.
ragethat the place of evil.for my sake make my fears go away.
thank you!!!! this song is called rage by christopher lee shepherd. age 13.2222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccoooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''tttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt
e-mail me at saimai330@yahoo.com.
hey hillary ive been a fan for awhile and you are realey hot so if you want email me whn ever
Hi Hilary my name is marcus,im 14 years old,i live in Fresno,California.Im a big fan of urs and i hope to meet u in real life.Ever since i first saw u in that show Lizzie Maguire i have been wishing that mayb somday ill meet u.I think about u alot.I think u are very beautiful and nice.U can email me at BlueFusion89@yahoo.com, email me anytime. Love Marcus
Hey Hilary its me again,i was wondering if u had aim cause i do.If u do have aim then i wanted to let u know that my screen name is xMaRkUs412x so put me on ur buddylist plz.If u can give me ur screen name when u email me.U remember my email address do u?Well if u forgot then here it is again BlueFusion89@yahoo.com,and if u dont want to email me then u could call me at xxx xxx-xxxx, my area code is 93705. Love Marcus
can tou email me please!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
hey hilary, ur pretty and all, but u have NO TALENT, your acting is ok... but its not great, and NEWS flash, YOUR SINGING SUX!!!! but u are a good role model to kids, u show them that even if you have no talent u can still be famous.. well as long as you have looks to back it up that is
britni I just read what u wrote, thanx about agreeing w/ me. I'll email u soon, I dont use "jennie" though.
Hilary ISNT ALL THAT!!
if any body have hilary duff email adderss can you plases give it me to and maybe we can be pen pals
hi i'm looking for hilary's own e-mail and not one off of the site. if anyone has an e-mail address for her please send it to matt.bridwell@cox.net. thanx a lot.
i want to be your friends please...............
i hope you email me at azaro_ny60@yahoo.com
Hey if you read this hilary email me @ leo1n2_6dem0n6stickdeath@hotmail.com
Luv ya work
hope all iz well with arron
Hey,if anybody knows hilary duff in person then can u please tell her to email me at BlueFusion89@yahoo.com cause i like her and i really want to meet her.She is so beautiful and nice.
hey hilary, i jus wanted to say that i luv yo movies
i jsut wnat to say that um hillary sux, i want to meet her in a dark alley so i could kill her! she is soooo fake and annoying i dont see HOW you guyz dont see it! she is SUCH a poser!! she can't sing! i have seen MUCH better actresses and um do you think her voice could get ANY higher and squeakier?! and NOW she is tryin to bust out on to like TRL and Mtv...HEY HILARY GO BACK TO YOUR DISNEY CRAP AND LEAVE THE REAL TALENT TO BE ON TRL!!!!!!!!!!!!
yo i think all you little punks who make fun of hilary should die because i think she is beautiful and one of the most hottest girls that are like in "the business" and alot of guys like her!!!so if you make fun of her again ill have to give you a little talking 2!!haha.well i love hilary and i want to marry her it is my life long dream.i am going to become famous meet hilary and marry her.haha i doubt its ever gonna happen because of "aaron carter" ill just have to fight him.hahaha!!!well see you all around my screen name is bROWNSOUNd41182 if you wanna talk to me lol bye.
oh yeah that screen name is for AIM
Hey Hilary I love you and that is the truth. I feel like I'm programed for you. You are very talented so don't waste it. Will you please give me your email address. Mine is BlckswrdMgc@aol.com. Could you also give me your phone number that would be great. Thanks and email me soon. Ryan
P.S.
You can call me Roy.
hey hil i love u when i first saw u i fell in love without even meeting u please email me at www.hen6st@aol.com
Hi hilary. If you read this i just wanted to say i herd your c.d. off of kazaa and i burned all of your songs of kazaa . When you get a chance if im not asking to much Could you please call me at 1-xxx-xxx-xxxx. Ok I think you are so pretty and when i first saw you i knew thin that something cliked with me and you. And ever since i saw you I told my mom that I wanted to meat you.
sorry for the other comment.
but if you can't call me please email me at ron454ss@yahoo.com
thanks .
sorry for the other comment.
but if you can't call me please email me at ron454ss@yahoo.com
thanks .
Hey Hill,
I hope you get a chance to call me sometime.
I would like to meet you in real life.
Where you live at?
My home address is:
xxx xxxxx xxxx
xxxxxx, PA
xxxxx
My number is xxx-xxx-xxxx
hey hilary you r the best actress . don't listen to those people that say the bad things about you. to me I think your the best. I wish I could meet you but i bet you have better things to do anyways. but if you read this e-mail me.
love ya
hey hil, also wanted to say that I have your CD and I thought it was realy good and think you have a realy pretty voice.
Here is my email address socool69usa@yahoo.com
hey i was just wondering if u can give me ur SN for aol so we can talk....or u can hit me at littledevildev66 to talk....wel it will be great to talk to u since ur very sexy...and im 15 also so it would be really go to meat u.......well lata....plz IM me ....
Hey this is Jacquelyn....look Hilary is a very pretty girl,but I'd be lying if I said she was a good actress,SHE IS NOT A GOOD ACTRESS,ESPECIALLY ON LIZZIE MCGUIRE!And look I'm not jealous or anything,I mean I listen to her sing,and I watch her videos,but what people don't know is Hilary can't really sing!She uses a machine that clears up her shaky voice,and that is true!But I don't know if this is true or not but her breasts look fake,it looks like she stuffs bra pads all up in there!Well,anyways...I guess it comes to show you can get by in the buisness with good looks AND BEING A CHEATER AND FAKE!
Note from the Editor: People - when commenting please press "Post" once - you don't need to press it multiple times. It just takes a while to load.
And please don't post your home addresses and phone number. I'm going to start to take them off. It's really not safe to list that information.
The train wreck that is this thread? Comedy gold.
Wesley, no kidding. I die a little each time I have to fix the repeated comments, let alone read them...
i so wan to have sex
sup,Hilary i love you and i hop u read this and can u like e mAil me sometime phuongtruong@prodigy.net
later hot sex girl
Is this thread a joke, or a true reflection of America's youth?
There's no wonder marketing is directed towards this demographic, crazy ravenous fans.
Regardless, as Wesley said, this is gold, pure gold.
Go all the way hill
ur doin great stuff
keep it up e-mail me sometin
-meg
Hilary Duff- No offense but i just dont like her. Im not jealous or anything but i dont see why everyone likes her so much, she's not that great. And i dont think she should be showing her stomache so much, she's not that pretty or skinny.ithink shes a little chubby and singing is not her talent. Go back to the disney channel Hilary! singing is for real stars. Also i think she puts on too much make-up.
Like I said I dont like her that much. But i guess she's kinda nice.
Hey Hillary,
My name is Aaron. I have a question for you. Are you still going out with Aaron Carter? If not, I would love to be your boyfriend. I know you probably get a ton of guys asking you to be there girlfriend. Trust me, I know how to treat a lady righ plus I don't base relationships completely on how the girl looks. Personality is VERY important also. But if you don't mind me saying so, you are so beautiful. Please e-mail me!
Aaron
hi...ur so cute..haha..i just wanna drop a line or two...soo..yeah..pls email me back because i really want to talk to you
Hey Hillary
i doubt ull ever get this far down the list but if u do i think it would be really kewl if u would email me at huskyboy26@hotmail.com
Peace
hey Hillary wats happenin. I just wanted to say your HOTT and will u please email me i would luv that!!!!i watch your show all the time. hope to get an emial from you soon
hey Hillary wats happenin. I just wanted to say your HOTT and will u please email me i would luv that!!!!i watch your show all the time. hope to get an email from you soon
Hilary I think u are the greatest and i mean this with all my heart you are the most amazing person in the world and you are so hot. I would love to meet you. Email me at jmimoun@the-beach.net. I hope to meet you one day i live im miami
xxx xxxxxxxx. or call me at xxx-xxx-xxxx.
Heheh I bet ELLs only talent is sucking cock all day long!
Hey hil,
I know everyone want your e-mail and stuff, but i would like to contact you and way to talk to you about your dream(singing, and acting). I have had the same dream sense i was 9, when my older bro(who is now 17) started watching music videos, thats when i started my dream. I have been looking for dizney channel try outs, but i cant find any, if u could talk to me about getting in that would be the best day of my life. peace-~always~your non obsessed fan ~josh Stillamn~
You are the most beutiful women in the hole entire universe and love you I hope I meet you some day I live in xxxxx California xxxx in grand call me if you arefilming any movies at point fermin my number is xxxxxxx.
all you little kids and your fantasies make me sick. i know hilary we hang out with a bunch of other people with lives.by the way to those guys who think they have a chance with hil dream on boys ill get freaky with her before you turn 18.face it little punks shes mine so i suggest you stick to your hand and jack yourself off out of your little fantasies by the time you meet her she will no longer be available.
much luv bros
i like my potatoes baked, you know with spices and stuff, i'm not big on french fries.
p.s. the x on the hand is for unity
dear Hilary, Don't listen to anybody that says you stink at singing cause they are wrong your voice is beatiful. But you wear too much make-up. you are beautiful with out it!
hi me again YOUR'E BEAUTIFUL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!PLEASE E-MAIL ME. I LOOK UP TO YOU SO MUCH!!!!!!!!! MY NUMBER IS xxx-xxxx PLEASE CALL!! BOYS IM SINGLE 15 YEARS OLD CALL ME!!
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHA JENNIE AND BRITNI U GUYS ARE SOOO STUPID UR JUST JEALOUS OF HILARY, SHE IS THE BEST AND IF U DON'T AGREE THEN I SUGGEST U SHOULD KEEP UR LITTLE MOUTHS SHUT AND KEEP IT TO URSELF FREAKS!!!!IM SURPRISED U GUYS EVEN HAVE ANY FRIENDS!!!
Im sorry to all of you who do not get an answer from Hilary becase she never comes to this site. I am a fan of Hilary and to all of you who talk bad about her you can just shuve it.